Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
The Proverb Revoked 18:1–4
1
The word of YHWH came to me, saying:independent — word-event formula — the disputation that follows is YHWH's speech, set flush-left
vv. 2–4 — disputation: the opponents' saying quoted (v. 2) // the counter-thesis sworn (vv. 3–4)
2
What do you mean, you who use this proverbindependent — rhetorical question מַה לָּכֶם + participle; LXX adds υἱὲ ἀνθρώπου 'son of man'
about the land of Israel,phrase modifier — LXX ἐν τοῖς υἱοῖς Ισραηλ 'among the sons of Israel'
saying:phrase modifier — לֵאמֹר — introduces the quoted saying
'The fathers eat sour grapes,content — the proverb, colon A — yiqtol of the timeless maxim
and the sons' teeth are set on edge'?content — colon B — fathers // sons; Jer 31:29 cites the same saying
3
As I live,independent — oath formula חַי אָנִי
declares the Lord YHWH,phrase modifier — oracle formula
you shall surely no longer have occasion to use this proverb in Israel.independent — elliptical oath אִם = 'surely not' — the proverb revoked
4
Behold, all souls are mine;independent — הֵן — the ground: YHWH owns every נֶפֶשׁ; verbless, הֵנָּה resumptive
as the soul of the father, so the soul of the son — mine they are.independent — כְּ … וּכְ 'as … so' — father and son held equal
The soul who sins, it shall die.independent — the thesis — subject fronted and resumed by הִיא; returns word for word in v. 20
Case One: The Righteous Man 18:5–9
vv. 5–9 — case one, the righteous man: protasis (v. 5) → list of deeds (vv. 6–9a) → verdict (v. 9b)
5
Now a man — if he is righteousconditional — case-law opening וְאִישׁ כִּי — fronted subject + כִּי, as in priestly law
and does justice and righteousness —conditional — weqatal continuing the protasis; the pair is spelled out in the list below
vv. 6–9a — list: what 'justice and righteousness' is — cult and sex (v. 6), the poor (v. 7), money and courts (v. 8), summary (v. 9a)
6
he does not eat upon the mountains,phrase modifier — item 1 — phrase fronted + לֹא; shrine meals on the high places
nor lift up his eyes to the idols of the house of Israel;phrase modifier — item 2 — גִּלּוּלִים, Ezekiel's contempt word for idols
he does not defile his neighbour's wife,phrase modifier — item 3 — Lev 18:20
nor approach a woman in her impurity;phrase modifier — item 4 — Lev 18:19; 20:18
7
he oppresses no one,phrase modifier — item 5 — ינה Hiphil
he restores to the debtor his pledge;phrase modifier — item 6 — the positive duty; Exod 22:25–26; Deut 24:12–13
he commits no robbery;phrase modifier — item 7 — cognate object
he gives his bread to the hungryphrase modifier — item 8 — charity; cf. Isa 58:7
and covers the naked with a garment;phrase modifier — item 9
8
he does not lend at interestphrase modifier — item 10 — נֶשֶׁךְ, Lev 25:36–37
nor take increase;phrase modifier — item 11 — תַּרְבִּית
he withholds his hand from injustice,phrase modifier — item 12 — 'from injustice'; contrast 'from the poor' in v. 17
and executes true justice between man and man;phrase modifier — item 13 — the judicial duty
9
he walks in my statutesphrase modifier — summary item — the divine first person surfaces: 'my statutes'
and keeps my ordinances by acting faithfully —phrase modifier — summary item — infinitive of manner, לַעֲשׂוֹת + 'truth'
v. 9b — verdict: declaration + promise of life
he is righteous;independent — declaratory formula צַדִּיק הוּא — the priest's verdict
he shall surely live,independent — infinitive absolute חָיֹה יִחְיֶה — the counterpart of מוֹת יוּמָת
declares the Lord YHWH.phrase modifier — oracle formula
Case Two: The Violent Son 18:10–13
vv. 10–13 — case two, the violent son: protasis (v. 10) → the father's list inverted (vv. 11–13a) → verdict (v. 13b)
10
