Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
The Alarm: Covenant Broken, God Claimed 8:1–3
v. 1 — alarm cry and image (no verb in either colon), then the יַעַן ground in chiastic parallel: transgressed // my covenant :: my torah // rebelled
1
ATo your palate, the ram's horn!independent — verbless alarm command (cf. 5:8) — חִכְּךָ 'to your mouth', the watchman's horn; the addressee is not named
Like a vulture over the house of YHWH —comparative — elliptical simile with no stated subject: the invader as נֶשֶׁר (vulture or eagle) over YHWH's household, the land and people; obscure, and the LXX reads 'into their bosom like earth, like an eagle'
Bbecause they have transgressed my covenant,cause — יַעַן — the ground of the alarm; עָבַר בְּרִית, covenant-breaking (cf. 6:7)
and against my torah they have rebelled.cause — second member of the ground, in chiasm; פָּשָׁע, a vassal's revolt
v. 2 — the quoted cry: to me they cry // 'My God, we know you'
2
ATo me they cry out:independent — לִי fronted — the appeal is made to YHWH; iterative yiqtol
B'My God, we know you!' —content — the confession quoted, ironic: it echoes the knowledge-of-God theme of 4:1, 6; 6:3, and v. 3 shows it hollow
Israel.phrase modifier — the name held to the end — read as the speakers naming themselves ('we, Israel'), apposition to the subject of יְדַעֲנוּךָ; some take it as a vocative or gloss, and the LXX has no equivalent
v. 3 — rebuttal: Israel spurned the good // an enemy pursues him (cause // consequence, asyndetic)
3
AIsrael has spurned the good;independent — זָנַח — the verb returns in v. 5; טוֹב as covenant good, or YHWH himself
Ban enemy shall pursue him.independent — consequence colon, asyndetic; the LXX reads 'they pursued an enemy' (ἐχθρὸν κατεδίωξαν)
Kings Not From Me, a Calf Not God 8:4–6
v. 4 — indictment: they made kings // they made princes, each answered by a negation from YHWH; then silver and gold made into idols, with an ironic לְמַעַן
4
AThey made kings,independent — fronted הֵם — their king-making set against YHWH's (cf. the coups of 2 Kgs 15)
but not from me;phrase modifier — elliptical negation — no royal designation from YHWH
they made princes,independent — הֵשִׂירוּ from שׂרר 'make princes', parallel to הִמְלִיכוּ (some derive it from סור, 'they removed'); the LXX has ἦρξαν 'they ruled'
and I did not know.independent — 'know' as acknowledge or sanction — the second negation answers the first
BWith their silver and their gold they made idols for themselves,independent — materials fronted; עֲצַבִּים — the indictment moves from throne to cult
so that it may be cut off.purpose — לְמַעַן of result framed as purpose (ironic): they made idols in order to be cut off; the singular יִכָּרֵת leaves the subject open (the silver and gold, or Israel); the LXX has a plural, 'that they may be destroyed'
v. 5 — the rejection verb of v. 3 turned on the calf: spurned // my anger burns, then a lament-question
5
AHe has spurned your calf, O Samaria;independent — זָנַח, 3ms qatal — YHWH is the subject though he speaks in the next colon; some repoint it as an imperative ('spurn your calf'), as the LXX reads it (ἀπότριψαι, 'cast away'); עֶגְלֵךְ, the Bethel image (10:5)
my anger burns against them.independent — switch from 2fs address to divine first person and 3mp — typical of Hosea
BHow long will they be incapable of innocence?independent — עַד מָתַי lament-question; נִקָּיֹן 'cleanness' — guilt treated as chronic
v. 6 — anti-idol polemic: from Israel // a craftsman made it // not God, then the proof: it will be splinters
6
AFor from Israel is it too:independent — כִּי explanatory, grounding the whole verdict of v. 5; וְהוּא 'and it' — a terse, much-debated phrase (some redivide it as 'for who is Israel?'); the LXX reads 'in Israel; and it …'
a craftsman made it,independent — חָרָשׁ fronted — a human product; עָשָׂהוּ (cf. 'his Maker', v. 14)
and it is not God.independent — verbless negation, the polemic's core (cf. Isa 44; Jer 10)
BFor the calf of Samaria shall become splinters.cause — second כִּי — the proof that it is no god: it will be smashed; שְׁבָבִים is a hapax ('splinters', or 'flames'), uncertain; the LXX has 'your calf, Samaria, was deceiving' (πλανῶν ἦν)
Wind and Whirlwind: Israel Swallowed Among the Nations 8:7–10
v. 7 — harvest proverb: wind // whirlwind, sow // reap (object fronted in both cola), then a futility curse built on the sound-play צֶמַח / קֶמַח
7
AFor they sow wind,independent — כִּי loosely connective; רוּחַ fronted — sin-and-consequence as a law of harvest; the LXX has 'wind-blasted things' (ἀνεμόφθορα)
and the whirlwind they shall reap.independent — סוּפָתָה — the wind grown worse: the harvest exceeds the seed
