Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
No Festival Joy: Harvest Failure and Exile 9:1–6
v. 1 — prohibition and ground: do not rejoice // (not) to exultation; you played the harlot // you loved a harlot's wages
1
ADo not rejoice, O Israel,independent — אַל + jussive — the festival joy cancelled, probably at the autumn harvest feast
to the point of exultation like the peoples,phrase modifier — אֶל גִּיל 'unto exultation' is an unusual phrase; the LXX's 'nor be glad' (μηδὲ εὐφραίνου) suggests a verb in its place; כָּעַמִּים — the nations' harvest rites
for you have played the harlot, departing from your God;cause — כִּי causal; זָנָה מֵעַל — harlotry as desertion
Byou have loved a harlot's wagescause — the ground continued asyndetically; אֶתְנָן — the harvest taken as Baal's payment (cf. 2:14)
upon every threshing floor of grain.phrase modifier — where the 'wages' were paid; 4QXIIg (4Q82) preserves the closing דָּגָן
v. 2 — futility curse: threshing floor and vat // new wine; the places of the wages become places of failure
2
AThreshing floor and winevat shall not feed them,independent — יִרְעֵם 'pasture, feed'; the LXX has 'did not know them' (οὐκ ἔγνω αὐτούς)
Band the new wine shall fail her.independent — כחש 'deceive, fail'; the shift from 'them' to 'her' (the land or the wife) is typical of Hosea; the LXX has 'deceived them'
v. 3 — exile: not remain in YHWH's land // Ephraim returns to Egypt // unclean food in Assyria (Egypt // Assyria)
3
AThey shall not remain in the land of YHWH;independent — the land is YHWH's, so apostates cannot keep living in it
BEphraim shall return to Egypt,independent — weqatal וְשָׁב — the exodus reversed (cf. 8:13; 11:5)
and in Assyria they shall eat unclean food.independent — טָמֵא fronted — food eaten outside the land is unclean (Amos 7:17; Ezek 4:13)
v. 4 — the cult ended: no libation // no pleasing offering; mourners' bread; then the ground: bread for the appetite only
4
AThey shall not pour out wine to YHWH,independent — libation ended — no drink offering in exile
nor shall they be pleasing to him;independent — עָרַב 'be sweet, pleasing'; the segolta closes the clause here, so the subject is still 'they' (many translations make 'their sacrifices' the subject instead)
their sacrifices — like mourners' bread to them;independent — following the accents, זִבְחֵיהֶם heads the comparison; לֶחֶם אוֹנִים, food of a house of mourning, defiled by the dead (Num 19:14; Deut 26:14); the LXX has ὡς ἄρτος πένθους
all who eat of it shall be defiled.independent — the consequence of eating such bread — uncleanness
BFor their bread is for their appetite only;cause — כִּי — the ground: food that feeds the throat (נֶפֶשׁ) but cannot be offered
it shall not come into the house of YHWH.cause — the ground completed: no offering reaches the sanctuary
v. 5 — taunt question: the day of the appointed festival // the day of YHWH's feast (verb gapped)
5
AWhat will you do on the day of the appointed festival,independent — direct address in the second person; מוֹעֵד
Band on the day of YHWH's feast?independent — gapping — 'what will you do' carried over; חַג יְהוָה, probably Booths
v. 6 — death in exile: Egypt gathers // Memphis buries (sound-pair תְּקַבְּצֵם / תְּקַבְּרֵם); desolation at home: nettles // thorns
6
AFor behold, they have gone away from the devastation;independent — כִּי הִנֵּה — the answer to the taunt: by the feast they will be gone; מִשֹּׁד; the LXX has 'from the misery of Egypt'
Egypt shall gather them,independent — קבץ — gathered, but for burial
Memphis shall bury them;independent — מֹף, with its great necropolis; the sound-pair completes the colon; LXX Μέμφις
