Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Proverbs 28 — clausal layoutמשלי כח

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentcomparativecontentphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

Boldness, Order, and Integrity 28:1–6

v. 1 — antithetic, chiastic: the wicked flee // the righteous are confident; flight with no pursuer // the lion's calm

1
AThe wicked flee when no one pursues,independent — verb first, subject last — the singular רָשָׁע with a plural verb (distributive); וְאֵין רֹדֵף, the imagined pursuer (cf. Lev 26:17, 36)
Bbut the righteous are confident like a young lion.independent — antithetic colon — subject first, verb last: the chiasm; plural צַדִּיקִים with a singular verb; כִּכְפִיר, the only explicit simile

v. 2 — antithetic (political): a rebellious land has many rulers // one discerning man gives lasting order; first of the מֵבִין sayings (vv. 2, 7, 11)

2
AThrough a land's transgression its rulers are many,independent — בְּ of cause fronted — the quick turnover of rulers; the LXX has a different saying ('judgments are stirred up … a shrewd man will quench them')
Bbut through a man who understands and knows, stability endures.independent — antithetic colon — בְּ answers בְּ; כֵּן read as a noun, 'what is right, stability', subject of יַאֲרִיךְ (or adverbial 'so it lasts')

v. 3 — NOT antithetic: emblematic metaphor — the referent (colon A) // the image (colon B), with no 'like'

3
AA poor man who oppresses the poorindependent — the referent — the subject held in suspense; MT רָשׁ, 'poor', often read רָשָׁע, 'wicked' (the LXX: 'a bold man in acts of ungodliness')
Bis a driving rain that leaves no bread.comparative — the image — מָטָר סֹחֵף, a sweeping downpour; וְאֵין לָחֶם: the rain that should feed the crop washes it away

v. 4 — antithetic: forsake instruction // keep instruction; praise the wicked // contend with them; first תּוֹרָה saying (vv. 4, 7, 9)

4
AThose who forsake instruction praise the wicked,independent — construct participle עֹזְבֵי תוֹרָה — teaching or law: the chapter lets both senses sound
Bbut those who keep instruction contend with them.independent — antithetic colon — עֹזְבֵי // שֹׁמְרֵי with the same object; hithpael יִתְגָּרוּ, 'engage in strife' (the LXX: 'put a wall around themselves')

v. 5 — antithetic: evil men do not understand // the seekers of YHWH understand everything; the verb יָבִינוּ repeated

5
AEvil men do not understand justice,independent — אַנְשֵׁי רָע — moral blindness as the mark of evil
Bbut those who seek YHWH understand everything.independent — antithetic colon — the same verb; מִשְׁפָּט // כֹל: the seekers of YHWH see what justice requires and more

v. 6 — NOT antithetic: comparative 'better … than' (a variant of 19:1); the dual דְּרָכַיִם, 'two ways', returns in v. 18

6
ABetter a poor man who walks in his integrityindependent — verbless — טוֹב: the preferred lot; participle הוֹלֵךְ, a whole way of life
Bthan one crooked in his two ways,comparative — the 'than' member — מִן + עִקֵּשׁ: the double-dealer walking two roads at once
 though he is rich.phrase modifier — circumstantial — וְהוּא עָשִׁיר: the poor // the rich laid out as integrity // crookedness (the LXX: 'a rich liar')

Teaching, Wealth, and Discernment 28:7–11

v. 7 — antithetic: keeps instruction // keeps company with gluttons; a discerning son // a shamed father; second תּוֹרָה saying

7
AWhoever keeps instruction is a discerning son,independent — verbless predicate — בֵּן מֵבִין; the father's teaching of chs. 1–9 now named תּוֹרָה
Bbut a companion of gluttons shames his father.independent — antithetic colon — רֹעֶה, 'one who herds with'; זוֹלְלִים as in 23:20–21

v. 8 — NOT antithetic: synthetic, one sentence across both cola — the retribution of reversal (cf. 13:22b)

