Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Proverbs 19 — clausal layoutמשלי יט

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentpurposecausecomparativeconditionaldashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

Integrity, haste, and folly 19:1–3

v. 1 — comparative 'better … than': the poor man of integrity // the crooked-lipped fool (doublet of 28:6, where the foil is the rich man)

1
ABetter a poor man who walks in his integrityindependent — טוֹב fronted; the participle הוֹלֵךְ makes integrity a way of walking
Bthan one crooked of lips, and he a fool.comparative — the 'than' member — מִן on עִקֵּשׁ; וְהוּא כְסִיל, a circumstantial tail: crooked speech and folly together. The Rahlfs LXX has no vv. 1–2

v. 2 — synonymous: desire without knowledge // haste of the feet; not good // misses the mark (גַּם links it to v. 1)

2
AAlso, desire without knowledge is not good,independent — verbless — נֶפֶשׁ as 'drive, appetite'; בְּלֹא דַעַת fronted
Band one who hurries with his feet misses the mark.independent — participles אָץ and חוֹטֵא — 'sin' in its root sense of missing the target; the walking of v. 1 continues

v. 3 — synthetic: cause // reaction; folly overturns the way, then the heart rages at YHWH

3
AA man's folly overturns his way,independent — gnomic yiqtol תְּסַלֵּף; דַּרְכּוֹ picks up the walking and feet of vv. 1–2
Band against YHWH his heart rages.independent — וְעַל יְהוָה fronted for the irony: the fool blames the God he never consulted. The LXX reads 'in his heart he blames God' (τὸν δὲ θεὸν αἰτιᾶται)

Wealth, friends, and false witness 19:4–7

v. 4 — antithetic: wealth // the poor man; many friends gained // his one friend lost (opens the friendship cluster, vv. 4, 6–7)

4
AWealth adds many friends,independent — הוֹן fronted — an observation, not an endorsement
Bbut the poor man is separated from his friend.independent — וְדָל fronted for the contrast; niphal יִפָּרֵד; רֵעִים רַבִּים // רֵעֵהוּ, many friends // his one

v. 5 — synonymous: false witness // one who breathes out lies; not unpunished // not escape (repeated in v. 9)

5
AA false witness will not go unpunished,independent — the law court — עֵד שְׁקָרִים (cf. Deut 19:16–21); niphal לֹא יִנָּקֶה
Band one who breathes out lies will not escape.independent — יָפִיחַ כְּזָבִים, the lying witness of 6:19 and 14:5; לֹא יִמָּלֵט answers לֹא יִנָּקֶה

v. 6 — synonymous: many // everyone; the generous man // the man of gifts; courting favour // being a friend

6
AMany seek the favor of a generous man,independent — יְחַלּוּ פְנֵי, 'they stroke the face of' — court a patron; the LXX has 'the faces of kings' (πρόσωπα βασιλέων)
Band everyone is a friend to a man of gifts.independent — verbless — הָרֵעַ with the article: the 'friend' belongs to the gift; picks up the friends of v. 4

v. 7 — a fortiori (אַף כִּי) tricolon: brothers // friends, hate // keep far; then an obscure third line (the only three-line verse of the chapter)

7
AAll the brothers of a poor man hate him;independent — שְׂנֵאֻהוּ, 'reject'; even the closest kin; develops v. 4b
Bhow much more do his friends keep far from him!independent — אַף כִּי — lesser to greater: if brothers, surely friends; the atnach falls here, after the second line
CHe chases after them with words, but they are gone.independent — obscure — participle מְרַדֵּף; Kethiv לא 'not (there)' and Qere לוֹ 'his' both stand in the text. Probably the remnant of a lost couplet: the LXX has two extra couplets here, the last ending ὃς δὲ ἐρεθίζει λόγους οὐ σωθήσεται

Sense, restraint, and the king 19:8–12

v. 8 — synonymous: one who gets sense // one who keeps discernment; loves his own life // will find good

