Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
The Father's Love and the Son's Straying 11:1–4
v. 1 — retrospect, father and son: when Israel was a boy → I loved him // out of Egypt I called my son (cf. Exod 4:22)
1
AWhen Israel was a boy,conditional — temporal כִּי, verbless, leaning forward: the speech opens in Israel's youth; נַעַר
I loved him,independent — וָאֹהֲבֵהוּ — love as the first act of the relationship
Band out of Egypt I called my son.independent — מִמִּצְרַיִם fronted; לִבְנִי — Matt 2:15 follows the Hebrew 'my son'; the LXX has 'I called his children'
v. 2 — the call and the flight: they called // so they went; to the Baals they sacrificed // to the images they burned offerings (objects fronted, iterative verbs)
2
AThey called to them;independent — obscure — the callers are unnamed (the prophets?); the LXX has the first person, 'as I called them'
Bso they went away from before them.independent — כֵּן — 'so much the more'; the LXX has 'from my face'
To the Baals they kept sacrificing,independent — לַבְּעָלִים fronted; iterative Piel yiqtol — habitual apostasy
and to the carved images they kept burning offerings.independent — synonymous member; יְקַטֵּרוּן with paragogic nun
v. 3 — the parent's care against the son's ignorance: I taught to walk // took them on the arms — but they did not know that I healed them
3
AYet it was I who taught Ephraim to walk,independent — emphatic וְאָנֹכִי against v. 2; תִרְגַּלְתִּי, a rare causative 'teach to walk'; the LXX has 'I bound Ephraim's feet'
taking them by his arms;phrase modifier — קָחָם — infinitive or a clipped 'I took them'; 'his arms' is difficult (many read 'my arms', with the LXX 'upon my arm')
Bbut they did not knowindependent — the book's charge of not knowing (2:10; 4:1, 6)
that I healed them.content — כִּי content clause; רָפָא, Hosea's healing theme (5:13; 6:1; 7:1)
v. 4 — gentle guidance: cords of a man // bands of love; then the image of the yoke lifted, and the stoop to feed
4
AWith cords of a man I drew them,independent — חַבְלֵי אָדָם — humane cords, not ropes for beasts; משׁך 'draw, lead'
with bands of love;independent — gapping — the verb carried over; אַהֲבָה answers אָדָם
and I was to themindependent — וָאֶהְיֶה — the image introduced
like those who lift the yoke upon their jaws;comparative — עֹל 'yoke' (the farmer easing it off the animal's jaws), or repointed 'infant' (a parent lifting a baby to the cheek); 4QXIIg preserves 'upon their jaws'; the LXX has 'like a man striking upon his cheeks'
Band I bent down to himindependent — וְאַט — from נטה 'bend' (or 'gently')
and fed him.independent — אוֹכִיל — the parent stooping to feed; the LXX has 'I shall prevail for him'
Judgment: Assyria, the Sword, Apostasy 11:5–7
v. 5 — judgment turning on שׁוּב: not return to Egypt // Assyria his king — because they refused to return
5
AHe shall not return to the land of Egypt,independent — crux — the MT negative stands against 9:3 ('Ephraim shall return to Egypt'); some read it as לוֹ 'to him' closing v. 4, or as a question; the LXX has 'Ephraim dwelt in Egypt', without a negative
but Assyria — he shall be his king,independent — casus pendens וְאַשּׁוּר הוּא; the LXX has 'Assyria itself is his king'
Bbecause they refused to return.cause — כִּי; the second שׁוּב — no return to YHWH, so no return home
v. 6 — the sword's three actions: whirl // make an end // devour (feminine weqatals), the cause in a colon of its own
6
AThe sword shall whirl in his cities,independent — וְחָלָה 'whirl, rage'; the LXX has 'grew weak', as from a different root
and make an end of his bars,independent — בַּדָּיו — gate-bars, or 'his boasters' / oracle-priests (cf. Isa 44:25); uncertain
and devour,independent — the third weqatal — the invasion completed
Bbecause of their counsels.phrase modifier — causal מִן; the atnach sets the cause apart as the second colon: their own policies between Egypt and Assyria
v. 7 — settled apostasy: bent on turning away // calling upward, but none exalts; a notorious crux
7
AMy people are bent on turning away from me;independent — disjunctive וְעַמִּי; תְלוּאִים 'hung on'; מְשׁוּבָה 'apostasy'; the LXX has 'his people are hanging from his dwelling'
Band to the Most High they call him,independent — very obscure: וְאֶל עַל 'to on high' (cf. 7:16), read as a title or emended (e.g. to 'Baal'); the LXX has 'God shall be angry over his precious things'
but none at all exalts him.independent — יַחַד לֹא יְרוֹמֵם — empty calling (cf. 6:1–3)
How Can I Give You Up? 11:8–9
v. 8 — divine soliloquy: four questions in two pairs, give up // hand over (Ephraim // Israel) and make like Admah // treat like Zeboiim (Deut 29:22); then heart overturned // compassion kindled
8
AHow can I give you up, O Ephraim?independent — אֵיךְ — sentence turns to anguish; 4QXIIg preserves this אֵיךְ
How can I hand you over, O Israel?independent — אֵיךְ gapped; מגן 'deliver up'; the LXX has 'shall I protect you?'