But if he fathers a son who is violent, a shedder of blood,conditional — weqatal וְהוֹלִיד as protasis; 'a violent son' + participle in apposition
and does any one of these things —conditional — crux: אָח ('ah!'? dittography of אַחַד? אַךְ?); LXX simply καὶ ποιοῦντα ἁμαρτήματα 'and doing sins'
11
(though he himself did none of these things) —phrase modifier — circumstantial וְהוּא + qatal — the righteous father; LXX 'in the way of his righteous father he did not walk'
vv. 11b–13a — list: the father's catalogue turned inside out
but even eats upon the mountains,phrase modifier — כִּי גַם 'but even' — the list resumes; item 1 of v. 6 inverted
and defiles his neighbour's wife,phrase modifier — v. 6 item 3 inverted
12
oppresses the poor and needy,phrase modifier — sharpened: 'the poor and needy' for v. 7's 'anyone'
commits robbery,phrase modifier — cognate plural object
does not restore the pledge,phrase modifier — v. 7 item 6 negated
lifts up his eyes to the idols,phrase modifier — v. 6 item 2 inverted
commits abomination,phrase modifier — summary label תּוֹעֵבָה
13
lends at interestphrase modifier — v. 8 item 10 inverted
and takes increase —phrase modifier — v. 8 item 11 inverted
v. 13b — verdict: question and answer, death formula, blood formula
shall he then live?independent — וָחָי — the verdict put as a question, without הֲ
He shall not live!independent — the answer — v. 9's promise denied
All these abominations he has done;independent — object fronted — the ground of the sentence
he shall surely be put to death;independent — death formula מוֹת יוּמָת of the law (Exod 21:12–17; Lev 20)
his blood shall be upon himself.independent — blood-guilt formula דָּמָיו בּוֹ יִהְיֶה (Lev 20:9–16) — his father's righteousness does not cover him
Case Three: The Grandson Who Sees 18:14–18
vv. 14–17 — case three, the grandson who sees: protasis (v. 14) → the righteous list restored (vv. 15–17a) → verdict (v. 17b)
14
But behold, he fathers a sonconditional — וְהִנֵּה + qatal — the third generation presented
who sees all the sins of his fatherconditional — wayyiqtol continuing the protasis — 'see', the key verb of this case
that he did;relative — אֲשֶׁר
he considers,conditional — וַיִּרְאֶה doubles וַיַּרְא — seeing becomes judgment; LXX καὶ φοβηθῇ 'and fears' (ירא for ראה)
and does not do likewise —conditional — וְלֹא + yiqtol; the list below spells it out
vv. 15–17a — list: the righteous man's catalogue restored, in reported perfects
15
he does not eat upon the mountains,phrase modifier — v. 6 item 1 again, with עַל for אֶל
nor lift up his eyes to the idols of the house of Israel;phrase modifier — v. 6 item 2 verbatim
he does not defile his neighbour's wife;phrase modifier — v. 6 item 3; the impurity item is absent
16
he oppresses no one,phrase modifier — v. 7 item 5
exacts no pledge,phrase modifier — cognate object — beyond v. 7: he takes no pledge at all
commits no robbery;phrase modifier — v. 7 item 7
he gives his bread to the hungryphrase modifier — v. 7 item 8
and covers the naked with a garment;phrase modifier — v. 7 item 9
17
he withholds his hand from the poor,phrase modifier — MT 'from the poor' where v. 8 has 'from injustice'; the LXX reads ἀπ' ἀδικίας here too
takes no interest or increase,phrase modifier — v. 8 items 10–11 combined
performs my ordinancesphrase modifier — summary item
and walks in my statutes —phrase modifier — summary item — chiastic to v. 9 (statutes … ordinances // ordinances … statutes)
v. 17b — verdict: inherited guilt denied, life promised
he — he shall not die for his father's iniquity;independent — fronted הוּא; the thesis of v. 4 applied: בַּעֲוֹן אָבִיו
he shall surely live.independent — v. 9's promise repeated
v. 18 — coda: the second generation's verdict in the light of the third
18
As for his father —independent — fronted אָבִיו, resumed by the verdict below