8
AWhoever increases his wealth by interest and profitindependent — the subject held in suspense — נֶשֶׁךְ and תַּרְבִּית, the interest the law forbids (Exod 22:25; Lev 25:36–37); Kethiv ובתרבית, Qere וְתַרְבִּית, both in the line
Bgathers it for one who is gracious to the poor.independent — the predicate — לְחוֹנֵן דַּלִּים fronted, the verb last: the usurer gathers for the generous

v. 9 — NOT antithetic: synthetic, measure for measure — casus pendens resumed by 'his prayer'; third תּוֹרָה saying

9
AWhoever turns his ear away from hearing instruction,independent — casus pendens — participle מֵסִיר; מִשְּׁמֹעַ, 'from hearing'
Beven his prayer is an abomination.independent — verbless — גַּם: the one who will not hear תּוֹרָה is not heard (cf. 15:8, 29; 1:24–28)

v. 10 — antithetic tricolon: the seducer falls into his own pit (A–B) // the blameless inherit good (C)

10
AWhoever leads the upright astray into an evil wayindependent — casus pendens — hiphil participle מַשְׁגֶּה, the one who misleads
Bwill himself fall into his own pit,independent — resumptive הוּא; בִּשְׁחוּתוֹ fronted — the trap recoils (cf. 26:27)
Cbut the blameless will inherit good.independent — antithetic colon after the atnach — יְשָׁרִים // תְמִימִים; the LXX adds a line: 'the lawless will pass through good things and not enter into them'

v. 11 — antithetic: the rich man wise in his own eyes // the discerning poor man who sees through him; מֵבִין again (vv. 2, 7)

11
AA rich man is wise in his own eyes,independent — verbless, predicate first — חָכָם בְּעֵינָיו (cf. 26:12)
Bbut a poor man who has understanding will search him out.independent — antithetic colon — דַל מֵבִין; יַחְקְרֶנּוּ, 'examines him' and finds him out

Confession, Fear, and Rulers 28:12–18

v. 12 — antithetic refrain (opens; closed by v. 28, taken up in 29:2, 16): the righteous exult // the wicked rise

12
AWhen the righteous exult, there is great glory,independent — בַּעֲלֹץ — temporal בְּ + infinitive, kept in the colon; תִפְאָרֶת, festive splendour (the LXX: 'through the help of the righteous')
Bbut when the wicked rise, people must be searched for.independent — antithetic colon — וּבְקוּם answers בַּעֲלֹץ; pual יְחֻפַּשׂ: people have to be hunted out, for they hide (v. 28)

v. 13 — antithetic: conceals // confesses and forsakes; will not prosper // will obtain mercy

13
AWhoever conceals his transgressions will not prosper,independent — participle subject — מְכַסֶּה פְשָׁעָיו: the only explicit call to confession in Proverbs (cf. Ps 32:1–5)
Bbut whoever confesses and forsakes them will obtain mercy.independent — antithetic colon — two participles, confession joined to forsaking; pual יְרֻחָם (the LXX: 'the one who recounts rebukes will be loved')

v. 14 — antithetic beatitude: אַשְׁרֵי the one who fears continually // the one who hardens his heart

14
ABlessed is the man who fears continually,independent — אַשְׁרֵי formula — participle מְפַחֵד: constant reverent dread
Bbut whoever hardens his heart will fall into calamity.independent — antithetic colon — מַקְשֶׁה לִבּוֹ, the language of Pharaoh; יִפּוֹל as in v. 10

v. 15 — NOT antithetic: emblematic metaphor — two images (colon A) // the referent (colon B), no 'like'

15
AA roaring lion and a charging bearcomparative — the images — two predators in apposition (cf. 19:12; 20:2); the LXX: 'a hungry lion and a thirsty wolf'
Bis a wicked ruler over a poor people.independent — the referent — verbless; מֹשֵׁל רָשָׁע over עַם דָּל: the defenceless as prey

v. 16 — antithetic (implicit): the oppressive leader // the one who hates unjust gain; the ruler theme of v. 15 continued

16
AA leader lacking in discernment is great in oppression;independent — verbless — נָגִיד, revia: a ruler who lacks תְּבוּנוֹת makes it up in extortion (the LXX: 'a king lacking revenues')
Bwhoever hates unjust gain will prolong his days.independent — asyndetic antithetic colon — Kethiv שנאי 'those who hate', Qere שֹׂנֵא, both in the line; בֶצַע, gain by violence

v. 17 — NOT antithetic: observation + prohibition — the bloodguilty fugitive, and the command not to shield him

