Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
The frame 12:1
Job's third reply — answering Zophar, the sixth and last speech of cycle 1 (chs. 12–14 are one speech)
1
Then Job answered and said:independent — speech heading — the dialogue formula, two wayyiqtols; the speech runs to the end of ch. 14
Wisdom will die with you 12:2–6
Address to the friends — sarcasm (vv. 2–3) and complaint (vv. 4–6)
v. 2 — sarcastic bicolon: 'you are the people' // 'wisdom dies with you'
2
ANo doubt you are the people,independent — mock asseveration — אָמְנָם כִּי; verbless אַתֶּם עָם, as if the friends were the whole nation of the wise
Band with you wisdom will die!independent — the sting — עִמָּכֶם fronted: when they go, wisdom goes
v. 3 — counterclaim (A) + rhetorical question (B); 3a–b recurs at 13:2
3
AI too have a mind as well as you;independent — verbless — גַּם־לִי לֵבָב, 'heart' as the seat of understanding
I do not fall short of you.independent — participle נֹפֵל + מִן — repeated at 13:2b, so the line brackets the address to the friends
BAnd who does not know such things as these?independent — rhetorical question, verbless — lit. 'with whom are there not the like of these?': the friends' wisdom is common stock. The Old Greek has only the first colon of the verse
v. 4 — the complaint, framed by שְׂחֹק … שְׂחוֹק: the man whose prayer was answered is now a joke
4
AA laughingstock to his friend I have become,independent — שְׂחֹק fronted; 'his friend', then 'I' — the person shifts in the Hebrew
one who called to Eloah and he answered him;participial — apposition to the speaker — קֹרֵא + wayyiqtol וַיַּעֲנֵהוּ: the record of answered prayer
Ba laughingstock — the righteous, blameless man!independent — verbless exclamation — צַדִּיק תָּמִים, the verdict of 1:1, 8 now the butt of the joke; the Old Greek keeps only this colon
v. 5 — the creed of the comfortable (crux): contempt for misfortune // the blow ready for the slipping
5
A'For misfortune — contempt!'independent — crux — MT points לַפִּיד 'torch' ('a despised torch'); most read לְפִיד 'for disaster' (פִּיד, 30:24; 31:29). Taken here as the secure man's maxim, quoted
so thinks the one at ease;phrase modifier — the frame of the maxim — לְעַשְׁתּוּת שַׁאֲנָן, 'in the opinion of the carefree' (עַשְׁתּוּת, a rare Aramaizing noun)
Bit is ready for those whose foot slips.independent — נָכוֹן — the blow 'stands ready' (cf. 18:12) for מוֹעֲדֵי רָגֶל, the already tottering; the Old Greek paraphrases ('an appointed time was prepared for him to fall')
v. 6 — the moral order inverted: robbers // God-provokers, capped by a headless relative
6
AThe tents of robbers are at peace,independent — יִשְׁלָיוּ — the peace the friends promised the righteous (5:24; 11:18) enjoyed by the שֹׁדְדִים
and there is security for those who provoke God,independent — verbless — בַּטֻּחוֹת, security for the מַרְגִּיזֵי אֵל; the A colon runs to the atnach
Bfor the one who carries his god in his hand.relative — headless relative in apposition with the God-provokers — crux: לַאֲשֶׁר הֵבִיא אֱלוֹהַּ בְּיָדוֹ, 'whose god is his own fist' (cf. Hab 1:11) or 'whom God has brought into his power'
Ask the beasts: the hand of YHWH has done this 12:7–12
vv. 7–8 — appeal to creation: four realms (beasts, birds, earth, fish), each an imperative (or gapped imperative) + a yiqtol of result
7
ABut ask the beasts,independent — וְאוּלָם 'but' — imperative singular: one friend singled out; Bildad's 'ask the former generation' (8:8) turned round
and they will teach you;purpose — weyiqtol of result — וְתֹרֶךָּ
Bthe birds of the heavens,independent — gapping — שְׁאַל carried over from A
and they will tell you;purpose — weyiqtol of result — וְיַגֶּד
8
Aor speak to the earth,independent — crux — שִׂיחַ read as the imperative 'speak, muse'; or the noun 'the shrubs of the earth'; BHS proposes חַיַּת הָאָרֶץ 'the beasts of the earth'
and it will teach you;purpose — וְתֹרֶךָּ repeated from 7a
Band the fish of the sea will recount it to you.independent — the fourth realm — verb first, subject last; the imperative gapped
v. 9 — the lesson creation teaches: rhetorical question + content clause; the only יְהוָה in the poetic dialogue
9
AWho among all these does not knowindependent — rhetorical question — מִי לֹא יָדַע; 'all these' are the four realms of vv. 7–8
Bthat the hand of YHWH has done this?content — כִּי + qatal, the content of the knowing. The divine name: the only יְהוָה in the poetic dialogue (3:2–42:6, outside the prose speech-headings); the colon matches Isa 41:20 word for word, which may explain it. BHS records a few Hebrew manuscripts with אֱלוֹהַּ, the dialogue's usual name; the Targum has 'the hand of God' (דאלהא, where it elsewhere writes ייי for the name); the Old Greek χεὶρ κυρίου does not decide, since κύριος also renders אֵל (v. 6)
10
Ain whose hand is the life of every living thingrelative — relative on יְהוָה, verbless — בְּיָדוֹ picks up יַד: the hand that 'did this' holds every נֶפֶשׁ
Band the breath of all human flesh.relative — gapped — נֶפֶשׁ // רוּחַ, כָּל־חָי // כָּל־בְּשַׂר־אִישׁ
