Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Job 17 — clausal layoutאיוב יז

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentcausecontentconditionalphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

A broken spirit among mockers 17:1–2

Job's reply continued (cycle 2, speech 2; frame at 16:1) — v. 1: three asyndetic clauses of falling length, spirit // days // graves

1
AMy spirit is broken,independent — רוּחִי חֻבָּלָה — the breath of life itself ruined
 my days are snuffed out;independent — crux — נִזְעָכוּ, a unique Aramaizing by-form of דעך, 'be extinguished'; the verse has no atnach, so its revia is the main break
Bthe graves are mine.independent — verbless — קְבָרִים לִי: the climax, the only possession left; the Old Greek, 'I beg for burial and do not obtain it'

v. 2 — the mockers: mockeries // provocation, with me // my eye

2
ASurely mockeries are with me,independent — verbless — אִם לֹא, the elliptical oath formula 'surely'; הֲתֻלִים, a hapax noun from התל, 'mock'
Band my eye must dwell on their provocation.independent — תָּלַן — the eye 'lodges' all night on the friends' provoking words (הַמְּרוֹתָם)

Plea for a surety; closed minds 17:3–5

vv. 3–4 — legal petition to God: pledge // surety // strike hands, then its ground (closed minds) and consequence (עַל כֵּן)

3
ALay down a pledge, please;independent — שִׂימָה נָּא — the object is unexpressed ('lay it down'); many restore עֶרְבֹנִי, 'my pledge'. Job turns to address God
 be surety for me with yourself.independent — עָרְבֵנִי עִמָּךְ — the legal paradox of 16:19–21 again: God asked to stand bail for Job with God; the Old Greek is wholly different, 'strangers have stolen my possessions'
BWho else is there who will strike hands with me?independent — the handshake of the guarantor (Prov 6:1; 17:18); the expected answer: no one among the friends
4
AFor you have hidden their heart from understanding;cause — כִּי — why no friend will go surety: God has closed their minds; לִבָּם fronted
Btherefore you will not exalt them.independent — עַל כֵּן — the consequence; תְרֹמֵם has no object ('them' supplied), and some read 'you will not let them triumph'

v. 5 — an obscure proverb: informing for a share → the children's eyes fail (its link to the context is disputed)

5
AOne who denounces friends for a share —conditional — implicit protasis — the asyndetic saying 'one informs on friends for a portion…'; probably branding the friends as betrayers; the Old Greek, 'he will announce evils for a share'
Bthe eyes of his children will fail.independent — apodosis — the informer's sin visited on his sons; the Old Greek, 'my eyes have melted away over my children'

A byword, yet the righteous hold on 17:6–9

vv. 6–7 — public shame and its result: byword // spitting, eye // limbs

6
AHe has set me up as a byword of the peoples,independent — וְהִצִּגַנִי — God, unnamed, the agent of the shame (the Old Greek, 'you have made me'); מְשֹׁל, a proverb told about him
Band I have become one in whose face they spit.independent — crux — תֹפֶת, probably 'spitting' (cf. Aramaic tuf); the same spelling as Topheth, but unrelated; the Old Greek, 'a laughingstock'
7
AMy eye has grown dim from grief,independent — wayyiqtol — the physical consequence; כַּעַשׂ, vexation, the word Eliphaz used of the fool (5:2)
Band my limbs, all of them, are like a shadow.independent — verbless — crux: יְצֻרַי, 'my members/forms', found only here; כַּצֵּל, the fading image

vv. 8–9 — wisdom observation, synonymous: upright // innocent // righteous // clean of hands — sincere, ironic, or Job's own resolve?

8
AThe upright are appalled at this,independent — יָשֹׁמּוּ — appalled at Job's ruin; read as irony, these are the friends who count themselves upright
Band the innocent rouses himself against the godless.independent — נָקִי … חָנֵף — the innocent stirred against the godless man the friends take Job to be (15:34); or Job, the innocent, against the friends
9
AYet the righteous holds to his way,independent — וְיֹאחֵז — perseverance in spite of scandal; within Job's speech an implicit self-claim (cf. 27:6). Some take vv. 8–10 as displaced
Band the clean of hands grows in strength.independent — טֳהָר יָדַיִם — clean hands, the claim of 16:17; יֹסִיף אֹמֶץ

Challenge to the friends; hopes snapped 17:10–12

v. 10 — challenge to the friends: come back // I will not find a wise man

10
ABut you — all of you —phrase modifier — וְאוּלָם — a sharp turn; כֻּלָּם is literally 'all of them', third person inside a second-person address (many read כֻּלְּכֶם, as 16:2)
 come back now, come on;independent — imperatives — a dare to renew the argument
BI will not find a wise man among you.independent — the result predicted — חָכָם, the friends' boast of wisdom (15:2, 18) denied them

vv. 11–12 — the snapped plans and the friends' false optimism: days // plans // desires; night → day, light // darkness

