Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Job 35 — clausal layoutאיוב לה

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentparticipialrelativecausecontentconditionaldashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

The frame 35:1

Elihu's third speech (ch. 35) — to Job, with the friends in view (v. 4)

1
 Then Elihu answered and said:independent — speech heading — the dialogue formula again (34:1); no reply from Job intervenes. The poem below is one speech

Job's claim restated 35:2–3

vv. 2–3 — disputation: question + two quotations of Job (cf. 34:5, 9)

2
ADo you think this to be just?independent — court term — לְמִשְׁפָּט; הֲזֹאת points forward to the quotation
BYou say,independent — asyndetic אָמַרְתָּ — the quotation formula
 'My righteousness is greater than God's.'content — verbless — crux: צִדְקִי מֵאֵל comparative ('more than God'), or 'I am in the right before God' (Old Greek 'righteous before the Lord')
3
AFor you ask,independent — כִּי — the second quotation formula
 'What advantage does it bring you?content — יִסְכָּן — the Aramaizing verb of 34:9 (cf. 22:2); 'you' may be God addressed, or Job in indirect speech; pausal לָךְ
BWhat do I gain more than if I had sinned?'content — comparative מֵחַטָּאתִי — piety pays no better than sin (9:22; 21:15); Old Greek 'what shall I do after sinning?'

God beyond human reach 35:4–8

vv. 4–5 — announcement of rebuttal + imperatival appeal to creation: heavens // clouds

4
AI will answer you with words,independent — fronted אֲנִי — Elihu supplies the answer the friends failed to give; מִלִּין, the Aramaic plural
Band your companions with you.independent — verb gapped — רֵעֶיךָ, the three friends now among the corrected
5
ALook at the heavens,independent — imperative הַבֵּט
 and see;independent — וּרְאֵה — second imperative
Band behold the clouds,independent — וְשׁוּר — Job's verb 'behold', which returns in vv. 13–14
 which are higher than you.relative — asyndetic relative, comparative מִמֶּךָּ — God's transcendence (11:7–8; 22:12)

vv. 6–7 — paired conditionals: if you sin → what to him? // if your sins are many → what to him? // if you are righteous → what do you give him? (Job's 7:20 turned)

6
AIf you have sinned,conditional — protasis, forward-leaning — אִם חָטָאתָ
 what do you accomplish against him?independent — rhetorical question — after Job's 'if I sin, what do I do to you?' (7:20)
Band if your transgressions are many,conditional — second protasis, without particle — weqatal וְרַבּוּ in conditional sense; 11Q10 …ובסגיא עויתך מא ת…, 'and in the multitude of your iniquities, what (will you do)'
 what do you do to him?independent — rhetorical question — the same answer: nothing
7
AIf you are righteous,conditional — the counter-case — צָדַקְתָּ, Job's claim
 what do you give him?independent — rhetorical question — Eliphaz's argument (22:2–3) renewed; 11Q10 preserves מא תתן לה או מא מידך יקבל, as the MT
Bor what does he receive from your hand?independent — God takes no bribe of piety

v. 8 — conclusion, verbless synonymous: wickedness // righteousness touch only a fellow human

8
AYour wickedness is for a man like yourself,independent — verbless — לְאִישׁ כָּמוֹךָ fronted; 11Q10 has חטיך 'your sin'
Band your righteousness for a son of man.independent — verbless — בֶן אָדָם // אִישׁ; 11Q10 ולבר אנש צדקתך, as the MT

Why cries go unanswered 35:9–13

v. 9 — synonymous, chiastic: from oppression → cry // call for help ← from the arm of the mighty

9
ABecause of the multitude of oppressions people cry out;independent — Job's own observation granted (24:12); hiphil יַזְעִיקוּ
Bthey call for help because of the arm of the mighty.independent — piel יְשַׁוְּעוּ // יַזְעִיקוּ; 11Q10 …עקון יצוחון מן קדם סגיאין, 'they cry, they shout because of the many'

vv. 10–11 — the prayer no one prays, quoted: God my Maker, in hymnic participles

10
ABut no one says,independent — וְלֹא אָמַר — the cry for relief is not a seeking of God; 11Q10 ולא אמר
 'Where is God my Maker,content — verbless — אַיֵּה, the seeker's question; עֹשָׂי plural in form ('my Makers'); 11Q10 …אלהא די עבדנה, 'God who made us'
Bwho gives songs in the night,participial — participle נֹתֵן — crux: זְמִרוֹת 'songs', or 'strength, protection' (a second root); Old Greek 'night watches'; 11Q10 ודי חלק לנא … בליליא, 'who apportions to us … in the night'
11
Awho teaches us more than the beasts of the earth,participial — מַלְּפֵנוּ — contracted piel participle of the Aramaizing verb אלף 'teach' (33:33); crux: מִן comparative, or 'through the beasts' (12:7); 11Q10 די פרשנא מן בע…, 'who separated us from the beasts', like the Old Greek
Band makes us wiser than the birds of the heavens?'participial — yiqtol יְחַכְּמֵנוּ continuing the participle; the quotation ends; 11Q10 …צפריא חכמנה

vv. 12–13 — the unanswered cry and the rule behind it: El // Shaddai, hear // regard

