Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
The frame 34:1
Elihu's second speech (ch. 34) — to the wise men (vv. 2–15), to Job (vv. 16–33), back to the wise (vv. 34–37)
1
Then Elihu answered and said:independent — speech heading — the dialogue formula (cf. 32:6; 35:1; 36:1); no reply from Job intervenes. The poem below is one speech
Summons to the wise 34:2–4
vv. 2–4 — call to hear, synonymous: wise // knowing, hear // give ear; ground (12:11 quoted) and proposal
2
AHear my words, you wise men;independent — vocative חֲכָמִים — the jury: the friends, bystanders, or an ideal court; מִלַּי, the Aramaizing word for 'words'
Band you who know, give ear to me.independent — יֹדְעִים // חֲכָמִים — the second imperative of the call
3
AFor the ear tests words,cause — כִּי — Job's own proverb (12:11) quoted back; מִלִּין, Aramaic plural
Bas the palate tastes food.cause — emblematic — the comparison lies in the juxtaposed cola, not in a particle (12:11 has 'and')
4
ALet us choose for ourselves what is right;independent — cohortative — מִשְׁפָּט fronted: the verdict the court must select
Blet us know among ourselvesindependent — second cohortative — a shared deliberation
what is good.content — object clause, verbless — מַה טּוֹב
Job's words on trial 34:5–9
vv. 5–6 — the charge sheet: Job quoted (27:2; 13:18; 6:4) — I am right // God took my right
5
AFor Job has said,independent — כִּי — the case opens; the quotation formula
'I am in the right,content — court term — צָדַקְתִּי, Job's claim (13:18)
Band God has taken away my right;content — 27:2 almost verbatim — 'El has taken away my right'
6
Ain spite of my right I am counted a liar;content — crux: עַל concessive; אֲכַזֵּב piel 'I am made a liar' or 'must I lie?'; Old Greek third person 'he has lied in my judgment'
Bmy wound from his arrow is incurable,content — verbless — חִצִּי, lit. 'my arrow' (the arrow in me): God's archery (6:4; 16:13); אָנוּשׁ, incurable
though I am without transgression.'phrase modifier — circumstantial, verbless — בְלִי פָשַׁע; the quotation ends. 11Q10 begins here: …מן חטא, 'from sin'
vv. 7–8 — censure of the speaker: rhetorical question + relative portrait (15:16; Ps 1:1)
7
AWhat man is like Job,independent — exclamatory question, verbless
Bwho drinks scorn like water,relative — asyndetic relative — Eliphaz's 'who drinks iniquity like water' (15:16) with לַעַג 'scorn' for עַוְלָה
8
Awho travels in company with the workers of iniquity,relative — weqatal וְאָרַח continuing the relative; פֹּעֲלֵי אָוֶן, the psalms' evildoers
Band walks with men of wickedness?relative — infinitive וְלָלֶכֶת continuing the finite verb — guilt by association; Old Greek 'who has not sinned … yet has shared the road'; 11Q10 ומתחבר לעבדי שקרא, 'who joins the doers of falsehood'
v. 9 — the second quotation: piety does not pay (cf. 9:22; 21:7–15; taken up in 35:3)
9
AFor he has said,independent — כִּי — the ground of the censure
'It profits a man nothingcontent — יִסְכָּן — 'be of use', a rare, Aramaizing verb (22:2; 35:3); a conclusion Job never states in these words; 11Q10 ארו אמר לא ישנא גבר, 'for he said, it makes no difference to a man'
Bwhen he is pleasing to God.'conditional — temporal — בְּ + infinitive בִּרְצֹתוֹ; Old Greek 'there will be no visitation of a man from the Lord'
Far be it from God to do wrong 34:10–15
vv. 10–12 — thesis: tricolon call + oath (God // Shaddai, wickedness // wrong), ground (retribution), restatement
10
ATherefore, you men of understanding, listen to me:independent — לָכֵן — the thesis; vocative אַנְשֵׁי לֵבָב, 'men of heart'; no atnach — the break after the ole-weyored
Bfar be it from God to do wickedness,independent — exclamation, verbless — חָלִלָה, 'a profanation!': injustice in God is a sacrilegious thought; 11Q10 …ס לאלהא מן שקר, '(far be it) from God to lie'
Cand from Shaddai to do wrong.independent — gapped — לָאֵל // וְשַׁדַּי, מֵרֶשַׁע // מֵעָוֶל
11
AFor according to a man's work he repays him,independent — כִּי — the ground: the doctrine of recompense, פֹּעַל … יְשַׁלֶּם
Band according to a man's way he makes it find him.independent — synonymous — אֹרַח // פֹּעַל; יַמְצִאֶנּוּ, the deed 'finds' its doer
12
ATruly God does not act wickedly,independent — אַף אָמְנָם — emphatic; Bildad's question (8:3) as flat assertion
Band Shaddai does not pervert justice.independent — יְעַוֵּת מִשְׁפָּט — Bildad's very words; the Old Greek turns the verse into a question, and so does 11Q10: הכען צדא אלהא ישקר, 'is it true that God would lie?'
