Sentence Flow · Clause Structure · English

Hosea 5 — clausal layoutהושע ה

The same clause-by-clause layout, line-aligned with the Hebrew edition: each line renders one clause or discrete phrase, colored by the Hebrew clause's syntactic type, with indentation marking levels of subordination.

independentpurposecausecomparativecontentconditionalphrase modifierdashed = verbless / suspended

Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped indent columns.)

Summons to the Leaders 5:1–2

v. 1 — call to hear: three imperatives // three addressees (priests, house of Israel, house of the king); then verdict and charge: snare // net, Mizpah // Tabor

1
AHear this, O priests!independent — שִׁמְעוּ זֹ֨את — call to hear (cf. 4:1); the priests named first, as in 4:4–10
 Pay attention, O house of Israel!independent — synonymous — הִקְשִׁיב; the people at large
 Give ear, O house of the king!independent — third member — vocative fronted, imperative last; the royal court
 For the judgment concerns you:cause — כִּי + nominal clause — הַמִּשְׁפָּ֑ט 'is for you': the justice they owed and the sentence they now receive
Bfor you have been a snare at Mizpah,cause — second כִּי — the charge in hunting imagery: leaders who trap their own people
 and a net spread out on Tabor.cause — synonymous — פַח // רֶשֶׁת, Mizpah // Tabor, the verb gapped; the Greek 'at the watchtower … over Itabyrion'

v. 2 — an obscure colon (the revolters' deep slaughter) // YHWH's answer: 'but I am discipline'

2
AAnd the revolters have gone deep into slaughter,independent — crux — שַׁחֲטָה occurs only here; שֵׂטִים 'revolters' (cf. Ps 101:3), or by emendation 'they have dug deep the pit of Shittim', a third place after Mizpah and Tabor (cf. 9:9); the Greek 'which the hunters of game fixed'
Bbut I am chastisement to all of them.independent — disjunctive וַאֲנִי — YHWH set over against all the guilty; מוּסָר 'discipline'; the Greek 'your disciplinarian'

A People That Cannot Return 5:3–7

v. 3 — chiasm: I know Ephraim // Israel not hidden from me; then the knowledge itself: Ephraim played the harlot // Israel defiled

3
AI know Ephraim,independent — אֲנִי fronted — YHWH knows them, though they do not know him (v. 4)
 and Israel is not hidden from me;independent — synonymous, put negatively — נִכְחַד 'hidden'
Bfor now, O Ephraim, you have played the harlot;content — כִּי — what is not hidden (or causal 'for'); עַתָּה; the sudden 2ms address to Ephraim
 Israel is defiled.content — synonymous, asyndetic — זָנָה // נִטְמָא, Ephraim // Israel again

v. 4 — diagnosis: their deeds block the return; כִּי: a spirit of harlotry within // YHWH not known

4
ATheir deeds do not permit themindependent — לֹא יִתְּנוּ — their own habits have become the prison
 to return to their God,content — infinitive complement — לָשׁוּב, Hosea's key verb (6:1; 14:2)
Bfor a spirit of harlotry is within them,cause — nominal clause — the רוּחַ זְנוּנִים of 4:12 now lodged within
 and YHWH they do not know.cause — object fronted — the knowledge missing in 4:1, 6

v. 5 — pride as witness; then the stumbling (cf. 4:5): Israel and Ephraim // Judah too; the first colon recurs at 7:10

5
AThe pride of Israel testifies to his face;independent — וְעָנָה — 'answer, testify against' in court; the Greek 'shall be humbled' (another root עָנָה)
BIsrael and Ephraim stumble in their iniquity;independent — yiqtol — the stumbling of the priest (4:5) now national
 Judah also stumbles with them.independent — climactic extension — גַּם יְהוּדָה: the south drawn into the same fall

v. 6 — futile pilgrimage: go to seek // not find; he has withdrawn

6
AWith their flocks and with their herds they goindependent — means fronted — sacrificial animals in place of knowledge (6:6)
 to seek YHWH,purpose — infinitive of purpose — בִּקֵּשׁ, the seeking v. 15 will demand in earnest
 but they will not find him;independent — וְלֹא — the pilgrimage fails
Bhe has withdrawn from them.independent — asyndetic qatal — חָלַץ 'pull away', anticipating v. 15; the Greek adds 'because'

v. 7 — marital betrayal: faithless to YHWH, alien children; then the verdict: the new moon devours