8
AOne who gets sense loves his own life;independent — participle subject קֹנֶה לֵּב, 'acquires a heart' — the call to 'get wisdom' (4:5–7)
Bone who keeps discernment will find good.independent — לִמְצֹא טוֹב — infinitive with לְ as predicate: he is bound to find good

v. 9 — synonymous; a near-doublet of v. 5, with only the last verb changed

9
AA false witness will not go unpunished,independent — identical to v. 5a
Band one who breathes out lies will perish.independent — יֹאבֵד replaces לֹא יִמָּלֵט — the sanction sharpened. The LXX keeps colon A but reads 'whoever kindles evil will perish by it'

v. 10 — a fortiori (אַף כִּי): luxury for a fool // a slave ruling princes; unfitting // how much less

10
ALuxury is not fitting for a fool;independent — verbless — לֹא נָאוֶה fronted, תַּעֲנוּג held to the end
Bhow much less for a slave to rule over princes!independent — the predicate gapped after אַף כִּי; the world upside down (cf. 30:21–22)

v. 11 — synonymous: insight that lengthens anger // the glory of passing over an offense

11
AA man's insight makes him slow to anger,independent — qatal of general truth — הֶאֱרִיךְ אַפּוֹ, 'lengthens his nose': patience. The LXX reads 'a merciful man is patient' (ἐλεήμων ἀνὴρ μακροθυμεῖ)
Band it is his glory to pass over an offense.independent — verbless — תִפְאַרְתּוֹ fronted, the infinitive עֲבֹר as its content; forbearance against the rage of vv. 3 and 12

v. 12 — antithetic with emblematic similes (the king): a lion's growl // dew on the grass; his rage // his favor

12
ALike the growl of a young lioncomparative — the image first — נַהַם כַּכְּפִיר; the colon recurs as 20:2a
 is a king's rage,independent — the referent — זַעַף מֶלֶךְ; זַעַף echoes יִזְעַף of v. 3
Bbut like dew on the grasscomparative — the counter-image — dew that gives life (cf. 16:15, his favor as a spring cloud)
 is his favor.independent — the referent — רְצוֹנוֹ answers זַעַף; the LXX keeps both similes (βρυγμῷ λέοντος … δρόσος ἐπὶ χόρτῳ)

Household and sloth 19:13–15

v. 13 — synthetic: two household troubles side by side; a foolish son // a quarrelsome wife, ruin // a continual dripping

13
AA foolish son is ruin to his father,independent — verbless — הַוֺּת fronted, an intensive plural: 'calamities'
Band a wife's quarrels are a continual dripping.independent — verbless — דֶּלֶף טֹרֵד, the leaking roof (again 27:15). The LXX has a different line here: vows (εὐχαί) paid from a courtesan's wages are not pure

v. 14 — antithetic: inheritance from fathers // a gift from YHWH; house and wealth // a prudent wife (the answer to v. 13b)

14
AHouse and wealth are an inheritance from fathers,independent — verbless — what passes by human descent
Bbut a prudent wife is from YHWH.independent — וּמֵיְהוָה fronted for emphasis; מַשְׂכָּלֶת, the counterpart of the quarrelsome wife. The LXX reads 'from God a wife is fitted to a husband' (παρὰ δὲ θεοῦ ἁρμόζεται γυνὴ ἀνδρί)

v. 15 — synthetic (the lazy man): laziness brings deep sleep // the slack soul goes hungry; effect // eventual result

15
ALaziness casts into a deep sleep,independent — hiphil תַּפִּיל; תַּרְדֵּמָה, the stupor of Gen 2:21. The LXX reads 'cowardice seizes an effeminate man'
Band a slack soul will go hungry.independent — נֶפֶשׁ רְמִיָּה, cf. the slack palm of 10:4; hunger is where the sleep ends

Commandment, generosity, discipline, and anger 19:16–19

v. 16 — antithetic: keeping the commandment // despising one's ways; keeps his life // will die

16
AOne who keeps the commandment keeps his life;independent — the same participle שֹׁמֵר in both senses: keep the command, keep the life
Bone who despises his ways will die.independent — בּוֹזֵה דְרָכָיו — his own conduct (or YHWH's ways); Kethiv יומת 'will be put to death' and Qere יָמוּת 'will die' both stand in the text

v. 17 — synthetic (wealth and poverty; YHWH's sovereignty): the loan to YHWH // YHWH's repayment