v. 13 — rhetorical questions, synonymous: earth // world — no one appointed God
13
AWho entrusted the earth to him,independent — crux: פָקַד עָלָיו, 'appointed over him' or 'entrusted to him'; the directional אָרְצָה is odd; Old Greek 'who made the earth?'; 11Q10 likewise ארעא עבד וקשט, '(he) made the earth and established (the world)'
Band who laid upon him the whole world?independent — שָׂם — object תֵּבֵל כֻּלָּהּ; the answer 'no one': God is no delegated governor
vv. 14–15 — conditional: if God withdrew his breath → all flesh would die (Gen 2:7; 3:19; Ps 104:29)
14
AIf he were to set his heart upon himself,conditional — protasis, forward-leaning — crux: יָשִׂים … לִבּוֹ 'set his heart' (often emended to יָשִׁיב 'take back'); the MT is kept
Band gather to himself his spirit and his breath,conditional — protasis continued — רוּחוֹ וְנִשְׁמָתוֹ: God's breath, lent to every creature; 11Q10 …תה עלוהי יכלא, '(his breath) he withholds from him'
15
Aall flesh would perish together,independent — apodosis — יִגְוַע כָּל בָּשָׂר
Band humankind would return to dust.independent — Gen 3:19; Job's own 10:9 — so the Creator has no motive for injustice
The impartial ruler 34:16–20
v. 16 — call to hear, now to Job (singular): conditional + two imperatives
16
AIf you have understanding,conditional — protasis, verbless — crux: בִּינָה noun ('if there is understanding') or imperative 'understand!'; Old Greek 'if he does not admonish'
hear this;independent — apodosis — singular שִׁמְעָה: Job addressed
Bgive ear to the sound of my words.independent — הַאֲזִינָה — מִלָּי once more
vv. 17–18 — disputation: rhetorical questions, then a fortiori from the human king
17
ACan one who hates justice govern?independent — הַאַף — חָבַשׁ, 'bind up', here 'rule'; government presupposes justice
BOr will you condemn the Righteous, the Mighty One?independent — court term — תַּרְשִׁיעַ, declare guilty; צַדִּיק כַּבִּיר, God
18
AIs it fit to say to a king,independent — crux: MT הַאֲמֹר, interrogative infinitive; Old Greek ὁ λέγων 'the one who says' (= הָאֹמֵר), making God the one who rebukes kings
'Worthless!'content — the insult — בְּלִיָּעַל
Bor 'Wicked!' to nobles?independent — verb gapped — the second insult, רָשָׁע, and its addressee on one line
vv. 19–20 — God's impartiality: princes // rich over poor — ground in creation; sudden judgment (tricolon of collapse)
19
Awho does not show partiality to princes,independent — relative אֲשֶׁר, set flush-left: no antecedent in view — 'he who' (God, v. 17); with the Old Greek reading of v. 18 it hangs on 'the one who says'; נָשָׂא פְּנֵי, lift the face
nor regard the rich above the poor,independent — the relative continued — נִכַּר — recognize, favour; שׁוֹעַ, a rare word for the noble or rich
Bfor they are all the work of his hands.cause — verbless — rich and poor alike God's handiwork (Prov 22:2)
20
AIn a moment they die,independent — רֶגַע — the swiftness of judgment
and at midnight a people is shaken and passes away;independent — וַחֲצוֹת לָיְלָה — the hour of the Exodus plague (Exod 12:29)
Band they remove the mighty,independent — impersonal plural — the agent unnamed
