Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Job 36 — clausal layoutאיוב לו

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentrelativepurposecausecontentconditionalphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

The frame 36:1

Elihu's fourth speech (36:1–37:24) — the last of his four; headed 'continued', not 'answered'

1
 And Elihu continued and said:independent — speech heading — וַיֹּסֶף … וַיֹּאמַר, 'he added and said' (the only Elihu speech so introduced; cf. 34:1; 35:1 'answered'); the speech runs to the end of ch. 37

Elihu asks a further hearing 36:2–4

vv. 2–4 — bid for a hearing: request + purpose (v. 2a), motive (v. 2b), resolve (v. 3), self-commendation (v. 4)

2
ABear with me a little,independent — imperative — Aramaizing diction: כַּתַּר 'wait, bear with' and זְעֵיר 'a little' are the Aramaic words
 and I will show you;purpose — weyiqtol after an imperative — purpose/result; אֲחַוֶּךָּ, Aramaizing חוה Piel 'declare' (cf. 32:6, 10, 17)
Bfor there are still words on God's behalf.cause — כִּי — the motive, verbless: עוֹד לֶאֱלוֹהַּ מִלִּים, Elihu as God's advocate

v. 3 — synonymous resolves: knowledge carried 'from afar' // righteousness ascribed to 'my Maker'

3
AI will carry my knowledge from afar,independent — אֶשָּׂא דֵעִי — knowledge fetched from far off (a wide source, or from above); רָחוֹק returns in v. 25
Band to my Maker I will ascribe righteousness.independent — לְפֹעֲלִי fronted — God named by a participle of פָּעַל; the speech's announced aim, the vindication of God

v. 4 — the ground: my words are true // a perfect knower is with you

4
AFor truly my words are not falsehood;cause — כִּי אָמְנָם — causal + asseverative, grounding vv. 2–3; verbless
Bone perfect in knowledge is with you.cause — verbless — תְּמִים דֵּעוֹת, Elihu of himself; the near-identical phrase is used of God in 37:16 (תְּמִים דֵּעִים), an irony the book may intend

The mighty God instructs by affliction 36:5–15

v. 5 — the thesis, הֶן: God mighty // mighty in understanding (climactic repetition of כַּבִּיר)

5
ABehold, God is mighty and does not despise;independent — הֶן — the argument proper begins; 'despise' has no object (the Old Greek supplies τὸν ἄκακον, 'the innocent')
Bmighty in strength of understanding.independent — verbless — כַּבִּיר repeated and specified: כֹּחַ לֵב, power joined to discernment

v. 6 — antithetic: the wicked not kept alive // justice given to the afflicted

6
AHe does not keep the wicked alive,independent — the retributive principle Elihu shares with the friends
Bbut he grants justice to the afflicted.independent — object fronted — וּמִשְׁפַּט עֲנִיִּים; the עֲנִיִּים are the subject of vv. 8–15

v. 7 — tricolon (ole-weyored, then atnach): his eyes on the righteous → enthroned with kings → exalted

7
AHe does not withdraw his eyes from the righteous;independent — negated yiqtol — God's watchfulness, the counterpart of v. 6a; the break falls after עֵינָיו (ole-weyored)
Band with kings on the throne —independent — fronted phrase, completed by the next colon; 4QJob^a reads ב כסא, 'on the throne', for MT לַכִּסֵּא; 11Q10 paraphrases 'with kings sitting on [their thrones]' (למלכין יתבי)
Che seats them forever,independent — wayyiqtol of a general truth — וַיֹּשִׁיבֵם, the suffix now plural: the righteous as a class
 and they are exalted.independent — wayyiqtol — the result; יִגְבָּהוּ, height for the humbled

vv. 8–10 — conditional sentence: the righteous in bonds (protasis, v. 8) → God discloses their sin and opens their ear (apodosis, vv. 9–10, wayyiqtols)