BStanding grain — it has no sprout;independent — casus pendens קָמָה; אֵין לוֹ צֶמַח
it will yield no meal;independent — בְּלִי + yiqtol; קֶמַח rhymes with צֶמַח — the futility curse
if perhaps it should yield,conditional — אוּלַי — a concessive 'even if'; forward-leaning on the curse below
strangers would swallow it up.independent — זָרִים — foreign armies and tribute; יִבְלָעֻהוּ is the catchword for v. 8
v. 8 — catchword בלע: the grain swallowed → Israel swallowed; simile of the unwanted vessel
8
AIsrael is swallowed up;independent — נִבְלַע — the image carried from crop to people
Bnow they have become among the nationsindependent — עַתָּה — the sentence already in force
like a vesselcomparative — the simile (cf. Jer 22:28; 48:38)
that no one wants.relative — asyndetic relative — אֵין חֵפֶץ בּוֹ; the LXX has 'a useless vessel'
v. 9 — the ground: gone up to Assyria; the pun פֶּרֶא (wild donkey) / אֶפְרַיִם; the harlot who pays her lovers
9
AFor they have gone up to Assyria,cause — כִּי grounding v. 8 — alliance diplomacy (cf. 5:13; 7:11)
a wild donkey keeping to itself;phrase modifier — the image in apposition to 'they'; the atnach keeps it with Assyria, though the sound-play points ahead to Ephraim; the LXX reads a verb, 'Ephraim flourished by himself'
BEphraim has hired lovers.cause — the ground continued — הִתְנוּ, to pay a harlot's fee (the harlot pays instead of being paid); the LXX has 'they loved gifts'
v. 10 — concession and sentence: though they hire // now I will gather; the last colon is obscure
10
AEven though they hire [lovers] among the nations,conditional — גַּם כִּי concessive; יִתְנוּ picks up הִתְנוּ (v. 9)
now I will gather them up;independent — קבץ — gathered for judgment, not for homecoming (cf. 9:6)
Band they have begun to dwindle a littleindependent — uncertain: וַיָּחֵלּוּ may be 'they began' (חלל), or a form of חיל 'they will writhe'; מְעָט 'a little' or 'soon'
under the burden of the king of princes.phrase modifier — מַשָּׂא as tribute; 'king of princes' probably the Assyrian great king (cf. Isa 10:8); the LXX has 'from anointing king and rulers' (τοῦ χρίειν βασιλέα καὶ ἄρχοντας)
Altars for Sinning, Torah as a Stranger 8:11–13
v. 11 — the line repeats its own ending: altars for sinning // altars for sinning (epiphora)
11
AFor Ephraim has multiplied altars for sinning;independent — כִּי loosely connective; לַחֲטֹא — meant as 'for sin-removal', it turned out 'for sinning'
Bthey have become to him altars for sinning.independent — the repetition is the irony: the means of atonement became the occasion of guilt; the LXX has 'beloved altars' in the second colon
v. 12 — unreal condition: write the myriads of my torah → reckoned a strange thing
12
AWere I to write for him the myriads of my torah,conditional — asyndetic yiqtol as an unreal protasis; the Kethiv אכתוב and רבו, Qere אֶכְתָּב and רֻבֵּי ('myriads'); an early witness to written divine instruction in the north
Bthey would be regarded as a strange thing.independent — כְּמוֹ זָר — the strangeness belonging to strange gods turned onto YHWH's own law; the plural verb takes the torah-precepts as subject
v. 13 — sacrifice refused (cf. Jer 14:10, which repeats this verse's verdict), then the verdict pair remember // punish (= 9:9) and the exodus reversed
13
AAs for my sacrificial gifts,phrase modifier — casus pendens; הַבְהָבַי is a hapax of uncertain sense (perhaps 'my gifts', from יהב)
they sacrifice flesh and eat it;independent — the offering reduced to a meat-meal; וַיֹּאכֵלוּ in a present frame
YHWH does not accept them.independent — רָצָם — the priestly acceptance term refused (cf. Amos 5:22)
BNow he will remember their iniquityindependent — עַתָּה — the verdict; the pair recurs at 9:9
and punish their sins:independent — synonymous member — פָּקַד answering זָכַר
they shall return to Egypt.independent — fronted הֵמָּה — the exodus reversed (cf. 9:3; 11:5); the LXX adds 'and in Assyria they shall eat unclean things' (cf. 9:3)
Forgotten Maker, Fire on the Cities 8:14
v. 14 — summary indictment: Israel forgot and built // Judah multiplied, then the fire formula of Amos 1–2: send fire // it devours
14
AIsrael has forgotten his Makerindependent — עֹשֵׂהוּ — the true Maker against the craftsman who 'made' the calf (v. 6)
and built palaces,independent — הֵיכָלוֹת — palaces or temples; the LXX has τεμένη 'sacred precincts'
and Judah has multiplied fortified cities;independent — Judah drawn into the charge; הִרְבָּה as in v. 11
Bbut I will send fire upon his cities,independent — weqatal — the fire formula of Amos 1:4, 7, 10; 2:5
and it shall devour her citadels.independent — the formula's second member; אַרְמְנֹתֶיהָ — the feminine suffix refers to the city or land