Btheir precious things of silver —phrase modifier — casus pendens; the LXX takes מַחְמַד as a place-name, 'Machmas shall bury them'
nettles shall possess them,independent — יָרַשׁ — weeds 'inherit' the treasures
thorns shall be in their tents.independent — gapping — the verb understood; abandoned homes
The Days of Reckoning and the Mocked Prophet 9:7–9
v. 7 — anaphora: have come the days of punishment // have come the days of recompense; then the taunt: fool // mad, the prophet // the man of the spirit
7
AThe days of punishment have come;independent — בָּאוּ — the reckoning is present
the days of recompense have come;independent — anaphora — בָּאוּ repeated; פְּקֻדָּה // שִׁלֻּם
let Israel know it!independent — יֵדְעוּ — jussive or future ('Israel shall know'); the LXX has 'Israel shall be afflicted' (κακωθήσεται)
B'The prophet is a fool,independent — the people's taunt, quoted without a frame (or the prophet's own verdict on false prophets); verbless
the man of the spirit is mad!' —independent — synonymous member: מְשֻׁגָּע // אֱוִיל, אִישׁ הָרוּחַ // הַנָּבִיא
because of the greatness of your iniquity,cause — עַל רֹב — the prophet's explanation of the scorn
and great is the hostility.cause — מַשְׂטֵמָה — the word recurs in v. 8; the LXX has 'your madness was multiplied'
v. 8 — the watchman and the snare: with my God // in the house of his God; text and syntax disputed
8
AThe watchman of Ephraim is with my God;independent — obscure; the atnach closes the colon here, so the watchman (צֹפֶה, the prophet's office: Jer 6:17; Ezek 3:17) is said to stand with God; the LXX joins 'prophet' to this colon
Bas for the prophet —phrase modifier — casus pendens opening the second colon, as the accents divide it
a fowler's snare is on all his ways,independent — פַּח יָקוֹשׁ — the prophet hunted
hostility in the house of his God.independent — מַשְׂטֵמָה again (v. 7) — opposition even at the sanctuary
v. 9 — analogy and verdict: corruption as at Gibeah; he will remember // he will punish (= 8:13)
9
AThey have deeply corrupted themselves,independent — asyndetic verb pair as hendiadys: הֶעְמִיקוּ שִׁחֵתוּ
as in the days of Gibeah;comparative — the outrage of Judg 19–21 (cf. 10:9); 4QXIIg preserves the end of the verb and כִּימֵי
Bhe will remember their iniquity,independent — the verdict of 8:13, here asyndetic
he will punish their sins.independent — synonymous member — פקד answering זכר
From First Fruits to Barren Womb 9:10–14
v. 10 — two similes of first delight: grapes in the wilderness // first-ripe fig, I found Israel // I saw your fathers; then the fall: Baal-peor → the Shame → detestable
10
ALike grapes in the wilderness I found Israel;independent — simile fronted — unexpected fruit in the desert; the election tradition
like the first-ripe fig on the fig tree in its first season I saw your fathers.independent — synonymous member: מָצָאתִי // רָאִיתִי; 4QXIIg preserves כְּבִכּוּרָה with the MT; the LXX has 'like an early watchman on a fig tree'
BBut they came to Baal-peorindependent — fronted הֵמָּה — the turn; the apostasy of Num 25
and consecrated themselves to the Shame,independent — וַיִּנָּזְרוּ — dedicated as to a deity; בֹּשֶׁת standing in for Baal
and they became detestableindependent — שִׁקּוּצִים — they became what they served
like the thing they loved.comparative — כְּאָהֳבָם — 'like their love' (cf. 2 Kgs 17:15; Ps 115:8); the LXX has 'the beloved became as the abominable'
v. 11 — curse of infertility: glory flies off like a bird; the birth process run backwards, no birth // no womb // no conception
11
AEphraim —phrase modifier — casus pendens on the zaqef; the name means 'fruitful'
like a bird their glory shall fly away:independent — כָּעוֹף יִתְעוֹפֵף — sound-play; כָּבוֹד as fertility and numbers
