Flush-left = a main (independent) clause. Each dependent line begins directly
beneath the word it attaches to in the line above — the anchor word is dotted-underlined, and lights
up when you hover its dependent clause; each tag also names the attachment. A dashed border marks
verbless, elliptical, or suspended lines. Where a long sentence's staircase runs wider than the
page, the diagram scrolls sideways. (In print, or without JavaScript, lines fall back to stepped
indent columns.)
One Fate for All 9:1–3
v. 1 — thesis: the righteous and the wise are in God's hand; 'no one knows' whether love or hatred awaits them
1
For all this I laid to my heart,independent — כִּי links back to 8:16–17; the object אֶת כָּל זֶה is fronted; 'give to the heart' as in 1:13, 17
even to examine all this:purpose — infinitive וְלָבוּר of the rare root בּוּר; the LXX has instead 'and my heart saw all this' (καὶ καρδία μου … εἶδεν τοῦτο)
that the righteous and the wise and their deeds are in the hand of God.content — אֲשֶׁר as 'that'; עֲבָדֵיהֶם is an Aramaic-type noun 'deeds' found only here; 'in the hand of' = under God's control
Whether it is love or hatred,phrase modifier — fronted object of 'knows', with correlative גַּם … גַם; love // hatred, a merism of every possible disposition
no one knows;independent — formula 'no one knows' (אֵין יוֹדֵעַ הָאָדָם), picking up 8:17
everything lies before them.independent — verbless; 'before them' may mean 'still ahead of them' or 'open to them'
v. 2 — merism list: one fate for paired opposites (righteous // wicked, good [unpaired], clean // unclean, sacrificer // non-sacrificer), sealed by two equations (good = sinner, swearer = oath-fearer)
2
Everything is as it is for everyone:independent — terse verbless; the LXX has ματαιότης ἐν τοῖς πᾶσιν, 'vanity in all', apparently reading הֶבֶל for הַכֹּל
one fateindependent — מִקְרֶה אֶחָד, the keyword of 2:14–15 and 3:19; the list follows as its recipients
for the righteous and for the wicked,phrase modifier — list item 1: the moral pair
for the good,phrase modifier — list item 2, unpaired in MT; the LXX adds καὶ τῷ κακῷ, 'and for the evil'
and for the clean and for the unclean,phrase modifier — list item 3: the cultic pair
for the one who sacrifices and for the one who does not sacrifice.phrase modifier — list item 4: worship practised or neglected; אֵינֶנּוּ + participle
As is the good, so is the sinner;independent — equation כְּ … כְּ, 'the one like the other'
the one who swears is as the one who fears an oath.independent — the order flips: the blameworthy figure now comes first (chiasm with the preceding pairs)
v. 3 — evaluation: the one fate judged 'evil' under the sun, then a bleak anthropology ending in a verbless cry
3
This is an evilindependent — verbless verdict זֶה רָע
in allphrase modifier — the field of the verdict
that is done under the sun,relative — אֲשֶׁר + Niphal; refrain 'under the sun'
that there is one fate for all.content — epexegetic כִּי spelling out 'this'; מִקְרֶה אֶחָד again
Moreover the heart of the sons of man is full of evil,independent — וְגַם adds a second evil: the evil of fate // the evil of hearts (רָע repeated)
and madness is in their hearts while they live,independent — הוֹלֵלוֹת as in 1:17; 2:12
and after that — to the dead!independent — elliptical cry; the suffix of וְאַחֲרָיו ('after him / after it') is ambiguous
A Living Dog and a Dead Lion 9:4–6
v. 4 — the one advantage of the living (hope), grounded in a 'better … than' saying: the despised dog // the noble lion
4
For whoeverphrase modifier — casus pendens ('as for whoever'), picked up by the existential יֵשׁ
is joined to all the living,relative — Kethiv יבחר 'is chosen' and Qere יְחֻבַּר 'is joined' both stand in the text; the LXX κοινωνεῖ follows the Qere
there is hope;independent — יֵשׁ בִּטָּחוֹן; the noun is found elsewhere only in 2 Kgs 18:19 // Isa 36:4
for a living dog — it is bettercause — proverb: לְ of the topic + resumptive הוּא; the dog, the most despised of animals
than a dead lion.comparative — the 'than' member (מִן); the lion, king of beasts: any life outranks the grandest death