because he practised extortion,cause — כִּי causal; cognate object
committed robbery against a brother,cause — cognate object again; the LXX lacks 'brother'
and did what is not good among his people —cause — headless אֲשֶׁר clause as object; LXX 'my people'
behold, he dies for his own iniquity.independent — וְהִנֵּה + participle — the verdict as fact; 'his own' iniquity, not his son's
The Objection and the Principle 18:19–20
v. 19 — disputation: the hearers' objection quoted → answered from case three
19
Yet you say,independent — weqatal וַאֲמַרְתֶּם — the objection anticipated
'Why does the son not bear the iniquity of the father?'content — the sour-grapes proverb put as a question
When the son has done justice and righteousness,conditional — disjunctive וְהַבֵּן + qatal — the answer framed as the case already decided; objects fronted
and has kept all my statutes and done them,conditional — qatal + wayyiqtol continuing the protasis
he shall surely live.independent — the verdict of v. 9 again
v. 20 — the principle as law: thesis (v. 4) → two chiastic denials (Deut 24:16) → two assignments
20
The soul who sins, it shall die.independent — v. 4b verbatim
A son shall not bear the iniquity of the father,independent — Deut 24:16
nor shall a father bear the iniquity of the son;independent — chiasm son/father // father/son
the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him,independent — each verdict assigned to its own bearer
and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him.independent — Kethiv רשע / Qere הָרָשָׁע (with article) side by side; righteousness // wickedness
Turning Changes the Verdict 18:21–24
vv. 21–22 — case four, the wicked who turns: protasis → verdict → elaboration
21
But the wicked man — if he turns from all his sinsconditional — case form וְהָרָשָׁע כִּי as in v. 5; שׁוּב, the key word from here on; Kethiv sg / Qere pl 'sins'
that he has committed,relative — אֲשֶׁר
and keeps all my statutesconditional — weqatal continuing the protasis
and does justice and righteousness,conditional — v. 5's pair
he shall surely live;independent — infinitive absolute — the promise
he shall not die.independent — the promise doubled, positive // negative
22
All his transgressionsindependent — subject fronted
that he has committedrelative — אֲשֶׁר
shall not be remembered against him;independent — Niphal — the language of the divine record; the predicate after the relative
for his righteousnessindependent — בְּ of ground, fronted
that he has donerelative — אֲשֶׁר
he shall live.independent — the verdict
v. 23 — the centre of the chapter: two rhetorical questions, 'no' // 'yes' (again in v. 32 and 33:11)
23
Do I indeed delight in the death of the wicked,independent — הֲ + infinitive absolute הֶחָפֹץ אֶחְפֹּץ — expects 'no'
declares the Lord YHWH,phrase modifier — oracle formula
and not rather in his turning from his ways,independent — הֲלוֹא — expects 'yes'; the verb gapped; LXX ἐκ τῆς ὁδοῦ τῆς πονηρᾶς 'from the evil way'
that he may live?purpose — weqatal וְחָיָה of result
v. 24 — case five, the righteous who turns away: the mirror of vv. 21–22
24
But when a righteous man turns away from his righteousness and does injustice,conditional — temporal בְּ + infinitive, then weqatal — the turn reversed
according to all the abominationsphrase modifier — the standard of his acts
that the wicked man did,relative — אֲשֶׁר + qatal
he acts —conditional — yiqtol יַעֲשֶׂה resuming the protasis after its long modifier
shall he live?independent — וָחָי as in v. 13; absent from the LXX
All his righteous deedsindependent — subject fronted; Kethiv צדקתו (sg) / Qere צִדְקֹתָיו (pl)
that he has donerelative — אֲשֶׁר
shall not be remembered;independent — Niphal — the mirror of v. 22
