Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Job 12 — clausal layoutאיוב יב

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentparticipialrelativepurposecomparativecontentphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

The frame 12:1

Job's third reply — answering Zophar, the sixth and last speech of cycle 1 (chs. 12–14 are one speech)

1
 Then Job answered and said:independent — speech heading — the dialogue formula, two wayyiqtols; the speech runs to the end of ch. 14

Wisdom will die with you 12:2–6

Address to the friends — sarcasm (vv. 2–3) and complaint (vv. 4–6)

v. 2 — sarcastic bicolon: 'you are the people' // 'wisdom dies with you'

2
ANo doubt you are the people,independent — mock asseveration — אָמְנָם כִּי; verbless אַתֶּם עָם, as if the friends were the whole nation of the wise
Band with you wisdom will die!independent — the sting — עִמָּכֶם fronted: when they go, wisdom goes

v. 3 — counterclaim (A) + rhetorical question (B); 3a–b recurs at 13:2

3
AI too have a mind as well as you;independent — verbless — גַּם־לִי לֵבָב, 'heart' as the seat of understanding
 I do not fall short of you.independent — participle נֹפֵל + מִן — repeated at 13:2b, so the line brackets the address to the friends
BAnd who does not know such things as these?independent — rhetorical question, verbless — lit. 'with whom are there not the like of these?': the friends' wisdom is common stock. The Old Greek has only the first colon of the verse

v. 4 — the complaint, framed by שְׂחֹק … שְׂחוֹק: the man whose prayer was answered is now a joke

4
AA laughingstock to his friend I have become,independent — שְׂחֹק fronted; 'his friend', then 'I' — the person shifts in the Hebrew
 one who called to Eloah and he answered him;participial — apposition to the speaker — קֹרֵא + wayyiqtol וַיַּעֲנֵהוּ: the record of answered prayer
Ba laughingstock — the righteous, blameless man!independent — verbless exclamation — צַדִּיק תָּמִים, the verdict of 1:1, 8 now the butt of the joke; the Old Greek keeps only this colon

v. 5 — the creed of the comfortable (crux): contempt for misfortune // the blow ready for the slipping

5
A'For misfortune — contempt!'independent — crux — MT points לַפִּיד 'torch' ('a despised torch'); most read לְפִיד 'for disaster' (פִּיד, 30:24; 31:29). Taken here as the secure man's maxim, quoted
 so thinks the one at ease;phrase modifier — the frame of the maxim — לְעַשְׁתּוּת שַׁאֲנָן, 'in the opinion of the carefree' (עַשְׁתּוּת, a rare Aramaizing noun)
Bit is ready for those whose foot slips.independent — נָכוֹן — the blow 'stands ready' (cf. 18:12) for מוֹעֲדֵי רָגֶל, the already tottering; the Old Greek paraphrases ('an appointed time was prepared for him to fall')

v. 6 — the moral order inverted: robbers // God-provokers, capped by a headless relative

6
AThe tents of robbers are at peace,independent — יִשְׁלָיוּ — the peace the friends promised the righteous (5:24; 11:18) enjoyed by the שֹׁדְדִים
 and there is security for those who provoke God,independent — verbless — בַּטֻּחוֹת, security for the מַרְגִּיזֵי אֵל; the A colon runs to the atnach
Bfor the one who carries his god in his hand.relative — headless relative in apposition with the God-provokers — crux: לַאֲשֶׁר הֵבִיא אֱלוֹהַּ בְּיָדוֹ, 'whose god is his own fist' (cf. Hab 1:11) or 'whom God has brought into his power'

Ask the beasts: the hand of YHWH has done this 12:7–12

vv. 7–8 — appeal to creation: four realms (beasts, birds, earth, fish), each an imperative (or gapped imperative) + a yiqtol of result

7
ABut ask the beasts,independent — וְאוּלָם 'but' — imperative singular: one friend singled out; Bildad's 'ask the former generation' (8:8) turned round
 and they will teach you;purpose — weyiqtol of result — וְתֹרֶךָּ
Bthe birds of the heavens,independent — gapping — שְׁאַל carried over from A
 and they will tell you;purpose — weyiqtol of result — וְיַגֶּד
8
Aor speak to the earth,independent — crux — שִׂיחַ read as the imperative 'speak, muse'; or the noun 'the shrubs of the earth'; BHS proposes חַיַּת הָאָרֶץ 'the beasts of the earth'
 and it will teach you;purpose — וְתֹרֶךָּ repeated from 7a
Band the fish of the sea will recount it to you.independent — the fourth realm — verb first, subject last; the imperative gapped

v. 9 — the lesson creation teaches: rhetorical question + content clause; the only יְהוָה in the poetic dialogue