not by a human hand.phrase modifier — verbless — לֹא בְיָד, by no human agency (Dan 2:34; 8:25); Old Greek goes its own way in vv. 19–20
The all-seeing judge 34:21–30
vv. 21–22 — omniscience: ways // steps (31:4), darkness // deep gloom — no hiding place
21
AFor his eyes are upon the ways of a man,independent — כִּי — verbless; Job's own words turned (31:4)
Band he sees all his steps.independent — synonymous — צְעָדָיו // דַּרְכֵי
22
AThere is no darkness and no deep gloomindependent — double אֵין — צַלְמָוֶת (10:21–22; Ps 139:11–12)
Bwhere the workers of iniquity can hide themselves.purpose — לְ + infinitive — 'for the workers of iniquity to hide there'
vv. 23–25 — no hearing needed: summary judgment and replacement of the powerful
23
AFor he does not set a man any further timeindependent — כִּי — crux: עוֹד 'further', often emended to מוֹעֵד 'appointed time'; the Old Greek ἔτι supports the MT
Bto go before God in judgment.purpose — court term — בַּמִּשְׁפָּט: Job's longed-for trial (13:3; 23:3–7) is not needed
24
AHe shatters the mighty without investigation,independent — יָרֹעַ — Aramaic רעע 'shatter' (Hebrew רצץ); court term — לֹא חֵקֶר, no inquiry required; 11Q10 …בין די לא סוף ויקים א…, '(princes) without end, and he raises up others'
Band sets others in their place.independent — wayyiqtol continuing the general present; Old Greek 'the one who seizes incomprehensible things'
25
ATherefore he knows their deeds,independent — לָכֵן, summarizing; מַעְבָּדֵיהֶם — an Aramaic-type noun, a biblical hapax; 11Q10 uses the same Aramaic root, …ם עבדהון
Band he overturns them in the night,independent — weqatal; לַיְלָה adverbial, recalling v. 20
and they are crushed.independent — וְיִדַּכָּאוּ — the end of the powerful
vv. 26–28 — public punishment, its ground (apostasy) and result (the cry of the poor heard)
26
AAs wicked men he strikes them,independent — crux: תַּחַת רְשָׁעִים 'as wicked' or 'in the place of the wicked'; סְפָקָם, a slap (cf. v. 37); no atnach — break at the revia
Bin a place where others see,phrase modifier — בִּמְקוֹם רֹאִים — punishment as public spectacle
27
Abecause they turned aside from following him,cause — אֲשֶׁר עַל כֵּן — compound causal
Band gave no heed to any of his ways,cause — fronted object וְכָל דְּרָכָיו; הִשְׂכִּילוּ
28
Aso that they brought to him the cry of the poor,purpose — result infinitive לְהָבִיא — their oppression sends the cry up to God
Band he hears the cry of the afflicted.independent — yiqtol יִשְׁמָע — against Job's complaint that God ignores the cry (24:12); 11Q10 preserves מסכנין וקבילת ענין ישמע, as the MT
vv. 29–30 — the sovereign's silence: two conditional questions + negative purpose (tentative; very obscure)
29
AWhen he keeps quiet,conditional — protasis, forward-leaning — וְהוּא יַשְׁקִט; or 'when he grants rest' (hiphil)
who then can condemn him?independent — court term — יַרְשִׁעַ, declare guilty
BWhen he hides his face,conditional — protasis — the hidden face, Job's complaint (13:24)
who then can behold him?independent — יְשׁוּרֶנּוּ — שׁוּר again (33:14); 11Q10 …ר אנפוהי מן יתיבנה, 'when he hides his face, who can turn him back?'