8
AAnd if they are bound in fetters,conditional — וְאִם — protasis; passive participle אֲסוּרִים, captivity as the image of affliction
Bcaught in cords of affliction,conditional — the protasis continues — yiqtol with paragogic nun יִלָּכְדוּן; חַבְלֵי עֹנִי
9
Athen he declares to them their deedsindependent — apodosis — wayyiqtol וַיַּגֵּד after a conditional protasis: suffering as disclosure
Band their transgressions,independent — object continued — פָּעֳלָם // פִשְׁעֵיהֶם
 that they have behaved arrogantly.content — כִּי content, epexegetic of the transgressions under the verb of declaring — Hitpael of גבר, self-exaltation as the hidden fault; 11Q10 'that they exalted themselves' (ארו התרוממו)
10
AHe opens their ear to disciplineindependent — apodosis continued — וַיִּגֶל אָזְנָם, 'uncovers their ear' (revelation idiom, cf. 33:16); מוּסָר, the key word of Elihu's theology of suffering
Band saysindependent — wayyiqtol — the frame of the instruction
 that they must turn back from iniquity.content — כִּי content, indirect speech — the call to repent; 11Q10 makes it a condition, 'if they turn from their evil' (הן יתובון מן באישתהון)

vv. 11–12 — the paired conditionals: 'if they listen' // 'but if they do not listen' — full days // death without knowledge (the two ways)

11
AIf they listen and serve,conditional — אִם — protasis of the positive case; the ole-weyored closes it (on וְיַעֲבֹדוּ)
Bthey will complete their days in prosperityindependent — apodosis — יְכַלּוּ יְמֵיהֶם בַּטּוֹב
Cand their years in pleasantness.independent — gapping — the verb carried over; days // years, good // pleasantness
12
ABut if they do not listen,conditional — וְאִם לֹא — the antithetic protasis, answering v. 11 word for word
 by the sword they will pass away,independent — apodosis — crux: שֶׁלַח 'weapon, missile' or 'the Channel' of the underworld (33:18); 11Q10 'by the sword they will fall' (בחרבא יפלון); the Old Greek rewrites the verse ('the ungodly he does not save, because they were unwilling to know the Lord')
Band they will perish without knowledge.independent — כִּבְלִי דָעַת — the charge Elihu laid against Job (34:35; 35:16) becomes the epitaph of the unteachable

vv. 13–14 — the godless: their character (v. 13) // their fate (v. 14)

13
AThe godless in heart lay up anger;independent — חַנְפֵי לֵב — 'store up' resentment, or incur God's anger
Bthey do not cry for helpindependent — the contrast with the afflicted righteous, who cry out under discipline
 when he binds them.conditional — כִּי temporal, following its clause — אֲסָרָם picks up אֲסוּרִים (v. 8)
14
ATheir soul dies in youth,independent — jussive-form תָּמֹת with indicative force — an early death
Band their life among the cult prostitutes.independent — gapping, verbless — קְדֵשִׁים (Deut 23:18), a byword for a dissolute, short life; the Old Greek has 'wounded by angels', and 11Q10 has '[their ci]ties by slayers' (…דינתהון בממתין)

v. 15 — the section's thesis, chiastic: rescue by affliction // the ear opened by oppression; wordplay עָנִי … בְעָנְיוֹ

15
AHe rescues the afflicted by his afflictionindependent — בְּ instrumental — affliction is the means of rescue; 11Q10 'and he delivers' (ויפרק); the Old Greek takes the verse quite otherwise ('because they afflicted the weak')
Band opens their ear through oppression.independent — וְיִגֶל … אָזְנָם — closes the bracket opened in v. 10

Warning to Job 36:16–21

vv. 16–21 — application to Job: the most obscure lines in Elihu's speeches; MT followed, alternatives flagged

v. 16 — from the narrow 'mouth of distress' to a broad place and a rich table (or: lured by plenty)