11
AMy days have passed by;independent — asyndetic perfects — life already over
 my plans are torn apart,independent — זִמֹּתַי נִתְּקוּ — the threads of purpose snapped
Bthe desires of my heart.phrase modifier — apposition to 'my plans' — crux: מוֹרָשֵׁי, elsewhere 'possessions', here 'the cherished things' of the heart; the Old Greek, 'the sinews of my heart'
12
AThey turn night into day:independent — subject probably the friends, who keep promising restoration (Zophar, 11:17: darkness will be like morning)
B'Light is near' —content — the friends' cheerful slogan quoted back at them — אוֹר קָרוֹב
 in the face of darkness.phrase modifier — מִפְּנֵי חֹשֶׁךְ — 'before (the advance of) darkness', or 'nearer than darkness'

Sheol as home: where is my hope? 17:13–16

vv. 13–15 — a conditional chain: four 'if' clauses (house // bed, father // mother and sister), then the apodosis — hope // hope

13
AIf I hope for Sheol as my house,conditional — protasis — אִם אֲקַוֶּה: the friends' word 'hope' (4:6; 11:18) applied to the grave
Bif in darkness I have spread out my bed,conditional — protasis continued — the grave as bedroom (cf. Ps 139:8)
14
Aif to the Pit I have cried,conditional — protasis continued — לַשַּׁחַת, the Pit as a person addressed
 'You are my father,'content — the cry quoted — the underworld replaces the family Job has lost
B'My mother' and 'My sister'content — gapping — the verb of crying carried over; the kinship words a bitter parody of belonging
 to the worm,conditional — לָרִמָּה — the worm as mother and sister; the Qumran Targum (11Q10) preserves the end of its word for 'worm'
15
Awhere, then, is my hope?independent — apodosis — וְאַיֵּה אֵפוֹ; the Qumran Targum keeps 'and where then' (ומא אפו)
BAnd my hope — who will see it?independent — תִקְוָתִי repeated and fronted — no one will see it; the Old Greek, 'and shall I see my good things?'

v. 16 — the closing question: down to Sheol // onto the dust, together

16
AWill they go down to the bars of Sheol,independent — the feminine plural verb takes Job's 'hopes' as subject; crux: בַּדֵּי שְׁאֹל, 'the bars of Sheol' — the Qumran Targum (עמי לשאול) and the Old Greek (μετ' ἐμοῦ εἰς ᾅδην) read 'with me to Sheol'
Bwhen together we descend onto the dust?independent — crux — אִם, 'when' or 'or'; נָחַת, 'rest' or 'descent'; the Targum seems to read 'shall we lie down', but its letters there are damaged
Analysis. The second half of Job's reply to Eliphaz (cycle 2, speech 2, framed at 16:1). The chapter has no heading of its own, so the poem continues flush-left from ch. 16, one colon per line. It is a dying man's lament, broken by short turns of address: to God (vv. 3–4, the plea for a surety), to the friends (v. 10, the challenge), and about the friends (v. 12, where their cheerful 'light is near' is quoted back at them and set one step in as their words). Five movements. (1) The collapse, vv. 1–2: three clauses of falling length end on the bare 'graves are mine', and the oath-formula אִם לֹא, 'surely', sets the mockers beside him. (2) The plea for a surety, vv. 3–5: Job asks God to post a pledge for him with God himself. This is the legal paradox of 16:19–21 again (God against God), and the page names it as such. The ground, God's closing of the friends' minds, is set one step in, and an obscure proverb about informers follows (v. 5). (3) The public shame, vv. 6–9: byword and spitting, the dimmed eye. Then two cola about the upright and the righteous (vv. 8–9) that may be sincere, ironic, or Job's resolve; they are kept flat and the choice is flagged. (4) The challenge and the snapped plans, vv. 10–12. (5) Sheol as home, vv. 13–16: a chain of conditions, set as forward-leaning protases ('if I hope for Sheol as my house… if to the Pit I have cried "You are my father"'), with the cries to the Pit and the worm nested as quoted words. The apodosis is the double question of v. 15, 'where then is my hope?', and the chapter ends on a last question about going down to the dust. Job takes up the friends' word 'hope' (תִּקְוָה, 4:6; 11:18) and buries it with himself. The A/B labels follow the poetic accents. Verse 1 has no atnach; its revia is the main break, and its first colon holds two clauses. Cruxes flagged in the tags: the Aramaizing נִזְעָכוּ (v. 1); the hapax הֲתֻלִים (v. 2); the unexpressed object of 'lay down' (v. 3); the objectless תְרֹמֵם (v. 4); the proverb of v. 5, which the Old Greek renders quite differently; תֹפֶת, 'spitting' (v. 6); the hapax יְצֻרַי (v. 7); the third-person כֻּלָּם in a second-person address (v. 10); מוֹרָשֵׁי (v. 11); and v. 16 (בַּדֵּי, 'bars', and נָחַת). The Qumran Targum of Job (11Q10, col. 1) begins here. It preserves the Aramaic of the question 'where then' in v. 15, and in v. 16 it reads 'with me to Sheol' (עמי לשאול), as the Old Greek does (μετ' ἐμοῦ εἰς ᾅδην), against MT 'to the bars of Sheol'.