Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Job 9 — clausal layoutאיוב ט

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentparticipialrelativepurposecausecomparativecontentconditionalphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

The frame 9:1

Job's reply to Bildad (chs. 9–10) — first cycle, fourth speech of the dialogue

1
 Then Job answered and said:independent — speech heading — the dialogue formula; the poem below, with ch. 10, is one speech

How can a mortal be right with God? 9:2–4

v. 2 — concession // counter-question: the theme of the speech, in legal terms

2
ATruly, I knowindependent — אָמְנָם — Job grants the friends' axiom
 that it is so;content — כִי content, verbless — 'so' = Bildad's 'God does not pervert justice' (8:3)
Bbut how can a mortal be in the right with God?independent — court term — צָדַק עִם, to be vindicated against an opponent at law; Eliphaz's question (4:17) recast as a lawsuit

v. 3 — the first legal hypothetical: contend (רִיב) → not answer

3
AIf one wished to contend with him,conditional — protasis — court term לָרִיב, to bring a lawsuit; the subject is indefinite
Bhe could not answer him once in a thousand.independent — apodosis — עָנָה, to answer a charge in court; crux: who cannot answer whom (man to God's questions, or God to man's), probably the man

v. 4 — epithets // rhetorical question: wise and mighty, so who resists him unharmed?

4
AWise in heart and mighty in strength —independent — verbless, casus pendens — the epithets of God (less likely of the litigant), left hanging before the question
Bwho has hardened himself against him and come out whole?independent — rhetorical question expecting 'no one'; wayyiqtol וַיִּשְׁלָם, 'and stayed whole'

The overwhelming Creator 9:5–13

vv. 5–10 — hymn in participles (Amos 4:13; 5:8; 9:5–6): mountains, earth, sun and stars, heavens and sea, constellations, wonders

5
AHe who removes mountains, and they do not know it,participial — article + participle הַמַּעְתִּיק — the hymn begins; וְלֹא יָדָעוּ, the mountains overthrown unawares
Bwho overturns them in his anger;relative — אֲשֶׁר on the subject of the participle — or 'when he overturns them', or the content of 'know' ('they do not know that he overturns them'); בְּאַפּוֹ, the hymn's dark note
6
Awho shakes the earth from its place,participial — participle 2 — הַמַּרְגִּיז, earthquake
Bso that its pillars tremble;independent — consequence — the earth on pillars (Ps 75:4)
7
Awho speaks to the sun,participial — participle 3 — הָאֹמֵר; חֶרֶס, a rare poetic word for the sun
 and it does not rise,independent — consequence — creation's order reversed (cf. Job's curse on the night, 3:9)
Band seals up the stars;independent — yiqtol continuing the participle; בְעַד … יַחְתֹּם, the stars shut away as under a seal
8
Awho alone stretches out the heavens,participial — participle 4 — נֹטֶה, creation language (Isa 40:22; 44:24); לְבַדּוֹ, alone
Band treads on the back of Yam;participial — participle 5 — דוֹרֵךְ: the Sea (יָם) as defeated foe; Old Greek 'walks on the sea as on dry ground'
9
Awho made the Bear and Orion and the Pleiades,participial — participle 6 — עֹשֶׂה; the identifications of עָשׁ, כְּסִיל, כִּימָה are uncertain (Old Greek: Pleiades, evening star, Arcturus). No atnach: the colon break is taken at the revia
Band the chambers of the south;phrase modifier — the object list continued, verb gapped — the southern constellations, or storm-chambers (cf. 38:31–32)
10
Awho does great things beyond searching out,participial — participle 7, the summary — Eliphaz's doxology (5:9) almost verbatim, now a complaint
Band wonders beyond number.phrase modifier — object gapped, the עַד אֵין phrase repeated — staircase

vv. 11–13 — the hymn turned to lament: the God who moves the cosmos is unseen, unanswerable, unstoppable