Bno birth,independent — privative מִן — the sequence reversed: birth
no womb,independent — pregnancy
no conception.independent — conception — the curse reaches the start of life
v. 12 — concession and bereavement, then the woe-cry: YHWH's own departure
12
AEven if they bring up their sons,conditional — כִּי אִם concessive — even children already born
I will bereave them until none is left;independent — weqatal apodosis; מֵאָדָם 'without a man'
Byes, woe to them indeedindependent — כִּי גַם asseverative, preserved in 4QXIIg; אוֹי
when I turn away from them!conditional — temporal בְּ + infinitive, following its clause; בְּשׂוּרִי as a by-form of סור 'turn aside' (cf. 5:6, 15); the LXX reads 'my flesh is from them' (σάρξ μου ἐξ αὐτῶν)
v. 13 — contrast, text obscure: Ephraim like Tyre planted in a meadow // Ephraim bringing out his sons to the slayer
13
AEphraim —phrase modifier — casus pendens, answered by וְאֶפְרַיִם in the second colon
as I have seen,comparative — כַּאֲשֶׁר רָאִיתִי — YHWH's view, as in v. 10
was like Tyre, planted in a meadow;independent — very obscure: לְצוֹר is read 'like Tyre' (secure and prosperous), or as 'a palm' or 'a rock'; the LXX has 'set their children for prey' (εἰς θήραν παρέστησαν)
Bbut Ephraim must bring out his sons to the slayer.independent — לְ + infinitive of obligation; הֹרֵג; 4QXIIg preserves the infinitive, as in the MT
v. 14 — intercession turned imprecation: give them // what will you give? // give them; womb // breasts (reversing Gen 49:25)
14
AGive them, YHWH —independent — imperative to YHWH; the prophet begins to intercede
what will you give?independent — the intercession falters into a question
BGive them a miscarrying wombindependent — staircase — תֵּן repeated; מַשְׁכִּיל: barrenness the lesser evil than sons for the slayer (v. 13)
and dry breasts.independent — gapping; 4QXIIg preserves 'dry' in plene spelling
Hated in Gilgal, Fruitless, Scattered 9:15–17
v. 15 — rejection in divorce language: hate // drive out // love no more; closing pun שָׂרֵיהֶם סֹרְרִים
15
AAll their evil is in Gilgal;independent — verbless; Gilgal the cult site (4:15; 12:12) and the place Saul was made king (1 Sam 11:15)
for there I came to hate them.cause — כִּי — שְׂנֵאתִים, the language of divorce (cf. 2:4)
Because of the wickedness of their deeds I will drive them out of my house;independent — עַל רֹעַ fronted; גרשׁ, the verb of divorce and expulsion; 'my house' = the land
BI will love them no more;independent — לֹא אוֹסֵף + infinitive — the reversal of covenant love
all their princes are rebels.independent — verbless closing pun: שָׂרֵיהֶם סֹרְרִים; the LXX has 'disobedient'
v. 16 — the name Ephraim ('fruitful') undone: struck // root dried // no fruit; then: even if they bear → I kill
16
AEphraim is struck down;independent — הֻכָּה — the plant blighted; the LXX has 'Ephraim suffered'
their root is dried up;independent — the plant image continued
they shall bear no fruit.independent — פְּרִי — the pun on אֶפְרַיִם; Kethiv בלי, Qere בַל
BEven if they give birth,conditional — גַּם כִּי concessive (cf. v. 12)
I will put to death the cherished ones of their womb.independent — weqatal apodosis; מַחֲמַדֵּי echoes מַחְמַד of v. 6
v. 17 — closing verdict in the prophet's voice: rejected // not listened → wanderers among the nations (Gen 4:12, 14; inclusio with 'like the peoples', v. 1)
17
AMy God will reject them,independent — מאס; 'my God' as in v. 8; 4QXIIg preserves 'my God' in plene spelling
because they have not listened to him;cause — כִּי — the covenant failure to 'hear'
Band they shall be wanderers among the nations.independent — נֹדְדִים — Cain's curse; the festival 'like the peoples' (v. 1) ends in scattering among them