16
AAnd indeed he lured you out of the mouth of distressindependent — crux — הֲסִיתְךָ 'he enticed you': rescue (a past or 'prophetic' perfect, 'he would draw you') or a charge that prosperity lured Job; מִפִּי צָר, the narrow mouth; 4QJob^a preserves מ פי צר רחב as MT
 into a broad place where there is no constraint;phrase modifier — elliptical — רַחַב לֹא מוּצָק תַּחְתֶּיהָ, 'a breadth, no narrowness beneath it'; the Old Greek reads 'abyss' and 'outpouring'
Band what is set on your table is full of fatness.independent — verbless — נַחַת שֻׁלְחָנְךָ, the laden table of restored prosperity (or of the indulgence that seduced)

v. 17 — reproach: full of the wicked's case → judgment seizes you (דִּין repeated)

17
ABut you are full of the judgment due the wicked;independent — crux — דִּין רָשָׁע מָלֵאתָ: Job has taken up the wicked's cause, or brought on their sentence; the Old Greek has a single different line
Bjudgment and justice take hold of you.independent — דִּין וּמִשְׁפָּט — the consequence; יִתְמֹכוּ 'they grasp'

v. 18 — warning: wrath/abundance // the ransom (crux)

18
ABeware of wrath,independent — crux — כִּי חֵמָה: 'for wrath …' (God's, or Job's own), or an Aramaizing 'beware' (Aramaic חמא 'see'); either way a warning
 lest it entice you into scoffing;purpose — פֶּן — negative purpose; יְסִיתְךָ echoes v. 16 הֲסִיתְךָ; crux סָפֶק, 'abundance' (enticed by plenty) or 'mockery'
Band let not the greatness of the ransom turn you aside.independent — אַל + jussive — כֹּפֶר: the price of Job's suffering (cf. 33:24), or a bribe; the Old Greek turns the verse into wrath on the ungodly who take gifts

v. 19 — rhetorical question: no resource avails (crux)

19
AWill your cry for help avail, apart from distress,independent — crux — יַעֲרֹךְ 'be ranged, avail'; שׁוּעֲךָ 'your cry' or 'your wealth'; לֹא בְצָר 'not in distress' or 'not gold ore' (בֶּצֶר, 22:24); 4QJob^a has ה יערך, as MT
Bor all the exertions of strength?independent — gapping, verbless — מַאֲמַצֵּי כֹחַ, a hapax (4QJob^a has the same מאמצי כח)

v. 20 — prohibition: do not long for the night (crux)

20
ADo not long for the night,independent — אַל + jussive — 'the night' of death or of judgment; perhaps aimed at Job's death-wish (ch. 3)
Bwhen peoples go up from their place.phrase modifier — לְ + infinitive qualifying 'the night' — לַעֲלוֹת 'to go up', i.e. vanish; תַּחְתָּם 'in their place'; sense disputed

v. 21 — closing warning + charge

21
ATake care, do not turn to iniquity,independent — imperative + prohibition — הִשָּׁמֶר; אָוֶן echoes v. 10
Bfor this you have chosen rather than affliction.cause — כִּי עַל זֶה — Job has preferred protest (or iniquity) to accepting affliction; מִן comparative; alternatively 'for because of this you have been tried by affliction'

God the incomparable teacher 36:22–26

The hymn begins (36:22–37:24) — two הֵן theses (vv. 22, 26) frame questions and a call to praise

v. 22 — thesis + rhetorical question: exalted in power // unrivalled as teacher

22
ABehold, God is exalted in his power;independent — הֶן — a new unit (cf. vv. 5, 26); 4QJob^a has the longer [ה]נה
Bwho is a teacher like him?independent — rhetorical question, verbless — מוֹרֶה ties the hymn to vv. 8–15: the God who teaches by affliction; the Old Greek has δυνάστης 'ruler'

v. 23 — two rhetorical questions: no one sets his way // no one can accuse him

23
AWho has appointed his way for him,independent — rhetorical question — פָקַד עָלָיו דַּרְכּוֹ, no one prescribes God's course
Band who can say,independent — the second question — 4QJob^a reads יאמר (yiqtol) for MT אָמַר
 'You have done wrong'?content — quoted accusation — פָּעַלְתָּ עַוְלָה, the charge Job's complaints imply; 4QJob^a spells פעלתה

vv. 24–25 — call to praise: magnify his work // all humankind beholds it, from afar