11
ABehold, he passes by me, and I do not see him;independent — הֵן — or 'if' (Aramaic sense; Old Greek ἐάν): 'if he passes by'; יַעֲבֹר, cf. the spirit that passed by Eliphaz (4:15)
Bhe moves on, and I do not perceive him.independent — synonymous — pass // move on (חָלַף, the verb of 4:15), see // perceive
12
ABehold, he snatches away —independent — הֵן again; יַחְתֹּף, a hapax-like verb of seizing
 who can turn him back?independent — rhetorical question 1
BWho can say to him,independent — rhetorical question 2 — the challenge no one may put (Eccl 8:4)
 'What are you doing?'content — the question no subject may ask a king
13
AGod does not turn back his anger;independent — אֱלוֹהַּ fronted — the anger of v. 5 again; Old Greek 'he himself has turned away wrath'
Bbeneath him the helpers of Rahab bowed down.independent — Kethiv תחתו and Qere תַּחְתָּיו side by side; רָהַב, the sea-monster of chaos (26:12; Isa 51:9) and her allies. Old Greek 'the sea-monsters under heaven'

A rigged lawsuit 9:14–24

v. 14 — a fortiori (אַף כִּי): if Rahab's helpers bowed, how much less I — answer // choose words

14
AHow much less could I answer him,independent — אַף כִּי, 'how much less'; court term עָנָה, to answer a charge
Bor choose my words against him?independent — synonymous — arguments chosen for the hearing; עִמּוֹ, 'with him' as opponent

vv. 15–16 — two hypotheticals: in the right yet unheard; heard yet unbelieved

15
AI who, even if I were in the right,conditional — protasis — אֲשֶׁר אִם: the relative resumes 'I' of v. 14; court term צָדַקְתִּי, 'I am in the right'
 could not answer;independent — apodosis — עָנָה again: no reply possible
Bto my accuser I would plead for mercy.independent — court term — לִמְשֹׁפְטִי, 'my opponent at law' (or 'my judge'): God is both; אֶתְחַנָּן, the pleading Bildad advised (8:5)
16
AIf I called and he answered me,conditional — protasis — the summons answered (קָרָא … עָנָה, court terms); wayyiqtol in a protasis
BI would not believeindependent — apodosis
 that he was listening to my voice.content — כִּי content of 'believe' — יַאֲזִין, to give ear

vv. 17–18 — the grounds: present suffering — storm // wounds, no breath // bitterness

17
Afor he crushes me with a tempest,cause — אֲשֶׁר with causal force; יְשׁוּפֵנִי, 'crush' or 'snap at' (cf. Gen 3:15); שְׂעָרָה, perhaps 'for a hair' (a trifle) by another vocalisation
Band multiplies my wounds without cause.cause — חִנָּם — the satan's word (1:9) and YHWH's (2:3): Job unknowingly names the wager
18
AHe will not let me catch my breath,independent — הָשֵׁב רוּחִי — no respite (cf. 7:19)
Bbut fills me with bitterness.independent — כִּי adversative after a negative — 'but rather'

vv. 19–20 — the dilemma in four conditional strokes: strength // justice, in the right // blameless

19
AIf it is a matter of strength,conditional — protasis, verbless — לְכֹחַ
 behold, he is the mighty one!independent — verbless apodosis — אַמִּיץ הִנֵּה, word order inverted for emphasis
BAnd if of justice,conditional — protasis, verbless — court term לְמִשְׁפָּט
 who will summon me?independent — court term — יוֹעִידֵנִי, to set a date and summon to trial; perhaps God's own challenge quoted ('who will summon ME?'); Old Greek 'who will withstand his judgment?'
20
AThough I am in the right,conditional — concessive protasis — אִם + yiqtol; צָדַק again
 my own mouth would condemn me;independent — court term — יַרְשִׁיעֵנִי, 'declare me guilty': his own testimony turned against him
Bthough I am blameless,conditional — concessive, asyndetic and verbless — תָּם אָנִי, the narrator's word (1:1)
 it would declare me perverse.independent — wayyiqtol in a hypothetical, unusual; וַיַּעְקְשֵׁנִי, 'pronounce me crooked'

vv. 21–22 — the oath of integrity and the climax: blameless // the blameless and the wicked alike

