Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
Wealth Without the Power to Enjoy It 6:1–2
v. 1 — 'there is' + 'I saw' + 'under the sun' (as 5:12): a new case
1
There is an evilindependent — יֵשׁ presents the case
that I have seen under the sun,relative — observation formula רָאִיתִי + refrain 'under the sun'
and it lies heavy upon mankind:independent — רַבָּה, 'great, common' or 'heavy'; עַל favors a burden
v. 2 — the case: 5:18 reversed (goods given, enjoyment withheld); verdict הֶבֶל + 'a grievous sickness'
2
a manindependent — the case named, in apposition to the 'evil' of v. 1
to whom God gives riches and possessions and honor,relative — the gifts of 5:18 with כָּבוֹד added (cf. 1 Kgs 3:13)
so that he lacks nothing for himself of allrelative — circumstantial וְאֵינֶנּוּ + participle חָסֵר, continuing the relative
that he desires;relative — Hithpael יִתְאַוֶּה
yet God does not empower him to eat from it,independent — וְלֹא יַשְׁלִיטֶנּוּ: the verb of 5:18 negated; מִמֶּנּוּ, 'from it'
for a foreign man eats it.cause — אִישׁ נָכְרִי, a stranger and not an heir (LXX ἀνὴρ ξένος)
This is vapor and a grievous sickness.independent — verdict הֶבֶל + חֳלִי רָע (cf. the 'sickening evil' of 5:12, 15)
Better the Stillborn 6:3–6
v. 3 — hypothetical case: a five-line protasis (children, years, days, no satisfaction, no burial) + the 'better … than' (טוֹב … מִן) verdict on the stillborn
3
If a man fathers a hundred childrenconditional — אִם + yiqtol: a hyperbolic case; 'a hundred' with 'children' understood
and lives many years,conditional — fronted 'many years'
and however many are the days of his years,conditional — וְרַב שֶׁיִּהְיוּ, 'and many though they be'
but his soul is not satisfied with good,conditional — the turn: נַפְשׁוֹ … לֹא תִשְׂבַּע (cf. 4:8)
and also he has no burial,conditional — crux: abrupt; an unmourned end (cf. Isa 14:19–20; Jer 22:19), or a clause displaced from the stillborn
I say:independent — אָמַרְתִּי: the verdict given as a judgment
better off than he is the stillborn.content — 'better … than' (טוֹב מִמֶּנּוּ) with the subject הַנָּפֶל last (cf. Job 3:16); 4Q109 reads טוב הנפל ממ׳נו
vv. 4–5 — the ground: three cola on the stillborn (in vapor it comes // in darkness it goes // in darkness its name is covered), then its advantage, 'rest'
4
AFor in vapor it comes,cause — כִּי; subject the stillborn; בַהֶבֶל, hebel as its element; 4Q109 spells the verb בה
and in darkness it goes,cause — come // go, the whole span in a merism; 4Q109 carries a correction הלך, 'went'
Band in darkness its name is covered.cause — וּבַחֹשֶׁךְ repeated; no name, no memory
5
It has not even seen the sun nor known anything;independent — גַּם, 'even'; to see the sun = to live (7:11; 11:7); 4Q109 agrees, with plene לוא
this one has more rest than that one.independent — נַחַת, the 'quiet' of 4:6; לָזֶה מִזֶּה, comparative מִן: the stillborn above the rich man; 4Q109 spells נוחת
v. 6 — extreme conditional (a thousand years twice over) + rhetorical question (הֲלֹא): all go to one place (3:20)
6
And even if he lived a thousand years twice overconditional — וְאִלּוּ, 'even if', an unreal condition (late form; 4Q109 has the common ואם)
but did not see good,conditional — fronted וְטוֹבָה: the deciding lack
do not all go to one place?independent — rhetorical הֲלֹא expecting 'yes'; מָקוֹם אֶחָד, the grave (3:20)
The Unsatisfied Appetite 6:7–9
v. 7 — aphorism (antithetic): toil for the mouth // the appetite unfilled; 'all the toil of man is for his mouth'
7
AAll the toil of man is for his mouth,independent — verbless; עֲמַל, the book's 'toil'; 4Q109 agrees (כול עמל האדם)
Band yet the appetite is not filled.independent — adversative וְגַם; נֶפֶשׁ as appetite, paired with 'mouth'; תִמָּלֵא as in 1:8
v. 8 — two rhetorical questions on the limits of wisdom: the wise // the poor, 'advantage' carried over
8
AFor what advantage has the wise mancause — rhetorical מַה יּוֹתֵר (cf. 1:3); 4Q109 reads כמה for כִּי מַה
over the fool?comparative — comparative מִן
BWhat has the poor manindependent — elliptical, 'advantage' carried over (LXX διότι ὁ πένης οἶδεν, 'because the poor man knows')
who knows how to walk before the living?participial — participle יוֹדֵעַ: knowing how to conduct oneself in public
v. 9 — 'better … than' (טוֹב … מִן): the sight of the eyes // the roving of the appetite; the last full refrain 'vapor and a chasing of wind'
9
ABetter is the sight of the eyesindependent — טוֹב: enjoying what is at hand
than the roving of the appetite;comparative — the 'than' member מֵהֲלָךְ; נֶפֶשׁ as appetite again (v. 7)
Bthis too is vapor and a chasing of wind.independent — gam-formula + refrain הֶבֶל וּרְעוּת רוּחַ
Named Already: The Limits of Human Knowledge 6:10–12
v. 10 — reflection: all already named (כְּבָר), man known, unable to contend with one stronger (the Masoretic midpoint of the book)
10
Whatever has come to be,phrase modifier — headless relative מַה שֶּׁ־ as casus pendens (cf. 1:9; 3:15), resumed by שְׁמוֹ
its name has already been called,independent — כְּבָר; to be named is to be defined and fixed
and it is knownindependent — Niphal וְנוֹדָע
what man is;content — אֲשֶׁר הוּא אָדָם; אָדָם perhaps with a glance at the ground (אֲדָמָה)
and he is not able to contendindependent — יוּכַל + infinitive לָדִין, a legal dispute
with one who is stronger than he.phrase modifier — Kethiv שהתקיף (with the article), Qere שֶׁתַּקִּיף, same sense (LXX μετὰ τοῦ ἰσχυροῦ ὑπὲρ αὐτόν); most naturally God
v. 11 — observation + rhetorical question of advantage (יֹתֵר)
11
For there are many wordscause — כִּי יֵשׁ; words, the theme of 5:1–6
that multiply vapor;participial — participle מַרְבִּים, wordplay with הַרְבֵּה; הָבֶל
what advantage is there for man?independent — rhetorical; יֹתֵר, as in v. 8
v. 12 — closing double rhetorical question, 'who knows' // 'who can tell' (the good now // what comes after): the first half of the book ends
12
AFor who knowscause — rhetorical מִי יוֹדֵעַ, expecting 'no one'
what is good for man in life,content — מַה טּוֹב: the 'good' that the 'better' sayings of ch. 7 take up
during the number of the days of his vapor-life,phrase modifier — accusative of time; חַיֵּי הֶבְלוֹ, 'his fleeting life', hebel again
which he spends like a shadow?relative — וְיַעֲשֵׂם, lit. 'and he makes them'; כַּצֵּל, like a shadow (LXX ἐν σκιᾷ)
BFor who can tell mancause — causal אֲשֶׁר, matching the opening כִּי; מִי יַגִּיד
what will be after him under the sun?content — the future closed to him (3:22; 7:14); refrain 'under the sun'