24
ARememberindependent — imperative — זְכֹר: instead of accusing, praise
 to magnify his work,content — כִּי + yiqtol as the object of 'remember' — תַשְׂגִּיא answers יַשְׂגִּיב (v. 22)
Bof which men have sung.relative — אֲשֶׁר on פָעֳלוֹ — שֹׁרְרוּ from שִׁיר 'sing', or from שׁוּר 'behold'; 11Q10 takes it so ('which they have seen', די חזו); the Old Greek has ἦρξαν
25
AAll humankind has gazed upon it;independent — כָּל אָדָם חָזוּ בוֹ — universal witness
Bman beholds it from afar.independent — אֱנוֹשׁ // אָדָם; מֵרָחוֹק — the limit of human sight, echoing Elihu's knowledge 'from afar' (v. 3) and preparing v. 26

v. 26 — the hymn's thesis: God great and unknown // his years unsearchable (הֶן אֵל as in v. 22)

26
ABehold, God is great,independent — verbless — הֶן אֵל שַׂגִּיא
 and we do not know him;independent — וְלֹא נֵדָע — 4QJob^a has ניד[ע], apparently passive, 'he is not known'
Bthe number of his years is unsearchable.independent — verbless — מִסְפַּר שָׁנָיו וְלֹא חֵקֶר, God's eternity; 11Q10 'the number of his years, which has no end' (ומנין שנוהי די לא סוף)

Rain, cloud and lightning 36:27–33

The storm hymn begins — rain (vv. 27–28), the thunder-cloud (vv. 29–30), the storm's double purpose (v. 31), lightning (vv. 32–33); it runs on into ch. 37

vv. 27–28 — the rain cycle: drops drawn up → distilled → poured down

27
AFor he draws up the drops of water;independent — כִּי explicative — grounds v. 26 across the section break; גָּרַע 'draw off', נִטְפֵי מָיִם
Bthey distill as rain from his mist,independent — crux — יָזֹקּוּ 'refine, distill' (4QJob^a ו זקו with the copula); לְאֵדוֹ 'from/for his mist' (אֵד, Gen 2:6), uncertain; 11Q10 'and gusts of rain go' (וזיקי מטר יהכן)
28
Awhich the skies pour down;relative — אֲשֶׁר on מָטָר — שְׁחָקִים 'skies, clouds'
Bthey drip abundantly upon mankind.relative — asyndetic continuation of the relative — יִרְעֲפוּ; רָב 'abundantly' or 'many' (11Q10: 'on a great people', עם סגיא); the Old Greek adds a long plus on beasts knowing their lairs

vv. 29–30 — the thunder-cloud: who can understand it? // lightning above, the sea's roots below (merism)

29
AIndeed, can anyone understand the spreadings of the cloud,independent — rhetorical question, אַף אִם — מִפְרְשֵׂי עָב, the spreading storm-cloud; 11Q10 'from the spreading' (מן פרס)
Bthe thunderings of his pavilion?independent — gapping, verbless — תְּשֻׁאוֹת 'crashings' (thunder); סֻכָּה, the cloud as God's booth (Ps 18:12); the Old Greek has 'the evenness of his tent'
30
ABehold, he spreads his light around him,independent — הֵן — פָּרַשׂ answers מִפְרְשֵׂי: lightning spread over the cloud; the Old Greek has the unexplained ηδω for 'his light'
Band the roots of the sea he covers.independent — object fronted — שָׁרְשֵׁי הַיָּם, the sea's depths; height // depth, the whole cosmos

v. 31 — the storm's double purpose: judgment // provision

31
AFor by these he judges peoples;independent — כִּי — בָם 'by these' (the storm's elements); יָדִין 'judges' is often emended to יָזוּן 'nourishes', but the Old Greek κρινεῖ and 11Q10 (בהון ידין) both read 'judges'
Bhe gives food in abundance.independent — asyndetic — לְמַכְבִּיר, 'in abundance' (כַּבִּיר, v. 5): the same rain destroys and feeds

vv. 32–33 — lightning as weapon; the storm announces him (v. 33 a crux)