How can I make you like Admah?independent — the second אֵיךְ; Admah, a city destroyed with Sodom
How can I treat you like Zeboiim?independent — synonymous member; Zeboiim, the other sister city (Gen 14:2; Deut 29:22)
BMy heart is overturned within me;independent — נֶהְפַּךְ — the verb of Sodom's overthrow (Gen 19:25) turned inward: the overthrow happens in God, not to Ephraim; 4QXIIg preserves נֶהְפַּךְ and 'my heart'
my compassions grow warm together.independent — synonymous member: לִבִּי // נִחוּמָי; כמר 'grow warm' (cf. Gen 43:30); the LXX has 'my repentance was stirred'
v. 9 — resolve: not execute // not again destroy // not come in wrath, grounded in holiness: God and not a man, the Holy One in your midst
9
AI will not execute my burning anger;independent — the first negation — חֲרוֹן אַפִּי renounced
I will not again destroy Ephraim;independent — לֹא אָשׁוּב + infinitive 'not again' (or 'not turn back to destroy'); 4QXIIg preserves 'to destroy Ephraim' and the following כִּי, partly damaged
Bfor I am God and not a man,cause — כִּי — the ground; אֵל אָנֹכִי וְלֹא אִישׁ (cf. Num 23:19)
the Holy One in your midst,cause — the ground continued: holiness as mercy beyond human retaliation
and I will not come in wrath.independent — the third negation; crux בְּעִיר — 'in wrath' (from a root for agitation) or 'into a city', as the LXX reads (εἰς πόλιν)
The Lion's Roar and the Return Home 11:10–11
v. 10 — the return: after YHWH they walk; the lion's roar (judgment in 5:14) now calls home, he roars // he roars (staircase); sons come trembling from the west
10
AThey shall walk after YHWH;independent — YHWH spoken of in the third person; 4QXIIg seems to read 'after him', with the divine name written above the line (letters partly damaged); the LXX has 'I will go after the Lord'
like a lion he will roar;independent — כְּאַרְיֵה — the predator of 5:14 becomes the summoner (cf. Amos 3:8)
Bindeed he will roar,independent — כִּי הוּא — asseverative 'yes' (or temporal 'when he roars'); יִשְׁאַג repeated in a staircase
and sons shall come trembling from the west.independent — חרד — the awe of return (cf. 3:5); מִיָּם 'from the sea'; the LXX has 'children of waters shall be astonished'
v. 11 — homecoming: like a bird from Egypt // like a dove from Assyria (reversing 7:11), then settlement and the oracle formula
11
AThey shall come trembling like a bird from Egypt,independent — יֶחֶרְדוּ picked up from v. 10 — the fluttering of birds
and like a dove from the land of Assyria;independent — gapping; the 'silly dove' of 7:11 now flies home
Band I will settle them in their houses —independent — weqatal; the divine first person returns
declaration of YHWH.phrase modifier — oracle formula נְאֻם יְהוָה sealing the promise; 4QXIIg preserves the divine name here; the LXX has 'says the Lord'