v. 5 — grounds: the living know // the dead know nothing (antithesis on יוֹדְעִים); wordplay reward // memory (שָׂכָר / זִכְרָם)
5
For the living knowcause — grounds the 'hope' of v. 4, ironically
that they will die,content — שֶׁ־ content clause: their one sure knowledge
but the dead know nothing at all,independent — disjunctive וְ + fronted subject: antithesis; אֵינָם + participle; מְאוּמָה
and they have no more reward,independent — וְאֵין עוֹד … שָׂכָר
for the memory of them is forgotten.cause — sound-play זִכְרָם / שָׂכָר; the forgetting of 1:11 and 2:16
v. 6 — the losses of the dead: love // hatred // jealousy (a triad with גַּם), and no 'portion' under the sun
6
Their love and their hatred and their jealousy have already perished,independent — triad marked by a thrice-repeated גַּם; love // hatred echo v. 1; כְּבָר + singular verb
and they have no longer any portion for everindependent — חֵלֶק, the allotted share (2:10; 3:22; 5:17–18), denied to the dead; v. 9 answers 'that is your portion'
in allphrase modifier — the sphere of the lost portion
that is done under the sun.relative — refrain 'under the sun', repeating v. 3a word for word
Eat, Drink, Rejoice, Work 9:7–10
vv. 7–10 — the carpe-diem charge: four commands, each with its motive (eat and drink → God has approved; garments // oil; enjoy life → it is your portion; do → there is no work in Sheol)
v. 7 — command 1: bread // wine, joy // glad heart, with its motive
7
Go, eat your bread with joy,independent — asyndetic imperatives לֵךְ אֱכֹל: the turn from observation to command
and drink your wine with a glad heart,independent — matches the first command: eat // drink, bread // wine
for God has already approved your works.cause — motive; כְבָר + רָצָה: joy as a gift God has already sanctioned
v. 8 — command 2: two jussives of festivity (white garments // oil on the head)
8
At all times let your garments be white,independent — jussive יִהְיוּ; white clothing for festal days. Siduri's counsel to Gilgamesh also pairs food, clean clothes, washing and a wife
and let oil not be lacking on your head.independent — jussive with אַל; anointing oil, the sign of gladness
v. 9 — command 3: 'see life' with a beloved wife, framed twice by 'the days of your הֶבֶל', and grounded in 'your portion'
9
Enjoy life with the womanindependent — רְאֵה חַיִּים, 'see life' = experience it
whom you loverelative — אֲשֶׁר + qatal
all the days of your vaporous lifephrase modifier — time frame; refrain הֶבֶל (חַיֵּי הֶבְלֶךָ): the gift held within transience
which he has given you under the sun,relative — God the unexpressed subject of נָתַן; refrain 'under the sun'
all your vaporous days;phrase modifier — the time frame said again in shorter form; refrain הֶבֶל a second time
for that is your portion in lifecause — motive; חֶלְקְךָ answers v. 6, where the dead have no portion
and in your toilphrase modifier — the second sphere of the portion
at which you toil under the sun.relative — cognate עָמָל … עָמֵל as in 1:3; refrain 'under the sun'
v. 10 — command 4: do with all your strength, because Sheol holds no work, reckoning, knowledge or wisdom (a list of four)
10
Whateverphrase modifier — fronted object (casus pendens) of the imperative
your hand finds to do,relative — 'the hand finds' = whatever lies within your power
do it with your might,independent — imperative עֲשֵׂה at the atnach; the LXX has ὡς ἡ δύναμίς σου, 'as your strength allows'
for there is no work or reckoning or knowledge or wisdom in Sheol,cause — motive: a list of four human capacities, all absent; שְׁאוֹל is named only here in the book
to which you are going.relative — אֲשֶׁר … שָׁמָּה with a resumptive adverb; participle הֹלֵךְ: you are already on the way
Time and Chance 9:11–12
v. 11 — observation formula ('I saw … under the sun') + a negated list: five expectations (לֹא … לְ) cancelled by one cause, 'time and chance'
11
Again I saw under the sunindependent — observation formula: שַׁבְתִּי וְרָאֹה ('I turned and saw', with the infinitive absolute carrying on the finite verb); refrain 'under the sun'
that the race is not to the swift,content — negated list, item 1: כִּי content clause with לֹא fronted