32
AWith his hands he covers the lightning,independent — עַל כַּפַּיִם כִּסָּה אוֹר — the lightning held in his palms (אוֹר as in v. 30); 4QJob^a keeps only a stray אם
Band commands it to strike the mark.independent — וַיְצַו — crux בְמַפְגִּיעַ: 'against the target' or 'as one who strikes' (פגע)
33
AHis thunder declares concerning him;independent — crux — רֵעוֹ 'his thunder' (רוּעַ) or 'his friend' (the Old Greek φίλον); 4QJob^a reads רעיו; 11Q10 has a verb of telling (…שיח על…)
Bthe cattle also, concerning what rises.independent — verbless, opaque — מִקְנֶה 'cattle' sensing the storm, or repointed מְקַנֵּא 'zealous'; עוֹלֶה 'what rises' or עַוְלָה 'iniquity' (the Old Greek περὶ ἀδικίας)
Analysis. Elihu's fourth and last speech (chs. 36–37), the only one headed וַיֹּסֶף 'and he continued' rather than 'answered': no one has spoken since 35:16, and Elihu simply goes on. The prose heading (v. 1) is a narrative frame in a short section of its own; the poem below it runs flush-left as the mainline, indenting only real subordination: protases, causal and content clauses, relatives and quoted words. Colon labels follow the poetic accents. Where the ole-weyored is the main break (vv. 7, 11) the B colon starts after the word carrying the yored, and the atnach then makes a third colon; elsewhere B starts after the atnach. The speech has two halves. The first is argument (vv. 2–21): a bid for a hearing in heavily Aramaizing Hebrew (vv. 2–4); the thesis that the mighty God despises no one (v. 5); and the doctrine of discipline (vv. 5–15). There a conditional sentence (vv. 8–10: 'if they are bound in fetters … then he declares to them their deeds … and opens their ear to discipline') is followed by the paired conditionals of vv. 11–12, 'if they listen … but if they do not listen', the two ways of life and death, laid out with each protasis one step in from its apodosis. A portrait of the godless (vv. 13–14) leads to the thesis line of v. 15, 'he rescues the afflicted by his affliction'. The application to Job (vv. 16–21) is among the most obscure passages in the book. The layout follows the Masoretic text and flags each crux in its tag rather than smoothing it: v. 16 (lured into distress or out of it?), v. 17, v. 18 (חֵמָה 'wrath' or 'beware'; סָפֶק 'abundance' or 'scoffing'; כֹּפֶר), v. 19 (שׁוּעֲךָ 'cry' or 'wealth'; בְצָר 'distress' or 'gold ore'), v. 20. The second half is hymn (v. 22 to 37:24). Two הֵן theses frame it: 'Behold, God is exalted in his power; who is a teacher like him?' (v. 22) and 'Behold, God is great, and we know him not' (v. 26). Between them come rhetorical questions and a call to praise, and after them the storm hymn begins: rain distilled from mist, the thunder-cloud as his pavilion, lightning held in his hands. It runs on without a break into ch. 37. Witnesses: 4QJob^a (4Q99) preserves much of vv. 7–33 with the consonants of MT, and its small differences are noted where they bear on a line (vv. 7, 22, 23, 26, 27, 33). The Qumran Targum (11Q10, cols. 28–29) covers vv. 7–33 in Aramaic paraphrase; it confirms 'by the sword' (v. 12) and 'he judges' (v. 31), and reads שֹׁרְרוּ as 'have seen' (v. 24). The Old Greek is often far from MT here (vv. 5, 12, 14–21, 28 with a long plus). The meteorological lines (vv. 27–33) carry several rare words: אֵד 'mist', שְׁחָקִים 'skies', תְּשֻׁאוֹת 'crashings', מַפְגִּיעַ, and the opaque v. 33.