17
AWhoever is gracious to the poor lends to YHWH,independent — nominal clause — מַלְוֵה יְהוָה fronted as predicate: the giver is YHWH's creditor (contrast 14:31). The LXX: δανίζει θεῷ, 'lends to God'
Band he will repay him his deed.independent — גְּמֻלוֹ fronted; piel יְשַׁלֶּם, 'repay in full': YHWH stands surety for the poor

v. 18 — admonition with a motive, then a limiting prohibition: discipline your son // do not set your desire on his death

18
ADiscipline your son,independent — piel imperative יַסֵּר — the household theme (cf. vv. 13, 26–27)
 for there is hope;cause — motive — כִּי יֵשׁ תִּקְוָה: while he is young and teachable
Bbut do not set your desire on his death.independent — crux — a limit on punishment ('do not lift your soul to killing him'), or a warning that neglect brings his death (cf. 23:13–14); וְאֶל הֲמִיתוֹ fronted. The LXX reads 'do not be lifted up in your soul to insolence' (εἰς δὲ ὕβριν)

v. 19 — synthetic with a conditional motive (anger): the hot-tempered man bears his fine // bailing him out only starts it over

19
AOne great of wrath bears the penalty;independent — Kethiv גרל ('rough'?) and Qere גְּדָל ('great') both stand in the text; עֹנֶשׁ, a fine
Bfor if you rescue him,conditional — כִּי אִם — the motive put as a condition; leans forward on the line below
 you will only have to do it again.independent — apodosis — וְעוֹד תּוֹסִף, 'and you will add again': the rescuer caught in a cycle

Human plans and YHWH's counsel 19:20–23

v. 20 — admonition with purpose: listen // accept, counsel // discipline (the catchword עֵצָה leads into v. 21)

20
AListen to counsel and accept discipline,independent — paired imperatives שְׁמַע … וְקַבֵּל; עֵצָה // מוּסָר
Bso that you may be wise in your latter end.purpose — לְמַעַן + yiqtol; בְּאַחֲרִיתֶךָ — wisdom as the end of teachability. The LXX adds the father: 'listen, son, to your father's instruction'

v. 21 — antithetic (YHWH's sovereignty): many plans // one counsel; a man's heart // YHWH (cf. 16:1, 9)

21
AMany are the plans in a man's heart,independent — verbless — רַבּוֹת fronted: the many
Bbut it is the counsel of YHWH that will stand.independent — casus pendens resumed by הִיא — YHWH's counsel and it alone; תָקוּם. The LXX adds 'forever' (εἰς τὸν αἰῶνα μένει)

v. 22 — synthetic, with a 'better … than' second colon: what is desired in a man // better poor than a liar (echoes v. 1)

22
AWhat is desired in a man is his loyalty,independent — verbless; crux — תַּאֲוַת אָדָם, 'what people desire in a man' or 'a man's desire'; with חֶסֶד II 'shame', 'a man's greed is his disgrace'
Band better a poor manindependent — וְטוֹב — the better-than form of v. 1 again, with the same רָשׁ
 than a liar.comparative — the 'than' member — מֵאִישׁ כָּזָב. The LXX reads 'a righteous poor man than a rich liar' (πτωχὸς δίκαιος ἢ πλούσιος ψεύστης)

v. 23 — synthetic (YHWH's sovereignty): the fear of YHWH leads to life // that life spelled out as a safe night's lodging

23
AThe fear of YHWH leads to life;independent — verbless — לְחַיִּים, 'is for life'
Bone rests satisfied and is not visited by harm.independent — שָׂבֵעַ יָלִין, 'he lodges for the night sated'; בַּל יִפָּקֶד רָע, asyndetic. The LXX differs: 'the fearless man will lodge in places where knowledge is not visited'

Sluggard, scoffer, and shameful son 19:24–29

v. 24 — synthetic satire (the sluggard), climax with גַּם: his hand in the dish // not even back to his mouth (near-doublet 26:15)

24
AThe sluggard buries his hand in the dish;independent — qatal טָמַן of the typical case; עָצֵל, the comic type
Bhe will not even bring it back to his mouth.independent — גַּם אֶל פִּיהוּ fronted — 'not even to his mouth'. The LXX reads 'hides his hands unjustly in his bosom'

v. 25 — synthetic, graded: strike the scoffer // reprove the discerning; the simple learn by watching, the discerning by being told (cf. 21:11)

