Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Ecclesiastes 5 — clausal layoutקהלת ה

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentrelativepurposecausecomparativecontentconditionalphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

Guarded Words Before God 5:1–6

v. 1 (English 5:2) — admonitions with motive: two prohibitions (mouth // heart), the ground (God in heaven // you on earth), the conclusion עַל כֵּן

1
 Do not be rash with your mouth,independent — prohibition אַל + jussive, asyndetic after 4:17
 and let your heart not hurry to bring out a word before God;independent — fronted 'your heart'; mouth // heart; infinitive לְהוֹצִיא
 for God is in heavencause — motive clause כִּי: the distance between God and the speaker
 and you are on the earth;cause — heaven // earth, a merism of the whole order, here a contrast of rank
 therefore let your words be few.independent — עַל כֵּן draws the conclusion; דְבָרֶיךָ answers דָבָר

v. 2 — embedded proverb grounding v. 1 (synonymous, the verb gapped): the dream // the fool's voice, בְּרֹב … בְּרֹב

2
AFor the dream comes with much preoccupation,cause — כִּי; עִנְיָן, the book's word for absorbing business
Band the voice of a fool with many words.cause — gapping: בָּא carried over; בְּרֹב repeated

v. 3 — the vow law applied (Deut 23:22): temporal clause, prohibition, motive, then the command restated

3
 When you vow a vow to God,conditional — temporal כַּאֲשֶׁר leaning forward; cognate תִּדֹּר נֶדֶר (Deut 23:22)
 do not delay to pay it,independent — אַל + jussive; לְשַׁלְּמוֹ as in Deuteronomy
 for there is no pleasure in fools;cause — motive clause; God's delight implied; the fools of 4:17
 what you vow, pay.independent — fronted headless relative אֵת אֲשֶׁר as object + imperative שַׁלֵּם: the command restated

v. 4 — 'better … than' (טוֹב … מִן) drawing the consequence (cf. Deut 23:23)

4
 Better that you not vowindependent — טוֹב + אֲשֶׁר clause as subject
 than that you vow and not pay.comparative — the 'than' member: מִן + late relative שֶׁ־ (מִשֶׁתִּדּוֹר)

v. 5 — two prohibitions + a rhetorical question of consequence (לָמָּה)

5
 Do not let your mouth cause your flesh to sin,independent — אַל תִּתֵּן + causative infinitive לַחֲטִיא; 'flesh' = the whole self
 and do not say before the messenger,independent — הַמַּלְאָךְ, a temple functionary (cf. Mal 2:7); LXX πρὸ προσώπου τοῦ θεοῦ, 'before God'
 'It was an error.'content — recitative כִּי; שְׁגָגָה, the category of inadvertent sin (Num 15:22–29)
 Why should God be angry at your voiceindependent — rhetorical לָמָּה: a warning in question form; 'your voice' picks up 'your mouth'
 and destroy the work of your hands?independent — weqatal וְחִבֵּל continuing the question

v. 6 — summary: dreams, vapors and words gathered up, then the climax 'fear God'

6
 For in a multitude of dreams come vapors and words in abundance;cause — elliptical; the unit's keywords gathered (dream v. 2, word vv. 1–2); הֲבָלִים, hebel in the plural
 rather, fear God.independent — adversative כִּי; fronted object + imperative יְרָא: the climax (cf. 3:14; 12:13)

Oppression and the Hierarchy of Officials 5:7–8

v. 7 — conditional admonition + ground: the chain of officials (high over high, and higher over them)

7
 If you see the oppression of the poor and the robbing of justice and righteousness in the province,conditional — אִם protasis, objects fronted before תִּרְאֶה; מְדִינָה, an administrative 'province'
 do not be astonished at the matter,independent — apodosis: prohibition; חֵפֶץ here 'affair'
 for a high one watches over a high one,cause — גָבֹהַּ מֵעַל גָּבֹהַּ: officials stacked; שֹׁמֵר, 'watches', to protect or to spy (LXX φυλάξαι)
 and higher ones are over them.cause — plural גְבֹהִים: further ranks (some hear a hint of the Most High)

v. 8 — cryptic proverb closing the observation: the land's profit and the king

8
 And the advantage of a land in everything is this:independent — יִתְרוֹן (1:3); Kethiv היא, Qere הוּא (gender only)
 a king for a cultivated field.phrase modifier — crux: a king devoted to tilled land (LXX βασιλεὺς τοῦ ἀγροῦ εἰργασμένου), or a king who is himself served by the field