vv. 11–12 — a proverb on testing (quoted again by Elihu, 34:3) and the traditional maxim it tests
11
ADoes not the ear test words,independent — rhetorical הֲלֹא — the right to test received wisdom
Bas the palate tastes food for itself?comparative — emblematic וְ — ear : words :: palate : food; טָעַם returns as the elders' 'discernment' (v. 20)
12
AWith the aged is wisdom,independent — verbless — the maxim (cf. Bildad's fathers, 8:8–10), perhaps quoted to be tested, perhaps a question
Band length of days is understanding.independent — synonymous — אֹרֶךְ יָמִים // יְשִׁישִׁים; v. 13 answers it with עִמּוֹ
Hymn to God's overturning wisdom 12:13–25
Hymn — thesis (v. 13), two הֵן illustrations (vv. 14–15), thesis renewed (v. 16), a participle catalogue of reversals (vv. 17–24), closing image (v. 25)
v. 13 — doxological thesis: עִמּוֹ // לוֹ, four attributes; the answer to v. 12
13
AWith him are wisdom and might;independent — verbless — עִמּוֹ fronted against בִּישִׁישִׁים: wisdom is with HIM, not with the old
Bto him belong counsel and understanding.independent — verbless — לוֹ; תְבוּנָה echoes v. 12b
vv. 14–15 — two הֵן illustrations, each act + irreversible result: tear down // shut in; withhold // release
14
ALook, he tears down,independent — הֵן — the illustration
and it will not be rebuilt;independent — the result — niphal: what he razes stays down
Bhe shuts a man in,independent — סָגַר עַל — imprisonment; Job 'hedged in' (3:23; 19:8)
and there is no opening.independent — the result — the prison stays shut
15
ALook, he holds back the waters,independent — הֵן again — drought
and they dry up;independent — result
Bhe sends them out,independent — flood — the same waters released
and they overturn the earth.independent — result — הָפַךְ, the verb of the overthrow of Sodom (Gen 19:25)
v. 16 — the thesis renewed (עִמּוֹ … לוֹ): strength, and error itself belongs to him
16
AWith him are strength and sound wisdom;independent — verbless — עֹז, and תּוּשִׁיָּה, wisdom's word for success (5:12; 11:6)
Bhis are the one who strays and the one who leads astray.independent — verbless merism — שֹׁגֵג וּמַשְׁגֶּה, deceived and deceiver: the bridge to the catalogue of misled leaders
vv. 17–24 — the participle catalogue: A opens with a participle (מוֹלִיךְ, מֵסִיר, שׁוֹפֵךְ, מְגַלֶּה, מַשְׂגִּיא, שֹׁטֵחַ), B finishes with a finite verb; counselors, judges, kings, priests, the trusted, elders, nobles, the strong, nations, chiefs
17
AHe leads counselors away stripped,independent — participle — מוֹלִיךְ … שׁוֹלָל, the refrain of v. 19; שׁוֹלָל 'stripped/barefoot', the captive's state (Mic 1:8)
Band judges he makes into fools.independent — yiqtol יְהוֹלֵל, poel of הלל 'make mad'; object fronted
18
AHe loosens the bond of kingsindependent — qatal פִּתֵּחַ — crux: מוּסַר, prob. 'bond' (מוֹסֵר), the bond of royal authority; the Old Greek reverses the line ('setting kings on thrones')
Band binds a loincloth on their loins.independent — wayyiqtol — אֵזוֹר, the captive's waist-cloth
19
AHe leads priests away strippedindependent — participle — the refrain of 17a, now priests
Band overthrows the long-established.independent — yiqtol יְסַלֵּף, object fronted — אֵתָנִים, 'the perennial', entrenched powers
20
AHe removes the speech of the trustedindependent — participle מֵסִיר — שָׂפָה, 'lip' = eloquence
Band takes away the discernment of elders.independent — yiqtol, object fronted — טַעַם 'taste': the elders lose what the maxim of v. 12 credited them with
21
AHe pours contempt on noblesindependent — participle שׁוֹפֵךְ — word for word Ps 107:40a
Band loosens the belt of the strong.independent — qatal רִפָּה, object fronted — the warrior's belt (cf. Isa 5:27); אֲפִיקִים 'the strong' is uncertain
v. 22 — interlude on darkness: deep things // deep darkness brought to light (revelation, or ominous in view of vv. 24–25)
22
AHe uncovers deep things out of darknessindependent — participle מְגַלֶּה
Band brings deep darkness out into the light.independent — wayyiqtol — צַלְמָוֶת, the 'death-shadow' of 3:5
v. 23 — rise and fall of nations: participle + wayyiqtol twice, לַגּוֹיִם repeated
23
AHe makes nations great,independent — participle מַשְׂגִּיא — many Hebrew manuscripts read מַשְׁגֶּה 'leads astray' (cf. v. 16), as the Old Greek πλανῶν
then destroys them;independent — wayyiqtol — the reversal
Bhe spreads nations out,independent — participle שֹׁטֵחַ
then leads them away.independent — wayyiqtol — into exile
24
AHe takes away the understanding of the chiefs of the people of the landindependent — participle מֵסִיר, as in v. 20 — לֵב 'heart' = sense
Band makes them wander in a trackless waste.independent — wayyiqtol — word for word Ps 107:40b; תֹהוּ, the unmade world of Gen 1:2
v. 25 — the closing image: blind groping // drunken staggering; וַיַּתְעֵם repeated from 24b
25
AThey grope in darkness without light,independent — the leaders as subject — חֹשֶׁךְ וְלֹא־אוֹר
Band he makes them staggerindependent — וַיַּתְעֵם — the verb of 24b again
like a drunkard.comparative — כַּשִּׁכּוֹר — the hymn ends on its darkest image