nor the battle to the mighty,content — item 2: וְלֹא
nor even bread to the wise,content — item 3: the series steps up to וְגַם לֹא; from physical strength to wisdom
nor riches to the discerning,content — item 4: וְגַם לֹא
nor favor to the knowledgeable;content — item 5, ending at the atnach
for time and chance happen to them all.cause — the single cause: עֵת וָפֶגַע, perhaps a hendiadys ('a time of mischance'); the verb יִקְרֶה echoes מִקְרֶה of vv. 2–3
v. 12 — 'no one knows' his time: a double simile (fish in a net // birds in a snare) applied to people (כָּהֵם, 'like them')
12
For moreover man does not know his time:cause — the 'no one knows' formula in the form לֹא יֵדַע הָאָדָם; עִתּוֹ, his time of calamity
like the fishcomparative — image 1
that are caught in an evil net,relative — late relative שֶׁ־ + Niphal participle; 'evil net'
and like the birdscomparative — image 2: fish // birds, water // air
caught in the snare,relative — article as relative on the participle הָאֲחֻזוֹת; the same root אחז as in the first image
so the sons of man are ensnaredindependent — the referent: כָּהֵם ('like them') takes up both images; Pual participle יוּקָשִׁים
at an evil time,phrase modifier — 'evil time' answers 'evil net'
when it falls upon them suddenly.conditional — temporal כְּשֶׁ־ + yiqtol; פִּתְאֹם, the unforeseen moment
The Poor Wise Man 9:13–18
v. 13 — the observation formula (רָאִיתִי) introducing an example story of wisdom
13
This also I saw as wisdom under the sun,independent — observation formula גַּם זֹה רָאִיתִי (זֹה, the late feminine demonstrative); refrain 'under the sun'
and it seemed great to me:independent — verbless: וּגְדוֹלָה הִיא אֵלַי
vv. 14–15 — the example story, told as narrative: setting (noun clauses), siege (three verbs), deliverance, forgetting; small // great, few // great
14
There was a small city,independent — asyndetic noun clause sets the scene
with few men in it;independent — circumstantial וְ + noun clause: small // few
and a great king came against itindependent — וּבָא: weqatal as a past narrative tense (late Hebrew); the small city set against the great king
and surrounded itindependent — וְסָבַב: the siege tightens
and built great siege-works against it.independent — מְצוֹדִים 'siege-works' echoes מְצוֹדָה 'net' (v. 12): the city is caught like the fish; 'great' repeated
15
And there was found in it a poor wise man,independent — impersonal וּמָצָא, 'one found'; poor yet wise: the paradox the story turns on
and he delivered the city by his wisdom;independent — וּמִלַּט הוּא; read here as what happened, though the perfect may be potential ('he could have delivered'); the LXX has a future, διασώσει
yet no one remembered that poor man.independent — disjunctive וְאָדָם לֹא: the ironic outcome; זָכַר echoes the forgotten memory (זִכְרָם) of v. 5; 'poor' repeated
v. 16 — the moral as a 'better … than' saying, at once qualified by antithesis (wisdom's worth // wisdom despised)
16
So I said,independent — reflective speech formula וְאָמַרְתִּי אָנִי
'Wisdom is bettercontent — טוֹבָה fronted, agreeing with the feminine חָכְמָה
than might';comparative — מִן of comparison; גְּבוּרָה recalls 'the mighty' of v. 11
but the wisdom of the poor man is despised,independent — the story qualifies the saying; passive participle בְּזוּיָה
and his words are not heard.independent — אֵינָם + participle; the poor man's unheard words
vv. 17–18 — two 'better … than' proverbs in A/B cola: quiet words // a shouting ruler; wisdom // weapons, then an antithetic sting (one sinner)
17
AThe words of the wise heard in quietnessindependent — comparative מִן with 'better' left unsaid; נִשְׁמָעִים answers 'not heard' in v. 16
Bare better than the shouting of a ruler among fools.comparative — the 'than' member: quiet // shouting, the wise // fools
18
AWisdom is betterindependent — the moral of the siege story
than weapons of war,comparative — מִכְּלֵי קְרָב: wisdom outranks the siege-works
Bbut one sinner destroys much good.independent — antithetic colon; wordplay טוֹבָה 'better' // טוֹבָה 'good'; leads into the dead flies of 10:1