The Lover of Money 5:9–11

v. 9 — synonymous aphorism (silver // abundance, the verb gapped) + the verdict 'this too is vapor'

9
AHe who loves silver will not be satisfied with silver,independent — participle subject אֹהֵב; כֶּסֶף … כֶּסֶף frame the colon
Band whoever loves abundance, with no income;independent — וּמִי, 'whoever'; elliptical, 'is not satisfied' carried over (or: 'has no yield'); the colon break follows the zaqef, while the atnach sets off the verdict
 this too is vapor.independent — gam-formula + הָבֶל

v. 10 — aphorism + rhetorical question: goods multiply consumers; the owner gains only the sight

10
 When good things increase,conditional — temporal בְּ + infinitive בִּרְבוֹת; wordplay רבה … רַבּוּ
 those who consume them increase;independent — apodosis
 and what success is there for their ownerindependent — rhetorical מַה; כִּשְׁרוֹן as in 4:4
 except the seeing of his eyes?phrase modifier — כִּי אִם, 'except'; Kethiv ראית, Qere רְאוּת, two forms of 'seeing'

v. 11 — antithetic aphorism: the laborer's sweet sleep // the rich man's sleeplessness

11
ASweet is the sleep of the laborer,independent — fronted predicate מְתוּקָה
 whether he eats little or much;conditional — אִם … וְאִם, 'whether … or', with the verb held to the end
Bbut the surfeit of the rich manphrase modifier — casus pendens; הַשָּׂבָע, abundance of goods or a full stomach
 does not let him sleep.independent — אֵינֶנּוּ + participle; resumptive לוֹ; sleep (שְׁנַת … לִישׁוֹן) frames the verse

The Sickening Evil of Lost Riches 5:12–16

v. 12 — 'there is' + 'I saw' + 'under the sun' introduce a case: 'a sickening evil' (inclusio with v. 15)

12
 There is a sickening evilindependent — יֵשׁ presents the case; רָעָה חוֹלָה
 I have seen under the sun:relative — asyndetic relative; observation formula רָאִיתִי + refrain 'under the sun'
 riches kept by their owner to his harm.phrase modifier — apposition naming the evil; passive participle שָׁמוּר; לְרָעָתוֹ plays on רָעָה

v. 13 — the case narrated in weqatal: loss, a son, empty hands

13
 And those riches perished in a bad venture;independent — weqatal וְאָבַד as narrative; עִנְיַן רָע (1:13; 4:8)
 and he had fathered a son,independent — weqatal וְהוֹלִיד
 and there is nothing at all in his hand.independent — circumstantial וְאֵין; the son's hand or the father's

v. 14 — the case generalised: out of the womb naked, back naked (cf. Job 1:21)

14
 As he came out of his mother's womb,comparative — comparative כַּאֲשֶׁר leaning forward; 4Q109 reads כיא here
 naked he will return, to goindependent — fronted עָרוֹם; לָלֶכֶת, 'to go', i.e. to die
 as he came;comparative — late כְּשֶׁ־, 'as'
 and he will carry away nothing for his toilindependent — fronted וּמְאוּמָה, echoing v. 13
 that he can take in his hand.relative — relative שֶׁ־; בְּיָדוֹ as in v. 13

v. 15 — verdict 'sickening evil' (inclusio with v. 12) + the programmatic question of profit (1:3)

15
 And this too is a sickening evil:independent — gam-formula with feminine זֹה; 4Q109 preserves גם זה
 exactly as he came,comparative — כָּל עֻמַּת שֶׁ־, 'just as'
 so he will go;phrase modifier — כֵּן answers כָּל עֻמַּת: birth and death matched
 and what profit has heindependent — rhetorical question of יִתְרוֹן (1:3); 4Q109 preserves מה יתרון ל׳ו
 who toils for the wind?relative — cognate relative שֶׁ־ (1:3); לָרוּחַ, an echo of 'a chasing after wind'

v. 16 — closing picture: days in darkness, vexation, sickness

16
 Also all his days he eats in darkness,independent — fronted 'all his days'; LXX ἐν σκότει καὶ πένθει, 'in darkness and mourning', without 'eats'
 and he is much vexed, with his sickness and anger.independent — וְכָעַס as a verb (or noun, 'vexation'); rough syntax; 4Q109 preserves כעס