Cwhether it concerns a nation or a single person alike —phrase modifier — elliptical — attachment unclear: to the questions, or forward to v. 30
30
Aso that a godless man should not reign,purpose — crux: privative מִן + infinitive, negative purpose; the anchor uncertain. Old Greek 'he makes a hypocrite king because of the people's perversity'; no atnach — break at the revia
Bnor that there be snares for the people.purpose — verbless — מִמֹּקְשֵׁי עָם, compressed; 11Q10 …אנש רשיעיא התקלו, 'wicked men are ensnared'
Verdict on Job 34:31–37
vv. 31–32 — the model confession, quoted (tentative): borne // not offend, teach me // not again
31
AFor has anyone said to God,independent — הֶאָמַר — question introducing the speech a chastened sinner ought to make; no atnach — break at the revia
'I have borne my punishment;content — נָשָׂאתִי — the object unstated (punishment? guilt?); 11Q10 …תו לה איחל, 'for him I will wait'
BI will not offend any more;content — crux: אֶחְבֹּל 'act corruptly', or with the Old Greek 'I will not take a pledge'
32
Awhat I do not see, teach me yourself;content — בִּלְעֲדֵי אֶחֱזֶה — asyndetic relative, 'apart from what I see' (Ps 19:13); fronted אַתָּה
Bif I have done wrong,conditional — protasis, forward-leaning
I will do it no more'?content — apodosis — לֹא אֹסִיף; the stance Elihu wants from Job; 11Q10 preserves לא אוסף, as the MT
v. 33 — challenge to Job (tentative; elliptical): repay on your terms? — you choose — speak
33
AShould he repay it on your terms,independent — crux: הֲמֵעִמְּךָ 'from with you' = by your judgment; the feminine object of יְשַׁלְמֶנָּה unspecified
because you have rejected it?cause — כִּי — מָאַסְתָּ, object unstated (God's recompense?)
BFor you must choose, and not I;independent — כִּי — fronted אַתָּה; the decision thrown back on Job; 11Q10 …ר ולא אנה, '(you will choose), and not I'
Cso declare what you know.independent — fronted object וּמַה יָדַעְתָּ + imperative דַבֵּר
vv. 34–35 — appeal to the jury and its verdict, quoted (38:2; 42:3)
34
AMen of understanding will say to me,independent — the jury of vv. 2, 10 — אַנְשֵׁי לֵבָב
Band a wise manphrase modifier — second subject of 'will say', verb gapped
who hears me:participial — attributive participle שֹׁמֵעַ
35
A'Job speaks without knowledge,content — the verdict — לֹא בְדַעַת: YHWH's own charge in 38:2, Job's confession in 42:3
Band his words are without insight.'content — verbless, synonymous — בְהַשְׂכֵּיל // בְדַעַת; Old Greek keeps the verse
vv. 36–37 — closing wish and its ground: Job's sin + rebellion
36
AWould that Job were tested to the end,independent — crux: אָבִי as wish particle, or 'my father' addressed to God; עַד נֶצַח; Old Greek 'learn, Job, give no further answer like the fools'
Bbecause of his answers like those of men of iniquity!cause — עַל תְּשֻׁבֹת — Job's replies sound like the wicked's (בְּאַנְשֵׁי 'among' or 'like')
37
AFor he adds rebellion to his sin;cause — כִּי — פֶּשַׁע, rebellion, on top of חַטָּאת; Old Greek first person plural 'lest we add to our sins'
among us he claps his hands,cause — יִסְפּוֹק — the clap of scorn (27:23; cf. v. 26), object understood
Band multiplies his words against God.cause — וְיֶרֶב אֲמָרָיו לָאֵל — the speech ends on Job's many words