9
AWho among all these does not knowindependent — rhetorical question — מִי לֹא יָדַע; 'all these' are the four realms of vv. 7–8
Bthat the hand of YHWH has done this?content — כִּי + qatal, the content of the knowing. The divine name: the only יְהוָה in the poetic dialogue (3:2–42:6, outside the prose speech-headings); the colon matches Isa 41:20 word for word, which may explain it. BHS records a few Hebrew manuscripts with אֱלוֹהַּ, the dialogue's usual name; the Targum has 'the hand of God' (דאלהא, where it elsewhere writes ייי for the name); the Old Greek χεὶρ κυρίου does not decide, since κύριος also renders אֵל (v. 6)
10
Ain whose hand is the life of every living thingrelative — relative on יְהוָה, verbless — בְּיָדוֹ picks up יַד: the hand that 'did this' holds every נֶפֶשׁ
Band the breath of all human flesh.relative — gapped — נֶפֶשׁ // רוּחַ, כָּל־חָי // כָּל־בְּשַׂר־אִישׁ

vv. 11–12 — a proverb on testing (quoted again by Elihu, 34:3) and the traditional maxim it tests

11
ADoes not the ear test words,independent — rhetorical הֲלֹא — the right to test received wisdom
Bas the palate tastes food for itself?comparative — emblematic וְ — ear : words :: palate : food; טָעַם returns as the elders' 'discernment' (v. 20)
12
AWith the aged is wisdom,independent — verbless — the maxim (cf. Bildad's fathers, 8:8–10), perhaps quoted to be tested, perhaps a question
Band length of days is understanding.independent — synonymous — אֹרֶךְ יָמִים // יְשִׁישִׁים; v. 13 answers it with עִמּוֹ

Hymn to God's overturning wisdom 12:13–25

Hymn — thesis (v. 13), two הֵן illustrations (vv. 14–15), thesis renewed (v. 16), a participle catalogue of reversals (vv. 17–24), closing image (v. 25)

v. 13 — doxological thesis: עִמּוֹ // לוֹ, four attributes; the answer to v. 12

13
AWith him are wisdom and might;independent — verbless — עִמּוֹ fronted against בִּישִׁישִׁים: wisdom is with HIM, not with the old
Bto him belong counsel and understanding.independent — verbless — לוֹ; תְבוּנָה echoes v. 12b

vv. 14–15 — two הֵן illustrations, each act + irreversible result: tear down // shut in; withhold // release

14
ALook, he tears down,independent — הֵן — the illustration
 and it will not be rebuilt;independent — the result — niphal: what he razes stays down
Bhe shuts a man in,independent — סָגַר עַל — imprisonment; Job 'hedged in' (3:23; 19:8)
 and there is no opening.independent — the result — the prison stays shut
15
ALook, he holds back the waters,independent — הֵן again — drought
 and they dry up;independent — result
Bhe sends them out,independent — flood — the same waters released
 and they overturn the earth.independent — result — הָפַךְ, the verb of the overthrow of Sodom (Gen 19:25)

v. 16 — the thesis renewed (עִמּוֹ … לוֹ): strength, and error itself belongs to him

16
AWith him are strength and sound wisdom;independent — verbless — עֹז, and תּוּשִׁיָּה, wisdom's word for success (5:12; 11:6)
Bhis are the one who strays and the one who leads astray.independent — verbless merism — שֹׁגֵג וּמַשְׁגֶּה, deceived and deceiver: the bridge to the catalogue of misled leaders

vv. 17–24 — the participle catalogue: A opens with a participle (מוֹלִיךְ, מֵסִיר, שׁוֹפֵךְ, מְגַלֶּה, מַשְׂגִּיא, שֹׁטֵחַ), B finishes with a finite verb; counselors, judges, kings, priests, the trusted, elders, nobles, the strong, nations, chiefs