Enjoyment as God's Gift 5:17–19

v. 17 — הִנֵּה + 'I saw': the counter-conclusion of enjoyment (cf. 2:24; 3:12–13, 22)

17
 Behold, what I myself have seenindependent — הִנֵּה + headless relative; observation formula רָאִיתִי with emphatic אָנִי
 to be good, what is fitting:independent — טוֹב אֲשֶׁר יָפֶה, 'good, which is fitting' (cf. 3:11)
 to eat and to drink and to see good in all his toilcontent — three infinitives, the enjoyment refrain; טוֹבָה answers טוֹב; 4Q109 preserves בכול עמל׳ו
 at which he toils under the sun,relative — cognate relative (1:3); refrain 'under the sun'
 the number of the days of his lifephrase modifier — accusative of time; Kethiv חיו, Qere חַיָּיו (spelling only)
 which God has given him,relative — God as giver (1:13)
 for that is his portion.cause — חֶלְקוֹ, the allotted 'portion' (2:10; 3:22)

v. 18 — the gift extended: wealth + the power to enjoy it = מַתַּת אֱלֹהִים (contrast 6:2)

18
 Also every personphrase modifier — casus pendens, taken up by זֹה
 to whom God has given riches and possessionsrelative — אֲשֶׁר … לוֹ, 'to whom'
 and whom he has empoweredrelative — weqatal וְהִשְׁלִיטוֹ continuing the relative; the power denied in 6:2
 to eat from it,purpose — complementary infinitive
 to take up his portion,purpose — חֶלְקוֹ as in v. 17
 and to rejoice in his toil,purpose — joy in toil, not from it
 this is a gift of God.independent — resumptive זֹה; מַתַּת אֱלֹהִים (3:13)

v. 19 — the ground: joy keeps him from brooding

19
 For he will not much remember the days of his life,cause — כִּי; לֹא הַרְבֵּה, 'not much'
 because God keeps him occupied with the joy of his heart.cause — participle מַעֲנֶה, 'keeps busy' (cf. עִנְיָן; LXX περισπᾷ), or 'answers him'
Analysis. This page follows the Hebrew (and LXX) verse numbers. MT 4:17 is English 5:1, so MT 5:1–19 corresponds to English 5:2–20. Ecclesiastes 5 is accented with the prose system and set as prose, one clause per line. A/B colon labels are kept for the embedded proverbs whose two halves are plainly parallel: the dream // the fool's voice (v. 2), the lover of silver // the lover of abundance (v. 9), and the laborer's sweet sleep // the rich man's sleeplessness (v. 11). The first unit (vv. 1–6) is instruction, so it is laid out as admonitions with their motives. Each prohibition (אַל + jussive) sits flush left, its כִּי motive or temporal clause hangs one step beneath it, and the conclusions (עַל כֵּן 'therefore', the imperative 'pay!', 'fear God') return to the margin. Verses 3–4 apply the vow law of Deut 23:22–23 and turn it into a 'better … than' saying. The observation on officials (vv. 7–8) is a conditional admonition with a ground, followed by the cryptic proverb about the king and the field. The rest of the chapter is labelled by its formulas. The observation formula and the refrain 'under the sun' open the case of lost riches (v. 12), 'this too is vapor' closes the lover of money (v. 9), the 'sickening evil' brackets the case (vv. 12, 15), the question of 'profit' (יִתְרוֹן) returns from 1:3 (v. 15), and the enjoyment passage (vv. 17–19) is opened by הִנֵּה and 'I saw'. The layout takes a side on several cruxes. It reads v. 6 as an elliptical summary capped by an adversative כִּי, 'rather, fear God'. It takes the 'higher ones' of v. 7 as further officials. In v. 8 it sets 'a king for a cultivated field' as an apposition to 'this' and leaves both readings open in the tag. It reads מַעֲנֶה in v. 19 as 'keeps him occupied'. On the witnesses: the LXX follows the MT numbering, renders the 'messenger' of v. 5 as 'before God' (πρὸ προσώπου τοῦ θεοῦ), and reads 'in darkness and mourning' (ἐν σκότει καὶ πένθει) for 'eats in darkness' in v. 16. The Qumran copy 4Q109 (4QQoh^a) survives for vv. 13–17. It opens v. 14 with כיא where the MT has כַּאֲשֶׁר, and it preserves מה יתרון ל׳ו in v. 15, כעס in v. 16 and בכול עמל׳ו in v. 17 in agreement with the MT.