For his treacheryindependent — מַעַל, covenant breach — fronted, resumed by בָּם
that he has committedrelative — אֲשֶׁר + cognate verb
and for his sinindependent — second fronted ground
that he has sinned —relative — אֲשֶׁר + cognate verb
for them he shall die.independent — בָּם resumes both grounds — the verdict
Whose Way Is Not Fair? 18:25–29
v. 25 — disputation: the people's charge // YHWH's counter-charge in two questions
25
Yet you say,independent — weqatal, as v. 19
'The way of the Lord is not fair.'content — לֹא יִתָּכֵן 'not weighed true' — the charge of arbitrary judgment
Hear now,independent — call to hear שִׁמְעוּ נָא
O house of Israel:phrase modifier — vocative
Is it my way that is not fair?independent — הֲ — the charge thrown back
Is it not your ways that are not fair?independent — הֲלֹא — the crooked measure is theirs
vv. 26–28 — the two turning cases restated: righteous → death // wicked → life
26
When a righteous man turns away from his righteousness and does injusticeconditional — temporal בְּ + infinitive, as v. 24
and dies for them,conditional — weqatal continuing the protasis; 'for them' = his unjust acts; the LXX lacks it
for his injusticeindependent — fronted ground
that he has donerelative — אֲשֶׁר
he shall die.independent — the verdict
27
And when a wicked man turns away from his wickednessconditional — temporal, as v. 26
that he has committedrelative — אֲשֶׁר
and does justice and righteousness,conditional — wayyiqtol continuing the protasis
he shall save his life.independent — fronted הוּא + Piel 'keep alive' with נַפְשׁוֹ — the turner the agent of his survival
28
Because he considered and turned away from all his transgressionscause — wayyiqtols read as the ground; seeing before turning, as the grandson in v. 14; LXX lacks 'he considered'; Kethiv וישוב / Qere וַיָּשָׁב
that he had committed,relative — אֲשֶׁר
he shall surely live;independent — the promise of v. 21
he shall not die.independent — doubled, as v. 21
v. 29 — charge and counter-charge repeated: inclusio with v. 25 round the restated cases
29
Yet the house of Israel says,independent — now in the third person
'The way of the Lord is not fair.'content — v. 25's charge verbatim
Are my ways not fair,independent — הֲ — the charge thrown back
O house of Israel?phrase modifier — vocative
Is it not your ways that are not fair?independent — plural 'ways' with singular יִתָּכֵן — the MT's disagreement kept
Call to Repent and Live 18:30–32
v. 30 — לָכֵן: judgment announced, then turned into the call to repent
30
Therefore each according to his ways I will judge you,independent — לָכֵן, the usual hinge to judgment; 'each according to his ways' fronted — judgment one by one
O house of Israel,phrase modifier — vocative
declares the Lord YHWH.phrase modifier — oracle formula
Turn, and turn away from all your transgressions,independent — Qal + Hiphil of one root, שׁוּבוּ וְהָשִׁיבוּ
so that iniquity may not be a stumbling block to you.purpose — וְלֹא + yiqtol of result; Ezekiel's phrase (7:19; 14:3–7); LXX εἰς κόλασιν ἀδικίας 'for punishment of injustice'
vv. 31–32 — the call: command // plea // ground // final imperatives
31
Cast away from yourselves all your transgressionsindependent — imperative
that you have committed,relative — אֲשֶׁר; LXX adds εἰς ἐμέ 'against me'
and make yourselves a new heart and a new spirit!independent — the demand — where 11:19 and 36:26 promise God's gift
Why will you die,independent — the plea — וְלָמָּה
O house of Israel?phrase modifier — vocative
32
For I take no pleasure in the death of the one who dies,cause — כִּי grounds the plea; v. 23 widened from 'the wicked' to 'the one who dies'
declares the Lord YHWH.phrase modifier — oracle formula
So turn, and live!independent — the closing imperatives; the LXX lacks them and ends at λέγει κύριος