17
AA man burdened with the blood of a life will flee to the pit;independent — no atnach in this verse — the break falls at the revia on יָנוּס; עָשֻׁק בְּדַם נָפֶשׁ, oppressed by bloodguilt (cf. Gen 4:12–14; Num 35:31)
Blet no one hold him back.independent — prohibition — אַל + jussive: do not shield the murderer (the LXX reads it of the one who goes surety for him, and adds 'Discipline a son, and he will love you')

v. 18 — antithetic: walks blamelessly // crooked in two ways; will be saved // will fall at once; echoes v. 6 (תֹּם, עִקֵּשׁ דְּרָכַיִם)

18
AWhoever walks blamelessly will be saved,independent — participle subject — הוֹלֵךְ תָּמִים; niphal יִוָּשֵׁעַ
Bbut one crooked in his two ways will fall at once.independent — antithetic colon — בְּאֶחָת, 'at once' (or 'in one of them'; some emend to 'into a pit'); the LXX: 'will be entangled'

Work, Greed, and Trust 28:19–27

v. 19 — antithetic, ironic repetition: sated with bread // sated with poverty (near-doublet of 12:11)

19
AWhoever works his land will have plenty of bread,independent — participle subject — עֹבֵד אַדְמָתוֹ; יִשְׂבַּע, 'be sated'
Bbut whoever pursues empty things will have plenty of poverty.independent — antithetic colon — the same verb, turned: לֶחֶם // רִישׁ; 12:11b ends differently

v. 20 — antithetic: the faithful man abounds in blessings // the one who hastens to get rich is not acquitted

20
AA faithful man will abound in blessings,independent — verbless — אִישׁ אֱמוּנוֹת, רַב בְּרָכוֹת
Bbut one who hastens to get rich will not go unpunished.independent — antithetic colon — אָץ לְהַעֲשִׁיר, haste as the sign of crooked gain (cf. v. 22; 13:11; 20:21); לֹא יִנָּקֶה

v. 21 — NOT antithetic: observation — the principle (colon A, = 24:23b) // its cheap betrayal (colon B)

21
ATo show partiality is not good,independent — verbless — הַכֵּר פָּנִים, 'recognizing faces', partiality in judgment; litotes לֹא טוֹב
Byet for a morsel of bread a man will transgress.independent — וְעַל פַּת לֶחֶם fronted — the price of a judge: a crust (the LXX: 'will sell a man for a morsel of bread')

v. 22 — NOT antithetic: observation with ironic outcome — he hastens after wealth // and does not know want is coming

22
AA man with an evil eye hastens after wealth,independent — niphal participle נִבְהָל fronted — רַע עָיִן, the grudging, envious man (cf. 23:6)
Band does not knowindependent — colon B — the blindness of the one in haste
 that want will come upon him.content — object of 'know' — כִּי + yiqtol: חֶסֶר comes toward the one running after הוֹן (the LXX read חֶסֶד: 'the merciful man will master him')

v. 23 — NOT antithetic: comparative 'more than' — honest rebuke // flattery

23
AWhoever rebukes a man will afterward find more favorindependent — participle subject — מוֹכִיחַ אָדָם; אַחֲרַי, pointed 'after me', read 'afterward'
Bthan one who flatters with the tongue.comparative — the 'than' member — מִן + hiphil participle מַחֲלִיק, the smooth tongue (cf. 27:5–6)

v. 24 — NOT antithetic: characterization — a casus pendens with a quoted excuse, then the verdict

24
AWhoever robs his father or his mother and says,independent — casus pendens — two participles, גּוֹזֵל … וְאֹמֵר (cf. 19:26)
 'It is no transgression,'content — the quoted excuse — אֵין פָּשַׁע, the heart of the indictment
Bis a companion to a man who destroys.independent — the verdict — verbless: חָבֵר הוּא, resumptive; אִישׁ מַשְׁחִית, the vandal

v. 25 — antithetic: the greedy stirs up strife // the one who trusts in YHWH is enriched; בּוֹטֵחַ the catchword into v. 26