17
AHe leads counselors away stripped,independent — participle — מוֹלִיךְ … שׁוֹלָל, the refrain of v. 19; שׁוֹלָל 'stripped/barefoot', the captive's state (Mic 1:8)
Band judges he makes into fools.independent — yiqtol יְהוֹלֵל, poel of הלל 'make mad'; object fronted
18
AHe loosens the bond of kingsindependent — qatal פִּתֵּחַ — crux: מוּסַר, prob. 'bond' (מוֹסֵר), the bond of royal authority; the Old Greek reverses the line ('setting kings on thrones')
Band binds a loincloth on their loins.independent — wayyiqtol — אֵזוֹר, the captive's waist-cloth
19
AHe leads priests away strippedindependent — participle — the refrain of 17a, now priests
Band overthrows the long-established.independent — yiqtol יְסַלֵּף, object fronted — אֵתָנִים, 'the perennial', entrenched powers
20
AHe removes the speech of the trustedindependent — participle מֵסִיר — שָׂפָה, 'lip' = eloquence
Band takes away the discernment of elders.independent — yiqtol, object fronted — טַעַם 'taste': the elders lose what the maxim of v. 12 credited them with
21
AHe pours contempt on noblesindependent — participle שׁוֹפֵךְ — word for word Ps 107:40a
Band loosens the belt of the strong.independent — qatal רִפָּה, object fronted — the warrior's belt (cf. Isa 5:27); אֲפִיקִים 'the strong' is uncertain

v. 22 — interlude on darkness: deep things // deep darkness brought to light (revelation, or ominous in view of vv. 24–25)

22
AHe uncovers deep things out of darknessindependent — participle מְגַלֶּה
Band brings deep darkness out into the light.independent — wayyiqtol — צַלְמָוֶת, the 'death-shadow' of 3:5

v. 23 — rise and fall of nations: participle + wayyiqtol twice, לַגּוֹיִם repeated

23
AHe makes nations great,independent — participle מַשְׂגִּיא — many Hebrew manuscripts read מַשְׁגֶּה 'leads astray' (cf. v. 16), as the Old Greek πλανῶν
 then destroys them;independent — wayyiqtol — the reversal
Bhe spreads nations out,independent — participle שֹׁטֵחַ
 then leads them away.independent — wayyiqtol — into exile
24
AHe takes away the understanding of the chiefs of the people of the landindependent — participle מֵסִיר, as in v. 20 — לֵב 'heart' = sense
Band makes them wander in a trackless waste.independent — wayyiqtol — word for word Ps 107:40b; תֹהוּ, the unmade world of Gen 1:2

v. 25 — the closing image: blind groping // drunken staggering; וַיַּתְעֵם repeated from 24b

25
AThey grope in darkness without light,independent — the leaders as subject — חֹשֶׁךְ וְלֹא־אוֹר
Band he makes them staggerindependent — וַיַּתְעֵם — the verb of 24b again
 like a drunkard.comparative — כַּשִּׁכּוֹר — the hymn ends on its darkest image
Analysis. Job's third reply, answering Zophar and closing the first cycle of the dialogue (Eliphaz, Job, Bildad, Job, Zophar, Job: this is the sixth speech, and Job's longest, running on through chs. 13 and 14 without a new heading). The prose heading (v. 1) is a narrative frame; it has a short section of its own, and the speech below it runs flush-left as the mainline, indenting only real subordination and quoted words. Colon labels A/B follow the poetic accents (the atnach is the main break throughout this chapter). In v. 6 the tricolon-like line is labelled as the accents divide it, with its first colon carried over two lines. The chapter has three movements. The first is sarcasm and complaint (vv. 2–6): the mock-asseveration 'No doubt you are the people', Job's claim to an equal mind, and the inverted moral order, where the answered man of prayer is a joke while robbers live at peace. The second is the appeal to creation (vv. 7–12). Four imperative-and-result pairs send one friend to the beasts, birds, earth and fish, and their lesson is a content clause under 'know': 'that the hand of YHWH has done this' (v. 9). This is the only יְהוָה in the poetic dialogue, flagged in its tag; a few Hebrew manuscripts read אֱלוֹהַּ and the Targum reads 'God', while the Old Greek's κύριος does not decide the question. A proverb about testing (v. 11) and a traditional maxim (v. 12) then set up the hymn. The third is a hymn to God's overturning wisdom (vv. 13–25): a thesis with עִמּוֹ … לוֹ (vv. 13, 16), two הֵן illustrations of irreversible acts (vv. 14–15), and a participle catalogue (vv. 17–24) in which each A colon opens with a participle and each B colon finishes with a finite verb, stripping counselors, judges, kings, priests, elders, nobles and nations. It ends with the leaders groping in the dark. The layout keeps the catalogue flat, as it is parallel assertion, not subordination. Cruxes flagged in the tags: v. 5 (MT 'torch' vs. 'for misfortune'), v. 6c (whose god is in his hand?), v. 8 (שִׂיחַ verb or 'shrubs'), v. 9 (the divine name), v. 18 (מוּסַר 'bond'), v. 23 (מַשְׂגִּיא vs. the variant 'leads astray'). No Qumran text of Job 12 survives.