7
AThey have dealt treacherously with YHWH,independent — object fronted; בָּגַד, the language of marital faithlessness (Jer 3:20)
 for they have borne alien children;cause — בָנִים זָרִים — offspring of the Baal cult (cf. 2:6)
Bnow the new moon shall devour them together with their portions.independent — uncertain text — the festival day (2:13) as agent or time of ruin; the Greek 'blight shall devour them and their allotted portions'

Alarm in Benjamin 5:8–12

v. 8 — battle alarm: horn // trumpet, a chain of towns Gibeah → Ramah → Beth-aven, ending in the war cry

8
ABlow the horn in Gibeah,independent — imperative — the alarm of war (Joel 2:1); a new oracle; Gibeah, Saul's town
 the trumpet in Ramah!independent — gapping — תִּקְעוּ carried over; שׁוֹפָר // חֲצֹצְרָה; the Greek reads the names as 'hills' and 'heights'
BSound the alarm at Beth-aven:independent — Beth-aven = Bethel (4:15) — the alarm moves north
 'Behind you, Benjamin!'content — the old battle cry (Judg 5:14) — vocative; the Greek 'Benjamin is beside himself'

v. 9 — verdict on Ephraim // YHWH certifies it before the tribes

9
AEphraim shall become a desolationindependent — subject fronted — שַׁמָּה, the land laid waste
 on the day of rebuke;phrase modifier — תּוֹכֵחָה — legal reproof: the day of sentence
Bamong the tribes of Israel I declare what is sure.independent — הוֹדַעְתִּי — a declaration before witnesses; נֶאֱמָנָה 'what is reliable'; the Greek 'I showed faithful things'

v. 10 — crime // punishment: boundary-movers // wrath poured like water

10
AThe princes of Judah have becomeindependent — Judah's officials indicted
 like those who move a boundary stone;comparative — the cursed crime of Deut 19:14; 27:17 — land seized in war?
Bupon them I will pour out my wrath like water.independent — עֲלֵיהֶם fronted; a flood answers the shifted boundary

v. 11 — two passive participles (oppressed // crushed) + a כִּי ground whose object is obscure

11
AEphraim is oppressed,independent — passive participle first — עָשׁוּק; the Greek has active verbs, 'Ephraim oppressed his adversary'
 crushed in judgment,independent — synonymous — עָשׁוּק וְרָצוּץ, the covenant curse of Deut 28:33
Bbecause he was determinedcause — כִּי + הוֹאִיל 'resolve, set out'
 to go after 'command'.content — asyndetic finite complement; obscure — צָו perhaps a mocking 'command' (cf. Isa 28:10) or, emended, שָׁוְא 'vanity'; the Greek 'after vanities'

v. 12 — emblematic: moth // rot, Ephraim // house of Judah — YHWH as the hidden decay

12
ABut I am like a moth to Ephraim,independent — emphatic וַאֲנִי + nominal clause — עָשׁ 'moth' (or 'pus'); the Greek 'turmoil'
Band like rot to the house of Judah.independent — gapping — רָקָב, rot in wood or bone; the Greek 'like a goad'

False Healing and the Lion's Withdrawal 5:13–15

v. 13 — narrative indictment: saw sickness // wound, went // sent (wayyiqtol chain); then the verdict: cannot heal // will not cure