25
AOne who is greedy stirs up strife,independent — רְחַב נֶפֶשׁ, 'wide of throat': unbounded appetite (cf. 15:18; 29:22)
Bbut whoever trusts in YHWH will be enriched.independent — antithetic colon — pual יְדֻשָּׁן, 'made fat'; grasping // trusting

v. 26 — antithetic: trusts in his own heart // walks in wisdom; a fool // delivered; each colon resumed by הוּא

26
AWhoever trusts in his own heart is a fool,independent — verbless — בּוֹטֵחַ again, now in himself (cf. 3:5–7); resumptive הוּא
Bbut whoever walks in wisdom will be delivered.independent — antithetic colon — resumptive הוּא; niphal יִמָּלֵט

v. 27 — antithetic: gives to the poor // hides his eyes; no lack // many curses

27
AWhoever gives to the poor will not lack,independent — verbless — אֵין מַחְסוֹר: generosity, paradoxically, leaves no want (cf. 11:24–26)
Bbut whoever hides his eyes will have many curses.independent — antithetic colon — verbless; מַעְלִים עֵינָיו, looking away from need (cf. 21:13); רַב מְאֵרוֹת

When the Wicked Rise 28:28

v. 28 — antithetic refrain (closes the inclusio with v. 12; cf. 29:2, 16): the wicked rise, people hide // they perish, the righteous increase

28
AWhen the wicked rise, people hide themselves,independent — בְּקוּם רְשָׁעִים, the words of v. 12b; יִסָּתֵר explains its 'must be searched for' (the LXX: 'in the places of the ungodly the righteous groan')
Bbut when they perish, the righteous increase.independent — antithetic colon — וּבְאָבְדָם: the fall of the wicked lets the righteous multiply; leads into 29:2
Analysis. Proverbs 28 laid out by cola. It opens the second half of the Hezekian collection (chs. 28–29), and the form is again the two-line sentence proverb: colon A states a case and colon B answers it, so nearly every line sits flush at the margin, with the small A/B labels marking the halves at the atnach. The gold label above each verse names its parallelism. Eighteen of the 28 sayings are antithetic, most of them setting the righteous against the wicked, the poor against the rich, or the one who keeps against the one who forsakes. The rest are marked as not antithetic: the emblematic metaphors of the oppressor as a beating rain (v. 3) and the wicked ruler as lion and bear (v. 15), the 'better … than' saying (v. 6), single sentences that run across both cola (vv. 8, 9, 17, 22, 24), the observation of v. 21, and the 'more than' comparison of v. 23. The page steps inward only where the Hebrew subordinates: the 'than' members of vv. 6 and 23, the circumstantial 'though he is rich' (v. 6), the כִּי clause that is the object of 'does not know' (v. 22), and the quoted excuse 'It is no transgression' (v. 24). Three threads bind the chapter, and the labels point them out: תּוֹרָה 'instruction, law' (vv. 4, 7, 9), the discerning man מֵבִין (vv. 2, 7, 11), and the public refrain on the rise of the wicked, which v. 12 opens and v. 28 closes (and 29:2, 16 take up). The sections follow the chapter's thematic clusters. Choices the layout takes: v. 2b reads כֵּן as a noun, 'stability'; v. 3 keeps the MT רָשׁ 'a poor man' (many read רָשָׁע 'wicked'); v. 10 is laid out as a tricolon (the atnach falls after the second colon); v. 17 has no atnach, and the break is placed at the revia on 'will flee'; in v. 18 בְּאֶחָת is read 'at once'; in v. 23 אַחֲרַי is read as 'afterward'. In vv. 8 and 16 the English follows the Qere (וְתַרְבִּית, שֹׂנֵא); the Kethiv forms are printed in the line with them. The Old Greek keeps the chapter's order, but rewrites several sayings: v. 2 is a different saying about judgments quenched by a shrewd man, v. 4 has those who love the law 'put a wall around themselves', v. 10 adds a line on the lawless who pass through good things, v. 16 has 'a king lacking revenues', v. 17 speaks of the one who goes surety for a man guilty of blood and adds 'Discipline a son, and he will love you', and v. 28a reads 'in the places of the ungodly the righteous groan'. In the Greek book these chapters stand later than in the Hebrew, after chs. 30 and 31:1–9. No Qumran manuscript preserves this chapter.