12
AThere they cry out,independent — שָׁם — 'there', in that plight, resuming v. 9; 11Q10 תמה יזעקון ולא…
 but he does not answer,independent — וְלֹא יַעֲנֶה — Job's complaint of the silent God (19:7; 30:20)
Bbecause of the pride of evil men.cause — crux: attaches to 'he does not answer' (the criers' own pride) or to 'they cry out' (under the oppressors' arrogance); Old Greek 'because of the arrogance of evil men'; 11Q10 preserves …אות and …אישין
13
ASurely God does not hear an empty cry,independent — אַךְ — שָׁוְא fronted, the insincere cry; 11Q10 ארו שוא יש…; Old Greek a different text
Band Shaddai does not regard it.independent — יְשׁוּרֶנָּה — שׁוּר again; אֵל // שַׁדַּי as in 34:10, 12

Application to Job 35:14–16

v. 14 — a fortiori: how much less when you say … (Job's complaints quoted, 23:8–9; 13:18)

14
AHow much less when you sayindependent — אַף כִּי — the a fortiori; 'will he hear' carried over from v. 13; 11Q10 הן תאמר, 'if you say'
 that you do not see him,content — asyndetic content — לֹא תְשׁוּרֶנּוּ, Job's 'I do not see him' (23:8–9; 9:11)
Bthat the case is before him,content — verbless — court term דִּין, the case laid out (13:18; 23:4); crux: or Elihu's own advice, 'the case is before him, so wait'
 and you are waiting for him!content — polel וּתְחוֹלֵל — waiting in anguish for the hearing

vv. 15–16 — ground → verdict: forbearance misread, so Job's words are breath (34:35; 38:2)

15
AAnd now, since his anger has not punished,conditional — causal clause leaning forward on v. 16 — וְעַתָּה כִּי; crux: אַיִן פָּקַד, awkward ('there is none that his anger has visited')
Band he has not taken much note of folly,conditional — crux: פַּשׁ, a hapax — 'folly, arrogance' from context; Old Greek παραπτώματι 'transgression', as if פֶּשַׁע
16
Atherefore Job opens his mouth in vain;independent — the verdict — fronted וְאִיּוֹב; הֶבֶל, breath
Bhe multiplies words without knowledge.independent — בִּבְלִי דַעַת — 34:35, and YHWH's 38:2; מִלִּין and the Aramaizing יַכְבִּר 'multiply'; 4QJob^a preserves בלי דעת מלין, as the MT
Analysis. Elihu's third and shortest speech, laid out by cola. As on the other Job pages, the prose heading (v. 1) stands in a short section of its own and the poem runs flush-left at depth 0; only real subordination and speech quoted inside the poem are indented. The speech is a disputation in four moves. First Elihu quotes Job (vv. 2–3: 'My righteousness is greater than God's'; 'What do I gain more than if I had sinned?'), each claim nested under 'you say' / 'you ask'. Then the answer (vv. 4–8): look at the heavens, then two paired conditionals (vv. 6–7), each protasis indented over its rhetorical question (if you have sinned → what to him? and if your transgressions are many → what to him? // if you are righteous → what do you give him?), concluding in the verbless cola of v. 8: sin and righteousness touch only other human beings. Third, the cry of the oppressed (vv. 9–13): they cry out, but no one asks 'Where is God my Maker …?' (the unspoken prayer nested under 'says', its hymnic participles one level further in), and so the cry goes unanswered 'because of the pride of evil men' (v. 12). Last, the application to Job (vv. 14–16), an a fortiori: how much less when you say …; the causal clauses of v. 15 lean forward on the verdict of v. 16, 'Job opens his mouth in vain; he multiplies words without knowledge', which echoes 34:35. The page follows the accents throughout. Cruxes flagged, not resolved: צִדְקִי מֵאֵל, 'more than God' or 'before God' (v. 2); the shift from 'you' to 'I' in the quotation of v. 3; the plural עֹשָׂי and זְמִרוֹת 'songs' or 'strength' (v. 10); comparative or instrumental מִן in v. 11; the attachment of 'because of the pride of evil men' (v. 12: to 'they cry out' or to 'he does not answer'; the page hangs it on the latter); the syntax of v. 14; and the hapax פַּשׁ and the awkward אַיִן פָּקַד (v. 15). Aramaisms noted in the tags: יִסְכָּן 'profit' (v. 3), the plural מִלִּין (vv. 4, 16), מַלְּפֵנוּ 'who teaches us' (v. 11, from אלף) and יַכְבִּר 'multiplies' (v. 16). The Old Greek is checked line by line (v. 3 'what shall I do after sinning?', v. 10 'night watches', v. 11 'who marks us off from the beasts', vv. 13–14 a different text). The Aramaic Targum 11Q10 covers vv. 6–15 in part; it has 'who made us' (v. 10) and, with the Old Greek, 'who separated us from the beasts' (v. 11). 4QJob^a (4Q99) preserves בלי דעת מלין of v. 16, as the MT.