21
AI am blameless —independent — verbless — תָּם אָנִי repeated from v. 20, now as a flat declaration. No atnach: the colon break is taken at the revia
 I do not care about myself;independent — לֹא אֵדַע נַפְשִׁי, 'I do not know my soul': I care nothing for what becomes of me
BI loathe my life.independent — asyndetic — the despair of 7:16
22
AIt is all one;independent — verbless — אַחַת הִיא, 'it is one (and the same)'
 therefore I say,independent — עַל כֵּן — the conclusion formally announced
B'He destroys the blameless and the wicked.'content — Job's thesis, quoted as his own verdict — objects fronted; the direct contradiction of Bildad's 8:20 ('God will not reject the blameless'); Old Greek 'wrath destroys the great and mighty'

vv. 23–24 — illustrations: sudden disaster, a corrupted court; tricolon ending in the accusation 'if not he, who?'

23
AWhen a scourge brings sudden death,conditional — temporal protasis — אִם 'when'; שׁוֹט, whip or flood-scourge
Bhe mocks at the despair of the innocent.independent — crux — מַסַּת, 'despair' (melting) or 'trial'; נְקִיִּם, the guiltless
24
AThe earth is given into the hand of the wicked;independent — the land handed over — רָשָׁע, singular; the colon ends at the revia
Bhe covers the faces of its judges.independent — God blindfolds the judges — the court itself corrupted; laid out as a second colon at the revia
CIf it is not he,conditional — protasis — אִם לֹא, verbless and elliptical
 then who is it?independent — אֵפוֹא, 'then'; the accusation pinned on God

Fleeting days and futile cleansing 9:25–31

vv. 25–26 — lament on the brevity of life: runner, reed-boats, eagle — land, water, air

25
AMy days are swifter than a runner;independent — comparative מִנִּי — the royal courier; picks up 7:6–7
Bthey flee away, they see no good.independent — asyndetic verbs — טוֹבָה, the good days of 7:7
26
AThey glide past like boats of reed,independent — חָלַף again; אֳנִיּוֹת אֵבֶה, papyrus skiffs
Blike an eaglecomparative — the third simile — כְּנֶשֶׁר
 that swoops upon its prey.relative — asyndetic relative — יָטוּשׂ. Old Greek: 'Is there a track for ships, or of an eagle flying in search of food?'

vv. 27–28 — hypothetical: the resolve to be cheerful (quoted) // dread and the known verdict

27
AIf I say,conditional — protasis — אִם אָמְרִי, infinitive: 'if my saying is'
 'I will forget my complaint,content — Job quotes his own resolve — cohortative 1; 4QJob^b preserves letters of this colon in agreement with the MT
BI will put off my sad face and be cheerful,'content — cohortatives 2 and 3 — וְאַבְלִיגָה, 'and brighten up'
28
AI dread all my sufferings,independent — apodosis — יָגֹרְתִּי
BI knowindependent — asyndetic — the turn to address God directly
 that you will not hold me innocent.content — כִּי content — court term תְנַקֵּנִי, 'acquit me'; the verdict known in advance
29
AI shall be condemned;independent — אָנֹכִי אֶרְשָׁע — 'I am to be guilty': the sentence already passed
Bwhy then should I labor in vain?independent — הֶבֶל, 'vapour', Qoheleth's word; Old Greek 'why did I not die?'

vv. 30–31 — hypothetical: cleansing undone — snow // lye, pit // clothes

30
AIf I washed myself with snow,conditional — protasis — Kethiv במו 'with' and Qere בְמֵי 'in the water of' side by side
Band cleansed my hands with lye,conditional — protasis continued — בֹר, alkali; washed hands, the gesture of innocence (Ps 26:6)
31
Athen you would plunge me into the pit,independent — apodosis — אָז; second person, God addressed; שַּׁחַת, pit or mire (Old Greek 'filth')
Band my own clothes would abhor me.independent — the grotesque climax — even his garments recoil from him

No arbiter between us 9:32–35

vv. 32–33 — the ground: no equal footing, no arbiter (מוֹכִיחַ)