13
AWhen Ephraim saw his sickness,independent — wayyiqtol — the chain opens on the diagnosis
 and Judah his wound,independent — gapping — verb carried over; חָלְי // מָזוֹר
 Ephraim went to Assyriaindependent — wayyiqtol — the political remedy (2 Kgs 15:19–20; 17:3)
 and sent to the great king;independent — מֶלֶךְ יָרֵב — 'King Jareb' (the Greek 'King Iarim') or 'the great king', the Assyrian title; Judah too sent (2 Kgs 16:7)
Bbut he is not ableindependent — disjunctive וְהוּא — the address turns to 2mp
 to heal you,content — infinitive complement — רָפָא, the healing only YHWH gives (6:1; 7:1)
 and will not cure you of your wound.independent — יִגְהֶה; מָזוֹר repeated — the wound stays open

v. 14 — lion simile: lion // young lion, Ephraim // house of Judah; then the attack: tear, go, carry off — no one rescues

14
AFor I will be like a lion to Ephraim,independent — כִּי — why Assyria cannot heal; nominal clause; the Greek 'panther' for שַׁחַל
 and like a young lion to the house of Judah.independent — gapping — כְּפִיר; image escalates from decay (v. 12) to predator
BI, I myself will tear and go away;independent — doubled אֲנִי אֲנִי — the predator himself
 I will carry off,independent — asyndetic — the prey dragged to the lair
 and there will be no one to rescue.independent — אֵין מַצִּיל — the formula of helplessness (Deut 32:39; Ps 50:22)

v. 15 — withdrawal with a limit: go // return to my place; until they bear guilt // seek my face; in distress they will seek me

15
AI will go and return to my place,independent — the lion back in its lair; cohortative אָשׁוּבָה
 until they acknowledge their guilt and seek my face;conditional — עַד אֲשֶׁר — the term set to the withdrawal; the Greek 'until they are destroyed'
Bin their distress they will seek me earnestly.independent — שִׁחֵר 'seek at dawn, eagerly' — leads straight into 6:1–3; the Greek adds 'saying', making 6:1–3 their words
Analysis. Hosea 5 is prophetic poetry in two oracles, and the page sets it colon by colon with A/B labels. Hosea carries the prose accents, so the colon break is chosen by parallelism; it falls at the atnach in every verse here. The first oracle (vv. 1–7) opens with a call to hear: three imperatives and three addressees (priests, house of Israel, royal house). The two כִּי clauses that follow are the only deep nesting in it, the verdict 'is for you' and then the charge (snare // net, Mizpah // Tabor). After that the lines run flat: YHWH's knowledge of Ephraim set against Israel's not knowing him (vv. 3–4), the pride that testifies, the stumbling that draws in Judah, and a pilgrimage with flocks that finds a God who has withdrawn. The second oracle (vv. 8–15) begins as a war alarm passed from Gibeah to Ramah to Beth-aven, often set in the Syro-Ephraimite war; that setting is inferred, not stated. It moves through Ephraim's desolation, Judah's boundary-moving princes, and the two images of YHWH as hidden decay (moth // rot, v. 12) and open predator (lion // young lion, v. 14). Between them stands v. 13, a short wayyiqtol narrative of the embassy to Assyria. The chapter ends on a limit: 'until they bear their guilt and seek my face'. Subordination is marked only where it is real: purpose and complement infinitives (vv. 4, 6, 13), the עַד אֲשֶׁר clause (v. 15), the כִּי grounds. Cruxes, all flagged in the tags: v. 2 is obscure, and the layout keeps the MT 'revolters … slaughter' and notes the emendation 'the pit of Shittim'. In v. 5 וְעָנָה is read as 'testifies' (the Greek 'be humbled'). In v. 7 'the new moon shall devour them' is kept and marked uncertain. In v. 11 צָו is left as an obscure 'command'. In v. 13 מֶלֶךְ יָרֵב is taken as 'the great king'. Greek readings are cited from the Rahlfs text. Of the Qumran witnesses, only 4Q78 touches this chapter (5:1), and it is almost entirely reconstruction.