25
AStrike a scoffer,independent — yiqtol תַּכֶּה with the object fronted — virtually conditional: 'when you strike a scoffer'
 and the simple will become shrewd;independent — the result — not the scoffer but the onlooker learns
Breprove a discerning man,independent — וְהוֹכִיחַ — a word is enough for him
 and he will understand knowledge.independent — the result — יָבִין דָּעַת. The LXX reads 'when a pestilent man is flogged, a fool becomes shrewder'

v. 26 — synthetic: two acts against the parents // the verdict, a son who shames (the reverse of the wise son, 10:1)

26
AOne who assaults his father and drives away his motherindependent — two participles — מְשַׁדֶּד, יַבְרִיחַ: violence against both parents; the subject of the verbless clause
Bis a son who brings shame and disgrace.independent — the predicate — בֵּן מֵבִישׁ וּמַחְפִּיר, a pair of hiphil participles (cf. 10:5)

v. 27 — ironic admonition: stop listening // only to stray (the chapter's only 'my son')

27
AStop listening to discipline, my son,independent — imperative חֲדַל + infinitive, the vocative בְּנִי inside the colon
Bonly to stray from the words of knowledge.purpose — infinitive לִשְׁגוֹת — ironic purpose or result: listening that only leads astray is no listening. The LXX reads 'a son who ceases to keep a father's instruction will meditate on evil sayings'

v. 28 — synonymous: a worthless witness // the mouth of the wicked; mocks justice // swallows iniquity (the false witness of vv. 5, 9)

28
AA worthless witness mocks justice,independent — עֵד בְּלִיַּעַל; יָלִיץ from the root of לֵץ (vv. 25, 29). The LXX has a different line ('whoever goes surety for a foolish child insults justice')
Band the mouth of the wicked swallows iniquity.independent — יְבַלַּע — wrongdoing gulped down like food

v. 29 — synonymous, the verb gapped: judgments // blows, scoffers // fools (with v. 25, a frame of scoffers)

29
AJudgments are prepared for scoffers,independent — niphal qatal נָכוֹנוּ fronted — already set in place
Band blows for the backs of fools.independent — gapping — נָכוֹנוּ carried over; מַהֲלֻמוֹת, beatings
Analysis. Proverbs 19 continues the first Solomonic collection (10:1–22:16), and the page keeps the shape of a sentence-proverb chapter: each verse is a self-contained saying, laid out as colon A and colon B flush at the margin, divided at the atnach (the chapter has no ole-weyored). The gold label over each verse names its form, and the balance has shifted away from the antithetic sayings of chs. 10–15. Only five sayings are antithetic (vv. 4, 12, 14, 16, 21). Eight are synonymous (vv. 2, 5, 6, 8, 9, 11, 28, 29), and ten are synthetic, where the second colon carries the first one forward to a consequence, a result or a comment (vv. 3, 13, 15, 17, 19, 22–26). The rest are a 'better … than' saying (v. 1, echoed in v. 22b), two a fortiori sayings with אַף כִּי (vv. 7, 10), and three admonitions (vv. 18, 20, 27). Indentation marks real subordination only: the 'than' members of vv. 1 and 22, the motive 'for there is hope' (v. 18), the conditional 'for if you rescue him' (v. 19), and the purpose clauses of vv. 20 and 27. The sections follow the chapter's own clusters: the poor man and his vanishing friends (vv. 4, 6–7) around the false witness (vv. 5, 9, repeated almost verbatim), the king (v. 12), the household of son and wife (vv. 13–14, 18, 26–27), the lazy man and the sluggard (vv. 15, 24), and YHWH's sovereignty over human folly, plans and charity (vv. 3, 14, 17, 21, 23). Verse 7 is the one tricolon, and the one place where the labels do not follow the atnach alone: it falls after the second line, and the third line (Kethiv לא / Qere לוֹ) reads like the remnant of a lost couplet. Where Kethiv and Qere both stand in the text (vv. 7, 16, 19), they share one line. Cruxes the layout takes a side on: v. 18b is read as a limit on punishment ('do not set your desire on his death'); v. 19b as a conditional motive (כִּי אִם, 'for if'); v. 22a as 'what is desired in a man is his loyalty'; v. 27 as ironic ('stop listening … only to stray'). The Rahlfs Greek has no vv. 1–2 and longer text at v. 7, and several of its cola differ; those differences are noted in the tags.