32
AFor he is not a man like me,independent — כִּי grounding the whole argument; verbless. Old Greek 'you are not a man like me'
 that I might answer him,purpose — asyndetic yiqtol of result — court term עָנָה once more
Bthat we might come together in judgment.purpose — court term — בַּמִּשְׁפָּט: a joint appearance at trial
33
AThere is no arbiter between us,independent — court term — מוֹכִיחַ, one who decides between parties. The crux: MT לֹא יֵשׁ 'there is no'; Old Greek εἴθε ἦν, 'would that there were', as if לוּ. MT kept
Bwho might lay his hand on us both.relative — asyndetic relative — the arbiter's hand on both parties, authority over each; the theme returns as witness (16:19) and redeemer (19:25)

vv. 34–35 — the conditions for a hearing: rod // terror, then speech without fear

34
ALet him remove his rod from me,independent — jussive — שִׁבְטוֹ, the rod of affliction
Band let not dread of him terrify me;independent — synonymous — rod // dread (cf. 13:21)
35
Athen I would speak and not fear him,independent — cohortative אֲדַבְּרָה, 'let me speak'
Bfor I am not so with myself.cause — crux — כִּי לֹא כֵן אָנֹכִי עִמָּדִי: 'I am not like that inside' (not guilty as feared), or 'it is not so with me' (the conditions are not met)
Analysis. Job's reply to Bildad (chs. 9–10), the fourth speech of the first cycle, laid out by cola; this chapter is its first half, spoken mostly about God in the third person, and ch. 10 turns to address him. As on the other Job pages, the prose heading (v. 1) stands in a short section of its own and the poem runs flush-left; only real subordination and speech quoted inside the poem are indented. The speech is a legal argument, and the page makes the courtroom visible. The theme question (v. 2), 'how can a mortal be in the right (יִצְדַּק) with God?', is followed by a chain of legal hypotheticals: if one wished to contend (לָרִיב, v. 3), even if I were in the right (v. 15), if I called and he answered (v. 16), if it is a matter of strength … of justice (v. 19), though I am in the right … blameless (v. 20), if I say (v. 27), if I washed myself (v. 30). Each protasis sits one level in from its apodosis and leans forward on it, so the indented אִם lines show at a glance how often Job reaches for a hearing and how each one closes. The tags name the court terms as they come: רִיב 'contend', עָנָה 'answer' in court, צָדַק 'be in the right', מְשֹׁפְטִי 'my opponent at law', יוֹעִידֵנִי 'summon me', יַרְשִׁיעֵנִי 'condemn me', תְנַקֵּנִי 'acquit me', מִשְׁפָּט, and מוֹכִיחַ 'arbiter'. The hymn of vv. 5–10 is a series of participles (who removes … who shakes … who speaks … who stretches out … who made … who does), laid out as flush-left participial lines with the finite consequences (the mountains do not know, the pillars tremble, the sun does not rise) on the same level; the gapped objects of vv. 9–10 are indented under 'made' and 'does'. Job borrows the doxology form, and v. 10 is almost exactly Eliphaz's 5:9, but he turns the hymn into a complaint, as vv. 11–13 show. The climax is v. 22 ('he destroys the blameless and the wicked'), set as the content of 'I say' and answering Bildad's 8:20. The speech closes on the absence of an arbiter (v. 33). Departures from the accents: vv. 9 and 21 have no atnach, and the colon break is taken at the revia; v. 24 is laid out as a tricolon (A/B/C) at the revia and the atnach. Cruxes flagged, not resolved: who fails to answer whom (v. 3); הֵן as 'behold' or, as in Aramaic and the Old Greek, 'if' (v. 11); the Kethiv/Qere pairs of v. 13 and v. 30 (each pair kept on one line); the identity of the constellations (v. 9); אֲשֶׁר in vv. 5, 15 and 17; whether 'who will summon me?' quotes God (v. 19); מַסַּת 'despair' or 'trial' (v. 23); and the obscure close (v. 35). The greatest crux is v. 33: the MT has לֹא, 'there is no arbiter', while the Old Greek reads 'would that there were our mediator' (as if לוּ). The page follows the MT and notes the alternative. The Old Greek is checked line by line (for example v. 8 'walks on the sea as on dry ground', v. 22 'wrath destroys the great and mighty', v. 29 'why did I not die?'). 4QJob^b (4Q100) preserves letters of v. 27 in agreement with the MT.